3 ms·
This has relevance to the magic of AI and the disenchantment feeling when we understand it. What we need is Feynman's enchantment at integrating scientific und
by dr_dshiv 7y ago
This has relevance to the magic of AI and the disenchantment feeling when we understand it.
What we need is Feynman's enchantment at integrating scientific understanding with awe, where they aren't in opposition. Where learning the biology of a rose can enhance appreciation.
E.g., "Wow, such a simple algorithm can create intelligent outcomes"
- api 7y agoIt really is a genuine mystery why mystery creates a sense of awe and why learning for many people leads to cynicism. Maybe we are driven toward learning via an emotional mechanism that draws us to the unknown and gives it a "sparkle" or "allure" similar to how sex drive works. Once we learn that mechanism turns off, again similar to how the sexual allure lessens after orgasm.
- vinceguidry 7y agoIt offers a heady sense of power and control, even though you intuitively know there's always a catch. If you want to be powerful like a genie, you have to learn to live in a lamp and do the bidding of whatever random a-hole figures out they have to rub it. The unknown is glamorous, and indeed an old word for magical spells was glamour. The disenchantment that results from actually learning how the spells work is the revelation that nothing truly offers infinite power, not even magic. Wisdom is the discovery that a world without magic, as much disillusionment as that might save people, is also a world without wonder. Children would stop getting impressed by dinosaurs once we start cloning them and putting them everywhere. Any wonder that's ubiquitous is by definition no longer wondrous
- rjf72 7y agoEvolutionary imperative would be a very simple explanation. The Sentinelese [1] are probably the best example here. They are a group of people that "we" have tried to make contact with numerous times, including with the offering of gifts. The Sentinelese have responded by, for the most part, trying to kill the visitors and occasionally succeeding. But the most interesting thing about this people is how incredibly primitive they are in other ways. They literally have not yet learned how to make fire. Instead when a lightning bolt catches something on fire, they have been observed guarding and trying to keep the fire going for as long as possible. And they have no knowledge of agriculture either. The point of this is that if at some point people were sufficiently awed or contented by discovered technology your society would start to reach a point where it would simply freeze in time. Instead this instinct we have to assimilate, absorb, bore, and repeat - to no end, is something that seems likely a factor in our (as of yet) never ending drive to develop, expand, and grow. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentinelese https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentinelese
- im_down_w_otp 7y agoIn the tech industry it doesn't feel to me like we're erring toward disenchantment. If anything, it feels like we're imbuing enormous numbers of mundane things with magical properties and cult-like followings to go along with them. There's a massive ecosystem of merkle trees which are purportedly going to completely transform humanity through how we transact payments. There are multiple glamorous conferences, dedicated to banal things like process schedulers, that an outsider could easily mistake for Sunday Mass at a megachurch. Furnished with altars reserved for an evangelizing priesthood sermonizing the congregation. We sometimes even live stream them too! Contrasted against being disenchanted, we're constantly generating enormous amounts of enthusiasm about what we do, why we do it, and even every nook & cranny of how we do it. I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing, but it does stand in sharp contrast to the idea that we're wallowing in disenchantment.
- bartcobain 7y agoWhat a way to look at things. I agree with you. Also, that makes me think that there's even the term "evangelist" used in the tech talks...
- vinceguidry 7y agoThe central definition of magic at use here is that an act is magical to the extent that control is removed from causation. Something went my way, but I didn't directly do anything in order to make it happen, and there's no rational way to ascertain how. It's as if I waved my hands and my will just manifested. The key is that behind every act of magic is a hidden jungle of complexity that the magical practitioner must master. A wizard masters arcane correspondences, which largely involve study of magical law, which is a rational domain divorced from human intention. If you mumble the words right and have just the right slice of frog lips, then your fireball goes boom. Or your code has to pass the syntax checker before it can get on with semantic evaluation. A priest masters the domain of human emotion and feeling, learning how to harness these things to earn mastery over divine power. If enough people believe a thing to be true, the truth manifests, called by a higher power into physical expression in the world. Or your startup manages to find funding because YC gave you their stamp of orthodox approval. You can't dispel magic because that means that there's no longer any complicated domain that we fail to understand but will pay dearly for a guide through it. Any time you have that, the emergent property of people willing to front-load time and effort for later riches and the dramatic flair for making it all look easy will manifest.