5 ms·
I don't think it's ever acceptable to make an "if I didn't do it, someone else may have done something worse" defense.
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I don't think it's ever acceptable to make an "if I didn't do it, someone else may have done something worse" defense.
- Groxx 7y agoWhich is part of what causes tragedies of the commons, yes. I totally get your point, and it's valid, but it's being demonstrated right now that the current appropriate strategies have failed rather spectacularly. When appropriate measures have massively failed, what are the alternatives? Vigilante actions are one option, as is "watch the whole thing burn down", and probably an infinite variety of stuff in the middle and along different axes. What's your preferred option? edit: also, it's not quite "may [do] something worse". Insecure IoT things are used as botnets. Frequently. It's not a hypothetical threat at all, it's just a question of scale / frequency.
- tty2300 7y agoI see like a food safety inspector going around shutting down unsafe restaurants. These IoT devices are a danger to society and should be shut down.
- mehrdadn 7y agoDDoSes are as bad as food poisoning now?
- Groxx 7y agoWhen it causes millions of dollars of damage... Yeah. Sure. Why not? https://www.zdnet.com/article/the-average-ddos-attack-cost-for-businesses-rises-to-over-2-5m/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/the-average-ddos-attack-cost-f...
- mehrdadn 7y agoYou measure your health in dollars? I dare say you won't find much common ground with most people.
- Groxx 7y agoYou'll find it in tons of large-scale (e.g. governmental) decisions at the very least. "is it worth more to prevent X than to deal with the fallout" is a decision that has to be made at some point, and human life / injury are part of that equation. So, in a way, yes. I do. So do lots of people when they go to urgent care rather than the ER, knowing that the ER could bankrupt them, and they'd rather risk the delay. I don't have numbers off the top of my head, but I don't think it's as uncommon as you seem to think it is.
- mehrdadn 7y agoYou're comparing urgent care to ER to somehow argue people view both DDoS and food poisoning in dollars? Just because some policymakers put rough numbers on the value of human life in the aggregate in very specific situations with very particular interpretations, you think people would support your cause of measuring everything in dollars and going around destroying their property because they're "just as dangerous as food poisoning"? Like, seriously? If you went around and asked people whether their restaurants should be shut down for unsanitary practices, do you think you would get a response on the same planet as what you would get if you asked them about their IoT devices getting shut down? Come on.
- Groxx 7y ago>You're comparing urgent care to ER to somehow argue people view both DDoS and food poisoning in dollars? No. I'm responding to: >You measure your health in dollars? And apparently reading it with a different intent than it was written with. --- >If you went around and asked people whether their restaurants should be shut down for unsanitary practices, do you think you would get a response on the same planet as what you would get if you asked them about their IoT devices getting shut down? They should, yes. I don't really think they do though. Botnets cause them harm (they're often used to hide the source of hacks, which often target financial info, which does affect millions of people), but it's often further removed than food poisoning, so it's harder for them to identify the cause. They're also usually more attached to purchases of things that work for longer than a meal lasts. People don't have visceral reactions to things in line with what they should rationally fear. I don't think anyone would debate that. I'm arguing DDoS (and everything else botnets are used for) are in that "does not get an appropriately strong reaction" category.
- pjc50 7y agoMore like an unlicensed vigilante "food inspector" going round restaurants and burning them down on sight of a cockroach.
- icebraining 7y agoSoft-bricking is hardly comparable to burning something down. More like adding an extra lock and throwing away the key. Inconvenient, but not destructive.
- oaw-bct-ar-bamf 7y agoTo you as a domain expert, yes. A typical user just tosses the device into the trashcan. For him it’s effectively bricked.
- SkyBelow 7y agoIn a society where people refuse to have food inspectors and some are being harmed by food poisoning, I think one could argue that there isn't something wrong with that level of action.
- nickpsecurity 7y agoI think it's more like firearms. These devices can be and are used as weapons to hurt 3rd parties on the Internet. It's more like firearm owners leaving their weapons in front of their barely-sturdy windows. Then, folks needing weapons keep breaking the windows before firing them at others. The homeowners and homebuilders keep letting it happen. So, vigilantees concerned about damage to innocent people keep breaking into the windows, stealing the guns, unloading them, and tossing them into landfills. I'd be like: "Stop putting your guns in front of the windows. Be a responsible gun owner." Enough broken windows and stolen guns might incentivize them to do that.
- seanhunter 7y agoFood safety inspectors have an official remit to do this that is enshrined in statues and local laws. You don't get to just decide for yourself you will shut down some restaurants on a freelance basis.
- boomlinde 7y agoThat's a misleading representation of the defense. "If I didn't do it, they would eventually have become a public nuisance in the form of nodes in a botnet" captures the supposed intent more fairly, and with the intent to target every known vector used by Mirai and Qbot it seems quite realistic that these systems would eventually become botnet nodes. It's IMO somewhat comparable to culling high-risk farm animals to prevent widespread disease outbreaks.
- FakeComments 7y agoOkay, I accept your analogy. Where do you have legal authority to do a vigilante culling of your neighbor’s herd, because you decided something about them merited it?
- boomlinde 7y agoThere is a dead reply to this which I think asks a fair question. > Where do you have legal authority to do a vigilante culling of your neighbor’s herd, because you decided something about them merited it? I am not making the argument that this is legally defensible. You can by definition not have legal authority to engage in vigilantism. It's from an ethical and practical perspective that I draw the analogy. On the matter of legality, the difference you point out applies, but also goes both ways. There is no legal framework around "culling" insecure devices, and very little regulation.