10 ms·
Microsoft Tells FTC Repair Poses a Cyber Risk
- shmerl 7y agoAs usual, DRM proponents try to sell DRM as a security feature. In practice it's the opposite. DRM is the security risk.
- saagarjha 7y agoThis isn’t quite DRM.
- xoa 7y agoThis sort of of statement is one I made back in the lates 90s and early 00s. As an absolute statement it was wrong and still is wrong, and I think the enthusiast tech community's adoption of it has done a huge amount of harm. We reflexively opposed things like TPMs at all, rather then recognizing that the real question is who controls putting keys there. It would have been (and still would be) better to fight to make sure the standard is that the end people in charge of the device have the right to control the master keys on it. By going for a blanket "no chains of trust at all" we gave up a lot of useful capabilities and left the door open for companies to come in making use of them but with unpleasant and unnecessary extras tacked on.
- shmerl 7y agoTPM itself is neutral of course. Devices which are locked out from the user to control are already not. So when I refer to DRM, I refer to the later. Users should have the ability to break and remove DRM, that's the point of "right to repair".
- _emacsomancer_ 7y ago> This sort of of statement is one I made back in the lates 90s and early 00s. As an absolute statement it was wrong and still is wrong, and I think the enthusiast tech community's adoption of it has done a huge amount of harm. It's absolutely a correct statement from a user perspective.
- thefounder 7y agoRemember not to buy Microsoft if you have alternatives
- doggydogs94 7y agoYou forgot to include Apple in your do not buy list.
- close04 7y ago> If the TPM or other hardware or software protections were compromised by a malicious or unqualified repair vendor, those security protections would be rendered ineffective and consumers’ data and control of the device would be at risk Then make it so the consumer can always tell if the security became ineffective.
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoI'm getting Vista flashbacks.
- Avamander 7y agoIt's time we also remove the "Windows"-button (edit: the branded concept, not the physical button) from all the keyboards. We should have the right to repair in the form of also removing corporate advertising from our devices.
- alexkavon 7y agoCome again? The “Windows”-button is just a super/command key that exists on many other keyboards and OSes outside of Windows.
- Avamander 7y agoIt exists on many keyboards outside of Windows, but always has Windows's branding (except with macs basically). It's anticompetitive to force such branding.
- ansgri 7y agoAs I understand, it's only about removing the Win logo from the button, which is long due on officially Linux-supporting laptops.
- Mikeb85 7y agoYou can get little Linux themed stickers to cover the Windows logo. Also Linux distros use the button for things...
- Avamander 7y agoYou can use the button, but it shouldn't be "the Windows button", we should remove the branded concept.
- dbtx 7y agoI agree in principle, having scraped their logo off my former favorite keyboard, including the big one with "Designed for Windows 98" on the bottom. But I also remember that we can now buy dozens of gigabytes of RAM for much less than the GDP of a small country, partly because MS helped bring up and keep up the demand across decades, justifying so much R&D. Now that key's name is just an annoying side effect of the way history went, and it's not the one I choose to focus on anymore.
- deogeo 7y agoIs this the "new, open-source friendly" Microsoft?
- jackyinger 7y agoHeh, well just look at how open Open Compute is...
- patrick5415 7y agoSeriously. It’s hard to understand why Microsoft has been getting so much fanfare from the OS community recently.
- Avamander 7y agoThere has also been a lot of backslash but anti-Microsoft people are called tinfoil-hats and similar condescending stuff. Just like before PRISM all the people saying NSA surveilled everyone were called conspiracy theorists.
- mhh__ 7y agoNew generation of programmers, many of which would have been very young/not alive when Microsoft were at peak (anti-OSS)/EEE?
- giancarlostoro 7y agoI am "one of them" Microsoft still has some old corporate people still in charge versus some of the new projects which are not managed necessarily by the same groups. Until all these types leave it will feel like Microsoft is passive agressive.
- maxxxxx 7y agoBlame it on the "old people" but you soon you will see that "young people" will pull the same nonsense as soon as they have to hit quarterly numbers. Big companies can't be your friend.
- jensv 7y agoBought a Surface Pro 5th generation. Less than 8 months later the battery barely holds a charge. (<5 minutes) You're basically stuck because everything is glued together so you don't have any options other than to buy a brand new device. Feels a little like the forced Windows 10 updates. Good luck running Linux unless you are willing to live with all kinds of fail, due to poor camera support. In the end it was far easier to just switch over to a Thinkpad.
