4 ms·
Wayland is literally never going to be ready unless it’s forced to be. How long has Nvidia promised to support it now, and still unless you’re using Nouveau it’
by jchw 7y ago
Wayland is literally never going to be ready unless it’s forced to be. How long has Nvidia promised to support it now, and still unless you’re using Nouveau it’s basically not usable on Nvidia cards.
- eropple 7y agoIs that still the case? I'm running FC29 with the nVidia closed-source drivers and I haven't had issues. (I have had issues on a laptop with switchable graphics, though, and Nouveau was the solution there.)
- jchw 7y agoIs this new? Last time I tried, Nvidia on Wayland had performance issues and did not support Optimus at all (Edit: after rereading what you said I am guessing that is still an issue.) If it is working though I retract what I said, though it’s absurd how long it took to happen.
- saltcured 7y agoEven without wayland, in recent Fedora releases (I forget if it started with 28 or 29), I've found optimus switchable graphics to be impossible or at least impractical to configure. What's become easier is having the entire X display use the nvidia gpu, with the intel gpu transparently slaved to relay pixels to its connected laptop display. But, it does return the annoying, periodic driver breakage, where a dnf update replaces the xorg-x11-drv-nvidia RPMs and suddenly the userspace is incompatible with the still-running kernel module's slightly older API, so new processes cannot use opengl until I reboot. This was one benefit of optimus via the optirun infrastructure. The main desktop was on the intel gpu and I could actually unload and upgrade the nvidia module if desired, without forcing a disruptive reboot.
- Iolaum 7y agoDo you have any documentation, or even random notes, on how you set that up? I have an optimus laptop and couldn't make the proprietary drivers work ( tried both rpmfusion and negativo17). I m happily using nouveau for now but at some point I ll need to use CUDA again.
- saltcured 7y agoI have an older Thinkpad T440p with Geforce GT 730M running Fedora 29. I use the MATE desktop rather than GNOME. I just installed the akmod-nvidia packages from rpmfusion which also pulls in xorg-x11-drv-nvidia and xorg-x11-drv-nvidia-cuda. Search for "PRIME" discussions in the README.txt under /usr/share/doc/xorg-x11-drv-nvidia. I cannot be sure every bit of my config is still necessary, as I left it alone once I got it working. First, I have /etc/X11/xorg.conf.d/nvidia-prime.conf with a small amount of config: Section "Module" Load "modesetting" EndSection Section "Device" Identifier "nvidia" Driver "nvidia" Option "AllowEmptyInitialConfiguration" EndSection Then, I created a custom script in /etc/lightdm/display_setup.sh: #!/bin/sh if rpm -q xorg-x11-drv-nvidia \ && lsmod | grep '^nvidia' ' then xrandr --setprovideroutputsource modesetting NVIDIA-0 xrandr --auto xrandr --output eDP-1-1 --set "PRIME Synchronization" 1 fi And in my /etc/lightdm/lightdm.conf I added one line to call that script: ... [Seat:*] ... display-setup-script=/etc/lightdm/display_setup.sh To be honest, my old GPU is too slow and with too small RAM to be worthwhile for OpenCL. I find it more practical to just use the Intel OpenCL runtime for multi-core CPUs on this old quad-core laptop or on newer workstations. I do get some use out of xorg-x11-drv-nvidia-cuda on a Titan X desktop GPU though.
- Iolaum 7y agoThanks a lot! I 've already created a thread about my problems in askfedora, made a last post there now linking to your post here in case they help somebody else. https://ask.fedoraproject.org/t/black-screen-after-installing-negativo17-nvidia-drivers-on-optimus-laptop/1967/8?u=iolaum https://ask.fedoraproject.org/t/black-screen-after-installin... I 'll try your notes when I have enough free time to re-install if things go bad.
- shrimp_emoji 7y agoWhy is your standard for a Linux desktop renderer whether a pretty Linux-hostile company's niche laptop energy saving hybrid GPU driver works well on it?
- jammygit 7y agoThat isn’t waylands fault, it’s the closed source third parties
- reidrac 7y agoThat was the same argument gnome 3 used when it wasn't working in my Nvidia GPU: the driver is buggy, not our fault. This is very hard to explain to your users, because there's nothing they can do. So yes, it really doesn't matter too much why if the software doesn't work. I don't mind X until Wayland is ready for all.
- Tharkun 7y agoThat's been the argument for every Linux problem for at least as long as I've been using Linux. WiFi drivers used to suck. To the point that you had to be careful which WiFi card (yes, card) you bought, because only a couple of models worked on Linux at all. This situation took an extremely long time to get better. The same thing happened (and is still happening) with graphics cards. But at least most of them sort of work, instead of outright failing. As long as enough consumers don't actively demand decent Linux (or BSD, whatever) support, it will never come. I'd suggest voting with your wallets, but with the laptop market being the steaming pile of shit that it is, that's virtually impossible. The year of the Linux desktop...just like fusion power, is always just around the corner.
- komali2 7y agoSometimes manufacturers lie to us, though. Like the Thinkpad x1 Carbon was supposed to be "linux-ready," and then it ships with sleep functionality broken for a couple months until they managed to get a BIOS fix through. I tried to vote with my wallet, but this is what Linux is like /shrug
- shmerl 7y agoIt's actually easy to explain - ditch Nvidia, they aren't supporting Linux properly. Pretty clear message, and users either get it and ditch it, and if not, nothing you could do to help them. It's totally Nvidia's fault.