6 ms·
I'll never understand why lawmakers think that fruit and other flavorings for tobacco are aimed at getting kids hooked. It's almost like they think no adult has
by zdragnar 7y ago
I'll never understand why lawmakers think that fruit and other flavorings for tobacco are aimed at getting kids hooked. It's almost like they think no adult has ever enjoyed fruit or candy, and that making teens smoke plain cigarettes will keep them from being rebellious.
I've tried almost every variation of ecigarette mod out there except mechanical mods, because I'm not an idiot enough to know I'm too much of an idiot to use one safely. Nicotine salt (the type used in juul and smok nord, among others) are the best- balance of nicotine from the sub-ohm types without the obscene amount of vapor pouring into your lungs, and the filter doesn't constantly clog / burn like the older, smaller pen and marker varieties.
Does it suck that also makes them perfect for teens to hide their addiction? Sure. Then again, there's also a market starting to boom for tobacco-free nicotine pouches, using tea leaves or other filler. It's also way, way cheaper to get the liquid for vaping online than it is in stores anyway.
This ban, at the scope of the city, won't help teens, and it's only going to hurt the people living there. For better or worse, drugs like caffeine, tobacco, alcohol, and THC are here to stay.
- graphememes 7y agoBecause kids love candy. Adults do too, but kids much more.
- zdragnar 7y agoThat's strange, I haven't seen any calls for bans for wine, wine coolers, candy flavored liquors, beers made with fruit such as lambics, etc. Kids under 16 aren't old enough to drive, and yet there are plenty of toys shaped like cars and trucks. Toy guns, movies involving gun violence without R ratings, saturday morning cartoons, television featuring people consuming alcohol, etc. All of the above can have just as bad as, if not worse, consequences for children should the gateway argument be applied. This is not to downplay the consequences of minors using tobacco products. It's to demonstrate that just because something appeals to a child does not mean that it should be prohibited for adults to consume / participate in situations that only adults should be allowed to consume it. Campfires are plenty enthralling - sing along songs, s'mores, hot dogs, etc. There's no calculating the devastation caused by out of control fires, and children definitely should not be playing with it, and yet there's no call to ban adults from enjoying them either. The whole argument is an ad absurdum, from campfires all the way back to banning pleasant tasting tobacco.
- Noos 7y agoI'm not sure they have been banned, but there used to be candy cigarettes, and Big League Chew is bubblegum that is patterned after chewing tobacco. Haven't seen either in a long time.
- Judson 7y agoBig league chew is still a thing.
- kalleboo 7y ago> That's strange, I haven't seen any calls for bans for wine, wine coolers, candy flavored liquors, beers made with fruit such as lambics, etc. When Alcopops gained prominence in Europe, there was a huge outrage and much talk of bans. In the US, the FTC has investigated the link between wine coolers and underage drinking several times. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcopop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcopop
- strken 7y agoAustralia raised the tax for alcopops in response to a rise in teen drinking, which was kind of stupid since teens moved to spirits and cask wine instead.
- robotron 7y agoI would love to see reaction vids of kids trying lambics. Pretty far stretch to compare those to candy-flavored anything.
- zdragnar 7y agoHeh. Of all the examples I gave, lambics were probably the worst, but not by as much as you think. Nicotine, like caffeine, has a bitter taste on its own. Ecigs are flavored in part to cover the taste. Lambics aren't fruit juice, ecigs and flavored chew aren't candy. No-one would ever mistake the two.
- woodruffw 7y ago
- r00fus 7y ago> I'll never understand why lawmakers think that fruit and other flavorings for tobacco are aimed at getting kids hooked. Do you have kids? They love what their friends have, and really really like candy flavors.
- phil248 7y agoYes, but adults also really like candy flavors. Should we no longer be permitted by the state to drink mojitos or Moscow mules because they also happen to be delicious? You also did not provide a response to the text you quoted. Why does having kids, or knowing that they like candy flavors, mean that all flavored things are aimed at children?
- delecti 7y agoI'm an adult and I also really like candy. I have no interest in tobacco or nicotine, but I've considered getting tasty non-nicotine vape flavors because a zero-calorie alternative to actual candy might help in much the same way that non-tobacco vaping is a healthier alternative to smoking.
- eridius 7y agoAdults like flavored nicotine too, but have you seen the ads? They're blatantly targeted at kids. Hell, I saw one once that showed a vape plugged into the USB port of a kid's laptop in class, where the advertising was basically saying your teacher won't know it's a vape.
- e40 7y agoThen BAN THE ADS!
- eridius 7y agoRight, because intentionally designing a harmful product to appeal towards kids and get them hooked on nicotine is perfectly fine, just as long as we eventually crack down on the ads.
- asdff 7y agoHow is it designed to appeal towards kids? It's just good design that's dirt simple and works. If you look at their previous product, the pax, it's right in line with their design language and philosophy.
- eridius 7y agoThe flavored nicotine is the part that's intended to hook kids, and as I already mentioned, the advertising was pretty blatantly targeted at kids.
- zdragnar 7y agoYou know what's less conspicuous than a vape pen hooked into your computer in class? A pack of smokes and a lighter in your pocket. I dont see the allure to children... College kids, maybe. Also, when did non-college-age children get allowed laptops in class? We werent even allowed to have a cell phone on our person during school hours, let alone a laptop.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mc32 7y agoI’m for regulating this as stringently as for regular cigs... but it’s weird... they don’t bother addicts injecting, they provide needles and let them shoot up, no problem. But you wanna vape? Nah! If they think banning is a solution to vaping and it’ll be successful, why not ban syringes —I’m sure they’re equally effective.
