4 ms·
The data rate from the surface of titan is abysmal. Even with a relay, we won't get much video, but man, I hope we get some.
by jvanderbot 7y ago
The data rate from the surface of titan is abysmal. Even with a relay, we won't get much video, but man, I hope we get some.
- maxxxxx 7y agoNo 4K flyovers for Instagram?
- jvanderbot 7y agoI mean sure, eventually, over many down link cycles. But not real time.
- spullara 7y agoSpace travel just makes it utterly clear there is on such thing as real time. Computing is constantly running up against the speed of light.
- aeorgnoieang 7y agoIn a sense tho, at-the-speed-of-light is real time, as it's the maximum speed of anything.
- pault 7y agoIf, as clock A nears the speed of light it appears that stationary clock B is slowing down, doesn't that mean that at the speed of light is no time? Does a photon in a vacuum arrive instantly at its destination? If a photon looks at another photon, does the other photon appear not to be moving at all, or... Ouch my brain.
- sq_ 7y agoNot completely related, but you reminded me of something interesting I remember hearing about neutrinos. Apparently (HN physicists please correct me if I'm wrong), neutrinos have an extraordinarily tiny objective lifetime, and the only reason we can detect them is that, because they travel so close to the speed of light, they experience almost no passage of time in while in flight.
- aeorgnoieang 7y ago> If, as clock A nears the speed of light it appears that stationary clock B is slowing down, doesn't that mean that at the speed of light is no time? If clock A could reach the speed of light (which it can't), then, yes, clock B would appear to be 'frozen in time'. > Does a photon in a vacuum arrive instantly at its destination? From the perspective of any possible observer, no, it always appears to be traveling at the speed of light. If an observer could travel at the speed of light (which it can't), then, yes, it would appear as if it arrived instantly in the sense that clocks at both its source and destination would appear to be not running at all. > If a photon looks at another photon, does the other photon appear not to be moving at all, or... Ouch my brain. Yeah, this is tricky. Photons can't look or see – what could that mean as looking/seeing involves detecting photons (or, in the sense that something like echolocation is 'seeing', detecting a pattern of matter, e.g. sound)? In a sense, not moving at all or both moving at the same maximum speed don't seem to be much different, from the 'perspective' of a photon. Somewhat related, this video describes how, if one could travel on a vehicle that could accelerate at a constant rate continuously for decades, one would eventually see the cosmic microwave background radiation as a rainbow ring because traveling closer and closer to the speed of light would shift the apparent frequency of the radiation first into the visible spectrum (and then beyond it).
- pault 7y agoMy comment was mostly tongue in cheek, I know photons don't have eyes. :)
- jvanderbot 7y agoIt's not about latency, it's about power required to transmit. From far away, you need to push lots of power through to get a readable signal on the receiver side. It's kinda-sorta like seeing a flashlight.
- johnhenry 7y agoDon't get your hopes down! It's still very possible that we'll get some good, if not real-time, video out of this!
- jvanderbot 7y agoAh, we likely will not get real time video. Maybe APL has some tricks I'm not privy to. Source: I asked a DSN coms engineer.
- swebs 7y agoThere will be at least an hour delay. Saturn is pretty far
- bdamm 7y ago10 seconds of video from Titan would change the world. It's shame we don't have this from Mars already. So it would take a few weeks to transmit - we got time. Now figuring out which 10 seconds to select and send to earth... that'll be interesting. An on-board cache of x GB data storage, with key frames taken every 30 minutes, would probably be able to select some pretty compelling 10 second segments.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoWhat about the world would be different after getting a 10 second video from Titan?
- cheerlessbog 7y agoIt would be inspiring for me at least.(Assuming something was moving)
- andygates 7y agoSend them all, just pick a likely-nice one for sending while the eyes of the world are on Mission Control. Caching everything then sending it at leisure is working nicely for New Horizons.
- T-hawk 7y agoFrom a scientific standpoint, there's really no value in downlinking video as opposed to still images. It costs several multiples worth of scarce downlink bandwidth, for a tiny gain in what there is to see of the same rocks at slightly different angles. Same reason we didn't have New Horizons at Pluto or the various Mars rovers do any video.
- martinald 7y agoWhy is bandwidth so scare still? Satellites in geosynchronous orbit on earth can do terabit/sec of total capacity now. Obviously latency is going to be extremely high, but I can't really understand why data rates are still so low?
- jvanderbot 7y ago"one over r-squared" Latency is high, but the power you have to pump through an antenna / laser to get enough watts on the receiver goes up really fast with distance. Here's a summary that touches on it if you'd like to learn more: http://www.qrg.northwestern.edu/projects/vss/docs/Communications/2-why-does-data-transfer-rate-drop-with-distance.html http://www.qrg.northwestern.edu/projects/vss/docs/Communicat... And here's a detailed derivation for voyager. https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/24338/how-to-calculate-data-rate-of-voyager-1 https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/24338/how-to-calcu...
- SomeHacker44 7y agoLow transmit power. Long distance. Very low SNR at receiver.
- pdonis 7y agoBecause the signals have to travel so much farther and are so much weaker when they arrive. It's amazing that any data at all can be extracted from a radio signal that travels a billion miles.
- zild3d 7y agoInverse square law. For the same transmit power, your received signal strength diminishes with the square of the distance That received signal strength is what determines channel capacity (C) which is the upper limit on the bit rate you can get. see Friis and Shannon's channel capacity [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friis_transmission_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friis_transmission_equation [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theore...