6 ms·
Well... At least now we can honestly say the system is still as vulnerable to being rigged as it was before. I'm honestly at a loss for words. EDIT: Words n
by salawat 7y ago
Well...
At least now we can honestly say the system is still as vulnerable to being rigged as it was before.
I'm honestly at a loss for words.
EDIT: Words no longer 404ing.
It appears the Court is not satisfied with the State's criteria/legal reasoning to justify justicable action against the districting plans. They hold the measure must be politically neutral, and have some basis in being legally addressed.
They go at length to describe circumstances to describe cases with inherent justicability (districting along racial demographics), but offer no hints or grasps as to a measure of degree at which political gerrymandering becomes "excessive".
It looks like Maryland attempted to use "likelihood of persistence" of the gerrymandered district, but this was dismissed on allowability based on previous precedent. "Intent" was also singled out in a couple different wordings, but did not hold satisfactorally for the Court.
Of particular concern was of the Federal Courts to support State Court's particular measures on what constitutes excessive gerrymandering. It seems the Court is nudging State populations to appeal to the Federal Legislature to oversee malconduct in individual State districting. I find this concerning, seeing as our Federal Legislature has enough on it's plate with getting things passed, and the last thing we want is to start having the different levels trying to micromanage each other.
I can sort of see some tiny speck of Wisdom in their judgement. I don't necessarily find it satisfying, but I have to grudgingly admit they at least reasoned it out.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoConstitutional amendment
- CameronNemo 7y ago34 senators are represented by less than 8% of the population. Good luck with that. Anarchism is the only reasonable path forward. Liberalism has failed.
- lostmsu 7y agoAnarchism have failed much harder long time ago.
- CameronNemo 7y agoAnarchism dominates, but some anarchists failed. Do you really think that the RNC has a political philosophy beyond "do whatever we need to stay in power"? There is no rule of law, they just tell liberals there is so as to pacify them.
- anigbrowl 7y agoYou're gonna have to back that initial assertion up with something more solid than 'everything not mandated by the state is a manifestation of a joyous anarchic impulse' or similar pseudophilosophy that regrettably dominates anarchist literature and marks it as an erotic orientation rather than a political position.
- CameronNemo 7y agoPolitical ideologies are lenses to view the world from. Some make more sense than others. When non-violent drug crimes result in 30 year prison sentences while violent sexual crimes against minors result in no prison sentences, it is clear that the rule of law does not exist.
- psychometry 7y agoA constitutional amendment on any subject is almost inconceivable at this point. The union needs to be disbanded. Sure, most of the south will be a 3rd-world country in a matter of decades, but they deserve no better.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ctlby 7y agoCuriously enough, the only parts of the country that have ever approached anything resembling "failure" are (heavily progressive) urban areas like NYC and Detroit.
- moate 7y agoI think we need to set some terms here. What do you consider "failing"? Not that I'm really looking to jump into the mud and wrastle on this one, this seems like a perfect point for a -citation needed-
- ctlby 7y agoI put the word in quotes to indicate the tendentiousness of any potential definition. I personally don't think of any part of America as having "failed," but if you force me to pick, I'd choose any area that suffered from breakdown in law and order and severe de-population. NYC in the late 70s and Detroit's long-running (but hopefully interrupted?) decline especially come to mind. A number of other urban centers could potentially fit too.
- moate 7y agoFair enough, and I agree with your sentiment. I think I can point to some rural states economic downturns, criminal problems and terrible literacy rates and draw similar conclusions. I think the best move here is to agree that either side (rural vs urban, left vs right, whatever vs it's opposite) could cherry pick items to point to and say "these bad things prove my point".
- salawat 7y agoOokay. Apparently something in my phrasing seems to have ruffled some degree of feather, but I'm not seeing much in the way as to response to substance, so perhaps a final clarification is in order. On vulnerability to being rigged: I Absolutely see gerrymandering as a form of systemic cheat. It is a legal option within the explicit constraints laid down by the Framers, however, from a systems oriented point of view, the practice of districting is meant as a way to geographically divide up up the space in a State in such a way as to allow representation to be ideally derived equitably via geographical proximity. I find any attempt to try to engineer a district based on anything but geographical division to be highly suspect. I understand local footprints change, and redistricting may be required, but the process should be looked at as an technical apolitical consideration, rather than as a strategic way to exploit statistics to try to shift district lines into a more favorable arrangement for one party or another. My original statement was meant to clarify that the Supreme Court decision hasn't really changed anything in the grand scheme of things. I.e. no new vulnerabilities to gerrymandering were introduced. There was only a closing of the door on the Federal Courts picking sides. On the rest; I find both Maryland and North Carolina's attempts to quantify and measure the effects of gerrymandering admirable, even if the Supreme Court chose to abstain from the fight. I'm not 100% clear, but I don't recall having seen SCOTUS overturning the lower court's judgements; they merely proclaimed that no precedent derived from either case had standing within the context of the Federal system, and further remedy would need to be sought either in the National Congress, or through State specific law. Then again, I may need to re-read. Wasn't trying to start a flame war, even though apparently my initial knee-jerk reaction did. I could not understand how gerrymandering could have been casually tossed aside, even with their reasoning. It took a bit of stepping back to get the subtler points to crystallize.