- seandougall 7y agoThere’s a public health reason for that. How many people have ever contracted HIV from a used e-cigarette?
- hnzix 7y agoHepatitis A, B and Swine Flu. You can literally buy little plastic condoms for your e-cigs. Don't pass that e-cig in the club kids. On a different note, as someone who's used e-cigs to wean off cigarettes and eventually quit altogether, this ban is pants-on-head puritanical stupidity.
- seandougall 7y ago> You can literally buy little plastic condoms for your e-cigs. That's both an amusing mental image and a pretty great idea. One that has no analog with hypodermic needles, so it's still a false comparison.
- ramphastidae 7y ago> I'll never understand why lawmakers think that fruit and other flavorings for tobacco are aimed at getting kids hooked. Candy cigarettes. Big League Chew. And now e-cigarettes. It's common (and now scientifically documented) knowledge that tobacco companies have used these types of flavors and products to target young smokers. There is decades of evidence and little reason to believe it won't continue. Whether it's 'fair' to adults in terms of how many flavors they have access to is up for debate but the lawmakers' reasoning is sound. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1118335/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1118335/ > Advocates of public health care consider candy cigarettes (cigarette sweets) one example of the way in which international trademark or copyright laws are violated to promote tobacco products to children.1,2 People with vested interests in confectionery and tobacco have denied these claims and argued that restrictions on confectionery resembling tobacco products are unnecessary. We review recently available documents from the tobacco industry, which describe cooperation between the manufacturers of tobacco and candy cigarettes, ineffectual trademark enforcement, evidence that candy cigarettes may promote smoking, suppression of unfavourable findings from research sponsored by the confectionery industry, and successful attempts to avoid legislation or regulation. > Summary points > * Candy products that mimic packaging of tobacco brands may promote smoking in young people > * Executives of both the tobacco and confectionery industries have regarded candy cigarettes as good advertising to future smokers > * Some tobacco companies granted confectioners permission to use cigarette pack designs and tolerated trademark infringement > * Children who have used candy cigarettes are more likely to become smokers > * Unfavourable research sponsored by the US candy cigarette industry was suppressed > * Elimination of candy cigarettes and other confectionery resembling tobacco products may help achieve public health goals of reducing tobacco use in young people
- my_usernam3 7y agoI disagree with your comparison of fruity e-cigs to candy versions of tobacco products. One is a 18+ only product (or 21+ in California) the other is in candy stores kids frequent and purchase. One is heavily restricted on advertising ESPECIALLY to youth, the other isn't (or wasn't, I don't know the current rules of big league chew). Fruity e-cigs are made for adults, purchased by adults, advertised to adults, and are illegally obtained by teens. Candy cigerettes, and big league chew is made for kids, purchasable by kids, advertised to kids, all hoping to later get them addicted to the products they actually represent.
- ryanmercer 7y ago>I'll never understand why lawmakers think that fruit and other flavorings for tobacco are aimed at getting kids hooked. It's almost like they think no adult has ever enjoyed fruit or candy, and that making teens smoke plain cigarettes will keep them from being rebellious. I can think of a dozen people off the top of my head that regularly smoke but say "it's not smoking, it's just hookah, it's a social thing". I guarantee you, if there weren't hookah bars and instead were "cheap-cigarette bars" exactly none of them would smoke. Then with 'e-cigarettes' you have flavours like 'blueberry pie' 'brownies' 'waffles' pretty much anything you could ever want. You're going to sit there and tell me you don't think if a minor gets their hands on one will be like "oh man, this grape jolly rancher flavor is awesome, but I think there is nicotine in it so I must never ever ever touch it again"? I was watching something on Hulu or Netflix this weekend that was high school aged characters and there were kids puffing away on liquid nicotine rigs in the background of multiple scenes.
- zdragnar 7y agoYou can get those same vape flavors without nicotine, too. They go down quite a bit easier, too.
- bliblah 7y ago>I'll never understand why lawmakers think that fruit and other flavorings for tobacco are aimed at getting kids hooked. Because the companies themselves have admitted to marketing towards this demographic. [1] The market was wildly unregulated and it was printing free money for these companies to target kids and sell these pods in retail stores. Heck I even remember going to a gamestop and seeing video game style vape pods. I'm not going to comment on the ban itself, but I think it is reasonable to assume that these companies have very big incentives to target minors and create brand loyalty early on since regulations can be quite murky regarding e-cigarettes. [1]https://www.forbes.com/sites/kathleenchaykowski/2018/11/16/the-disturbing-focus-of-juuls-early-marketing-campaigns/#275f6c0e14f9 https://www.forbes.com/sites/kathleenchaykowski/2018/11/16/t...
- Balgair 7y agohttp://www.fox5ny.com/news/fda-vaping-liquids-juice-boxes-candy http://www.fox5ny.com/news/fda-vaping-liquids-juice-boxes-ca... https://www.fda.gov/tobacco-products/ctp-newsroom/e-liquids-misleadingly-labeled-or-advertised-food-products https://www.fda.gov/tobacco-products/ctp-newsroom/e-liquids-... Just look at that packaging! It's aimed directly at kids. JFC, it's even got the leprechaun and rainbow on it, same font, same little marshmallow shapes, just like the cereal. 'Oh, but adults like colors too!' Give me a break.