3 ms·
> Google's OAuth APIs have been around for years as a way for apps to get access to and control your Google data. A third-party email app, for instance, would w
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
> Google's OAuth APIs have been around for years as a way for apps to get access to and control your Google data. A third-party email app, for instance, would want access to your Gmail account and the ability to send, read, and delete emails so it could control everything remotely. An IM app might just want access to your contacts and profile picture. For years this was purely an agreement between the user and the developer—the app would say what it wanted access to, and the user could deny or allow it.
Yeah, until the Cambridge Analytica scandal revealed that agreements like this aren't sufficient to protect user data. I think Google's making the only acceptable tradeoff here.
- mhandley 7y agoAnd for European users under GDPR, maybe the only legal tradeoff too.
- anoncake 7y agoWhat makes you think that the GDPR, which is designed to give users control over their data, makes it illegal to give users control over their data?
- mhandley 7y agoUnder GDPR, Google can only use your data for the uses you have given permission for. This includes not handing it to other companies (via their API or otherwise) for any other uses.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAll they'd need to do is give me a way to grant them permission to share this data, and add that other company to their who-we-share-with list for my account. (Also I guess they're already doing that, because the API isn't being killed off, it's being restricted to companies that threw a couple dozen kilodollars into a Google-approved bonfire.)
- quotemstr 7y agoI think that prohibiting user authorization of data access is throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I approve of privacy, but at the end of the day, my data is my data, and part of data ownership is having the freedom to share my data with whomever I choose.
- sha666sum 7y agoThat sounds nice in theory, but even as a highly technical user, I don't have any knowledge about what information apps actually gather about me.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI think that's not the right way to look at it. You can still get copies of all your data, and share them with whoever you want however you want. The only thing Google's restricting is the ability to set up a seamless interface, because the lack of seams often tricks people into trusting third parties more than they should.
- quotemstr 7y agoI'm not a fan of this recently-popular form of argument: "we're not banning X: we're just adding friction, so your arguments predicated on banning X are invalid". Support for a thing is continuous, not discrete. It ranges from full endorsement on one end of the spectrum to a total unrelenting ban on the other. The arguments against banning X also apply to adding friction to X, just to a lesser extent depending on how much friction we're talking about. If it didn't, you could defacto ban things by making them arbitratily difficult. I still think there's a data sovereignty argument against the move we're discussing on this thread. That it's just friction makes the move less bad, but I think it's still bad.