- no_wizard 7y agoThe one year warranty should have covered your surface I do support right to repair for the record. I just think this isn’t a great example of how the right to repair would have actually helped someone
- giancarlostoro 7y agoThe thing being asked for with the right to repair and why these companies are against it is that devices arent so convoluted you cannot repair them. We would see bigger devices that can be repaired because not everything is soldered together. At least thats what I remember reading a year ago. It would force companies to redesign their devices. Which is sensibly why they are against it all.
- no_wizard 7y agoIANL however my understanding of the legislation behind it boils down to: Right to repair essentially boils down to the product needs to be repairable in a reproducible way. It doesn’t state how that repair needs to be done or what exactly that means. The big one is for repair 𝙜𝙪𝙞𝙙𝙚𝙨 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙞𝙣𝙨𝙩𝙧𝙪𝙘𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣𝙨 and 𝙖𝙫𝙖𝙞𝙡𝙖𝙗𝙞𝙡𝙞𝙩𝙮 𝙤𝙛 𝙧𝙚𝙥𝙖𝙞𝙧 𝙥𝙖𝙧𝙩𝙨 is what is most important. So that a repair shop or savvy consumer could indeed do their repairs without push back from the manufacturer. It also means the specifications for those repairs and parts would be open(ish) Having to openly document repair procedure and have open part availability is what I think wrongly companies are attempting to protect. Because third parties could manufacturer spec compliant parts that wouldn't void the overall warranty of a product I think redesign is a non significant factor EDIT: I just want to note that in the right to repair debate product lifecycle planned obelesance is actually a legitimate argument for right to repair. I don't think devices are built to live longer then a product generations lifecycle (for instance, an iPhone has a typical generation lifecycle of 3-5 years I believe) Right to repair would reverse that trend at least somewhat
- gmueckl 7y agoIs there a way to replace board firmware with a hacked one that hides its alterations ny emularing ROM accesses? It could then also patch the secure boot checks out of the OS during system boot. Such a firmware would only be detectable by desoldering the flash chips and using a dedicated hardware reader. If that is the case, every computer could be fundamentally compromised if you left it out of sight for long enough.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou don't even have to replace the board firmware. You can just replace the board, or the entire device, with one that does whatever you want. Like emulate whatever the real device does until the user enters their PIN and then send it back to the attacker via wireless. There are a lot of different threat models here. The problem is that for the serious ones, like a state-level attacker, anything but continuous physical security is hopeless. But for the less serious ones, all of this faux spycraft is nothing but an excuse for anti-consumer behavior because the path of least resistance for your kids to get into your phone is by shoulder surfing your PIN, not using 0-days to install custom device firmware etc.
- ummonk 7y agoThe argument they're making is obviously true, both in theory and in fact (look up how Best Buy repair technicians act as informants for the government). >if Microsoft wants to make devices that nobody can service and repair without breaking their security model, they’re entitled to do that. They can make Surface Pros so hardened and tamper proof that merely opening them will destroy them. >What they can’t do is make devices that are repairable, and then lock out everyone but their own service technicians. There is no distinction here. The tamper proofing is what locks out everyone but their own service technicians.
- deogeo 7y agoThey could also make them merely tamper-evident. There's plenty of ways to allow device owners to unlock their own devices, without also letting others do so. Manufacturers just aren't interested in that, and are all to happy to lie and claim it's impossible.
- saagarjha 7y ago> There's plenty of ways to allow device owners to unlock their own devices, without also letting others do so. Such as?
- deogeo 7y agoThe mentioned tamper-evident-ness. E.g. the device can display at boot time a warning if any changes were made, or if keys were added to the trusted list. Adding extra keys can easily be locked behind a password that the owner can change. Note that this is not hypothetical - lots of unlockable Android phones will display a warning that they were rooted on boot.
- danShumway 7y agoMy Android phone checks software integrity on boot, but I can override it if I want to install a custom ROM. The setting can only be changed from within the OS, so an attacker or service technician can't do it without my permission. Some[0] Android phones even allow you to re-lock the bootloader afterwards by replacing the chain of trust, so as far as I know there's no technical reason why we couldn't have the best of both worlds. [0]: But not all of them. Don't blindly re-lock your bootloader unless you know for certain that your phone supports it, or you'll risk basically bricking your device.
- sorval 7y agoAh, Theres the old Steve Balmer Microsoft we all know and love.
- skc 7y agoSo, about the same as the Steve Jobs Apple then?
- userbinator 7y agoTo be fair, Steve's Microsoft wasn't the one that introduced and popularised invasive telemetry, "treat the user like an idiot" design (including things like forced updates), nor the feverish desire to lock down the PC platform in the name of "security", but it may have just been a matter of time.
- Fnoord 7y agoFor those who thought Microsoft was an alternative to Apple with regards to right to repair: think again. The mid-range and high-end HP laptops (not Lenovo) are the easiest serviceable these days.
