3 ms·
So oil tankers can apparently carry some 300000 tons. Three or four oil tankers full would then be enough storage space for the onsite water. Couldn't we fill s
by adrianN 7y ago
So oil tankers can apparently carry some 300000 tons. Three or four oil tankers full would then be enough storage space for the onsite water. Couldn't we fill some tankers and have them release the water far away from any fishing grounds?
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI wondered that myself. I think the problem is that they first need to dilute it considerably before releasing it. If they do that before loading it onto the ship it might take too many journeys to empty the tanks. If they do it onboard the ship the you've got a ship full of radioactive water sailing about. I'm not sure how hazardous the water is but you might struggle to find people willing to sail on it.
- adrianN 7y agoTritium is quite weakly radioactive. It is effectively shielded by a few millimeters of air. As long as the crew doesn't drink the cargo they should be pretty save.
- marcosdumay 7y agoEvaporation may make it hard to insulate the crew from the cargo.
- adrianN 7y agoEvaporations from crude oil are probably more dangerous so I assume that oil tankers are equipped for this.
- m4rtink 7y agoMaybe just get an older tanker and sink it over the destination ? If you make holes big enough in the process it should take care of both dilution & the contaminated vessel. It worked fine for ships full of chemical weapons in the past, so should be able to work in this case as well. :)
- VBprogrammer 7y agoThe tanks that they are containing the water in at the moment could be made to float with some bladders and towed out. Maybe we've cracked it :)
- gnode 7y agoThis was my thought also, although it may not be trivial to just hire an oil tanker to transport radioactive water. Before dilution, there may be a significant risk of contamination to the vessel and crew. You'd probably need a special vessel, specifically designed to handle radioactive fluids. Even if an oil tanker is technically adequate, there's likely some costly certification / approval that would need to be done. All the handling involved would also introduce risks, and is probably more cheaply and safely achieved on land. That said, there's a political aspect to this, and maybe the perception of disposing of the water far away from Fukushima justifies the scientifically unnecessary added complexity.
- pvaldes 7y ago> it may not be trivial to just hire an oil tanker to transport radioactive water I bet that this is not even legal, for good reasons
- knodi123 7y agoI get what you're saying, but I also can't help but chuckle at the fact that you're practically quoting the old "We'll just tow it until it's beyond the environment" skit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3m5qxZm_JqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3m5qxZm_JqM
- bitL 7y ago...and damage some preserved ecosystem in the process. Great idea!
- adrianN 7y agoThe article made it sound like the water is mostly harmless and Sellafield dumps orders of magnitude more into the sea without dramatic effects.
- gnode 7y agoThe same release from a vessel in open water is less likely to damage an ecosystem than release from the shoreline. That said, if it's diluted enough and released over a long enough period of time, it's unlikely to make much difference.
- pvaldes 7y agoNot!. Is just the opposite. Coastal ecosystems are much more resilient than deep water ecosystems! They evolved to stand changes. We must stop thinking in the ocean as just a lot of water. This way of thinking is suicidal.
- tru3_power 7y agoThat brings up a good point. There are a few nuclear zones that no one lives in right (Chernobyl came to mind after watching that hbo show)? Why don’t we at-least get some value out of of these sad situations and convert one to a nuclear disposal site?
- m4rtink 7y agoIIRC this is already happening in Chernobyl - other than all the wildlife preservation & tourism there is a big solar power plant being built: https://phys.org/news/2018-10-chernobyl-life-solar-power.html https://phys.org/news/2018-10-chernobyl-life-solar-power.htm... The article says they aim for up to 100 MWe capacity in the future, which would be nice, yet still illustrates how very powerful nuclear reactors are, with each of the 4 now inactive Chernobyl blocks producing 1000 MWe (and 3x times as much heat!).
- imchillyb 7y ago> ...Couldn't we fill some tankers and have them release the water... @adrianN 1st) Who is this /we/ you speak of? 2nd) Who's tankers are you suggesting /we/ utilize? 3rd) Who is the governing authority here that is in charge of the WE, the VESSELS, and the area of release? Who's backyard does this take place in? How much compensation is being offered for these privately owned tankers that will be permanently damaged by the radioactive waste being carried? Who is paying the wage and medical bills for the crews that are crewing said vessels? Where does this labor come from in the first place? Who is safety training these laborers in the proper use of protective gear, proper disposal procedures for contaminated gear, etc... Finally, where the hell is this highly-contaminated water going to be released and or stored? Most importantly, who the hell is going to pay for all of what you've suggested? _____ I sure as hell am not going to pay for it. TEPCO sure as hell isn't going to pay for it. Japan sure as hell isn't going to pay for it. SO, I ask again, who's footing the bill for this immensely complex and expensive process?
- pvaldes 7y agoHiding the problem under the rug. The sucessful human way of choice to manage radiation since the simpsons' first season Water currents would return it to home, or to somebody's home or kitchen. Fishes migrate also.
- Lazare 7y agoThat's not how it works. It's dilute enough it's safe to just dump it on the coast already; dumping it at sea would just be a big PR production to make it appear even safer. There's no risk of "water currents causing it to return home". That's not even something that is physically possible.
- pvaldes 7y ago> That's not even something that is physically possible. Water currents move water masses, travel in closed loops and obey the laws of physics. Claiming that is not even physically possible that the same water pass two times by a point is an overstatement. Can be unprobable, but is perfectly possible with enough time. Water in Fukushima travels to California and Alaska and then returns again to Japan, and then returns to USA in an endless loop. That's how it works. Ask an oceanographer. Water masses with their own collection of animals and plants are traced far away of their point of origin. Is not a secret at all.