- siphon22 7y agoI use a hp elitebook 8470p i got for 100 usd from some guys garage and it is simply amazing. No screws, not even one to get the bottom cover off! You just slide it off and bam, your cpu/heatsink, fan, ram, and hdd are accessible on pretty much the same layer.
- jammygit 7y agoMy wife had a hp once that had the thermal paste dry up. To fix it would have required taking apart everything from the keyboard to the monitor clips, top and bottom. We just bought a new laptop.
- Fnoord 7y agoThere are some sweet spots of old laptops which are serviceable. Some are even Macs. There's also some which have an Intel ME which can be disabled. Some are even x86-64. Its getting less common though.
- no_wizard 7y agoSo you mean HP isn't an alternative?
- Reelin 7y agoI was also quite impressed by the construction of Dell's 2-in-1 devices.
- _emacsomancer_ 7y agoLenovo ThinkPads at least up to the --30 generation are very repairable/user-serviceable, more so than HPs. And, unfortunately, at least for certain purposes, X230s/T430s are the most recent reasonable laptops anyway: after that it's currently impossible to replace any of the Intel/AMD firmware with something inspectable.
- xoa 7y agoMicrosoft isn't entirely wrong, and "right to repair" advocates conspicuous failure to acknowledge this tradeoff is one of the weaker and more irritating parts of the movement. Note tradeoff as the word, it's not as if good things don't come with it too, nor does it mean the same weighting applies to everyone. It doesn't mean that those who want to shouldn't be able to hack on their devices. A similar tradeoff applies to pure software signing, where I am very much in favor of a legal requirement that hardware "possessors" [1] should be able to load their own master signing keys into any cryptographic roots of trust, and thus be able to run software of their choice with no further relationship with the manufacturer even in a system that has full signing required. But the power to do that is also the power to screw it up. If any 3rd party can repair something like biometric hardware, any 3rd party could also compromise said hardware. Some people may find the benefits of the former outweigh the latter, but I do think it should be a choice in the law, and that liability should adjust accordingly. Ie., you can upfront on buying a device request that it not enforce cryptographic reqs for hardware repairs (this could be controlled by a permanent fuse or many other ways), but alternately you can also request that continue to be a requirement. In my case for example I do not want to buy an iPhone that is "right to repair enabled". I don't want the magic circle of who can mess with it expanded any further than the minimum, which is Apple themselves who are by definition inside the tent anyway. I also think the "right to repair" movement is a symptom rather then cause thing, and obscures the real problem for the vast majority of the market. The true core issue is that, in America in particular, legal standards for fitness for purpose are simply way, way too loose. The reasonable expectation most people have for buying something expensive is that it'll be in working order for a proportionate number of years. Not forever of course, but a $200-400+ bit of electronics shouldn't be dead in 13 months either. A $500-1k one should probably last at least 4-5 years without further cost, etc. The retail price should reflect whatever it takes to make that happen. Manufacturers are the ones in a position to deal with that, who have the best stats on failure rates, and can make decisions about tradeoffs between cheapness of repairs, more on QA, where more expensive repair reqs might reduce repair need even farther in the first place (or provide other feature value), etc. It simply shouldn't be the consumers' problem at all, beyond evaluating the retail price. Yet it's completely standard to have something ludicrous like a single year warranty. Essentially, it's a classic market Externality problem. Everyone does expect their devices to last, but are forced to roll the dice on whether they specifically have bad luck and have to pay expensive rare repairs all by themselves. The manufacturer gets to advertise an artificially low price but externalizing the failure rate percentage onto the customers, and even charge extra for what should be standard. Instead warranties should be adaptive, something like "1 month for every $12 retail price up to a maximum of 5 years" say. Then let the market sort it out from there. I'm worried "right to repair" will ultimately be camouflage that let manufacturers skip out on their real responsibilities in some cases. Right to repair could make out of warranty repairs cheaper, but you shouldn't have to pay at all within a reasonable normal life. ---- 1: which would be defined as something alone the lines of "anyone who has paid, either upfront or on an ongoing plan basis, for hardware and possesses the right to control access to it." Lawyers could make it watertight, but basically a definition which would explicitly not allow any sort of "oh we were only leasing it to them!" loopholes.
- awinter-py 7y agoTechnology needs an immune system. 'Tamper evident' is the right approach, but achieving this in a way that consumers can use is hard and requires building blocks that don't exist yet. How can you verify that the motherboard you sent out is the one you get back and it doesn't have extra hardware inside the case? msft isn't wrong that creating a trusted supply chain for hardware is difficult, but I think that 'how can I trust the repair shop' and 'how can I trust MS' are the same problem.
- devoply 7y agoThe real threat is not tampering, the real threat is from the manufacturer and the corporations that already have keys to the data kingdom and control the entire stack. I have yet to hear of a single case of hardware tampering as software tampering is much much easier and infinitely more effective... and even if hardware tampering happens it's an extreme edge case and almost irrelevant.
- solotronics 7y agoThis kind of blurs the line between hardware and software but there have been recent attacks where groups have written attack firmwares to motherboards and hard drives of cloud computing baremetal servers.
- stcredzero 7y agoIt's still software. It's just software that most application programmers ignore by inclination.
- stcredzero 7y agoAre there known cases of hardware tampering exploits, and how many of them are done by state actors as opposed to private ones? Also, how many of the known cases are indeterminate in that way? (state vs private) Restricting the public access to hardware will encourage more state hardware tampering.
- 7y ago
- olliej 7y agoGod I hate this argument (even when I worked at Apple). There are many valid (eg remotely plausible) reasons, but “haxors cybering your security” is not one of them. [autocorrect wanted to change haxors to hackers. I’m not sure if that’s good or not)
- olliej 7y agoPeople seem to hate this comment. Here's what I mean by plausible: "If we filled it entirely with resin and glue it is less likely to break and hence less likely to need repair, but doing that makes repair impossible" I do not mean good reasons, I am specifically saying that there are "reasons" that are more plausible than "security"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- orthoxerox 7y agoWhat about Tesla? IIRC they also prevent owners and third parties from working on their cars.
- cameronbrown 7y agoI can understand the rationale that modified software could be a major danger in their cars.
- userbinator 7y agoWe've had modified cars and the associated culture for over a century, and no major danger has arisen from it (no more than the usual attributed to bad drivers, anyway.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cameronbrown 7y agoMechanics are not software engineers. Now I do believe we should be able to modify the software, but the infrastructure is not there right now.
- guitarbill 7y agothe batteries are fairly new technology though and do pose a serious hazard. i have no doubt as the field matures it'll become safer though, with established procedures. glad to see people like Rich Benoit are blazing the trail already.
- Sendotsh 7y agoAre the battery packs really more dangerous than playing with nitrous injection or race fuel? I don’t need any certifications or permission to do either of those in my shed.
- 7y ago
- userbinator 7y agoRight to repair is just one of the many cases of "security" being used as an excuse to take away freedom, and it's one of the ways the corporations and governments (nearly the same thing, really) gradually build their dystopian vision of complete control over the population. It's so alluring, because "who doesn't want to be safe and secure?" On the surface it's appealing, but if you think about it, much like "a world without (cyber)crime", the ultimate result of striving for perfect security is dystopia. Then, much as perfect freedom is unattainable, so is perfect security; and I think it's time we rebelled against this desire to achieve it. Unfortunately, it seems desiring any sort of security is only going to give the companies more leverage to use it against us, so the way to go is to reject completely their notion of (centralised, authoritarian) security, and make freedom the highest priority. Insecurity is freedom, and that is what we should fight for. That infamous Benjamin Franklin quote has really taken on a deeper meaning recently.
- whatshisface 7y agoSecurity against institutions is just as important as security against individuals, because big institutions aren't any more moral than the average individual. Everyone thinks about security against criminals, but the reason we don't live in a third world dictatorship is our constitutionally enshrined security against the police.
- danShumway 7y ago> Security against institutions is just as important as security against individuals This is very well phrased. It gets across something I was having trouble putting into words -- that security and freedom aren't always just opposite goals that conflict with each other. Freedom isn't an ideal, it's a practical system designed to guard against tangible harms.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Reelin 7y agoI want perfect security, but I don't want perfect "security". Please allow me to explain. I find it particularly frustrating that in conversations about security it's difficult to differentiate between the different uses of the word. There's user security against other users (same system), criminals (remote), criminals (physical access), large entities (ie governments and corporations), and probably a few others. Then there's owner (or admin?) security, for example IT vs employees who do dumb things and other similar scenarios. There's also vendor security against user control of devices. Sometimes this is to protect a walled garden, but other times it's just a cheap way to prevent damage to their brand if clueless users do dumb things and then publicly blame the company for their own negligence. Arguably the first category (user security) is a good thing, but those designing the devices fall almost exclusively into the second two (I would argue mostly bad) categories.
- doggydogs94 7y agoI see no difference between Microsoft’s position and that of Apple. Except that Apple is a trendy brand.
- karmakaze 7y agoYes they're both on the wrong side of right to repair.
- yarrel 7y agoMicrosoft love Open Source. User freedom, not so much.