4 ms·
Private Equity bullshit and changing market. By "changing market", I mean: - Retail is brutal business. Everyone focuses on Amazon, but on the ground, Target
by Spooky23 7y ago
Private Equity bullshit and changing market.
By "changing market", I mean:
- Retail is brutal business. Everyone focuses on Amazon, but on the ground, Target did a bigger number on them. Target got really good at capturing the kid product lifecycles, from baby to tween. Target does toy and gadget merchandising much better than Walmart. Amazon prices for baby stuff always suck as compared to Target.
- Tablets and smartphones also really killed the toy market in general -- kids aren't playing with toys as tablets capture attention.
- Toys suck. As toys consolidated into a couple of giants, the quality of everything is just garbage. I bought a board game recently where the board was so thin, it bent from humidity! There's actually a thriving resale market for 70s and 80s toys. My wife sold a Fisher-Price House and a GI Joe helicopter at a consignment sale for $75!
- joezydeco 7y agoI totally agree that Target and Walmart filled the vacuum really well, and TRU reentering the market isn't going to change things back. I'd expect TRU to have a decent, but not great holiday 2019, then pretty much fall apart after that.
- metalliqaz 7y agoDon't forget that when they declared bankruptcy, they defined this as a major issue going forward: - Low birth rates. The size of their target population is actually shrinking.
- learc83 7y agoDo they consider their demographic to be just White kids or something? Because the number of children in the US is projected to keep growing until at least 2050.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoChildren with parents/relatives who have disposable income is their target market.
- learc83 7y agoI haven't seen any evidence that the number of children with parents or relatives who can afford to buy toys is going down. Toys R US was never a very high end brand. And if anything a declining birthrate with more children means a higher adult to parent ratio, which seems like a good thing for them.
- Spooky23 7y agoThe current cohorts of kids are smaller. It’s creating big challenges for schools and colleges.
- learc83 7y agoHow though? I'm sure in certain areas this is true, but across the country the number of children is increasing.
- Spooky23 7y agoNope, we’re on a peak. https://www.childstats.gov/americaschildren/tables/pop1.asp https://www.childstats.gov/americaschildren/tables/pop1.asp
- learc83 7y agoAre you looking at the same table I am? It's currently rising and keeps rising until 2050, which is the end of the prediction table. Slowly--but not that much slower than average. There was a slight dip between 2010 and 2015, but not enough to be cause smaller cohorts to be a problem nationally. We're talking about the difference of a few hundred thousand kids across a population of 70 million+. There was bigger dip in the 70s.
- rsj_hn 7y agoI think the issue is they need parents with more disposable income, but it's roughly a 50% drop in household income as you go from asian/white families to hispanic/black families. There's a time series here: https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-poverty/cps-hinc/hinc-04.html#par_list_11 https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-p... Take a look at Table HINC-04, which identifies income for families with children under 18: showing median/mean income: * white alone, not hispanic: 93K/120K * asian: 101K/136K * hispanic: 53K/72K * black: 47K/66K So stores like Toys-R-us can get hammered as a result of demographic shifts even if total population of kids is increasing.
- fsloth 7y agoToys indeed suck. It seems they are made for the parents to fullfill the ritual of buying toys, not actually to be fun to play with. In a reasonable market this would not work but - it seems the offerings from all toy brands except Lego are equally crappy.
- duderific 7y agoMy 5yo kid pretty much only plays with Legos, despite having many other toys. Everything else gets old really quick, but legos are endlessly entertaining for him.
- munificent 7y ago> Tablets and smartphones also really killed the toy market in general -- kids aren't playing with toys as tablets capture attention. This is really easy to underestimate if you don't have kids. If have elementary-school age kids. They get plenty of toys at birthdays and Christmas and I'm always surprised how many of them literally sit on a bookshelf unopened. (We end up donating many of them after a while.) They are basically interested in screen time or books and that's about it.
- asark 7y ago> I bought a board game recently where the board was so thin, it bent from humidity! This is the case for just about any of the fiddlier board games and boardgame-adjacent things from back then. Often the story is some Chinese company bought the license and is churning out the same thing, but 10-20% smaller and all the plastic's 1/2 as thick at best. Rock 'Em Sock 'Em? Smaller, way thinner plastic. Hungry Hungry Hippos? Similar story. Loopin' Louie? Weaker motor. Over and over if you dig into board game nerd talk about these the advice is to find an original, because though you can buy a new one on Amazon it isn't really the same thing, and often barely works at all.
- StrictDabbler 7y agoI agree that board games have gotten cheap as the market for them has shrunk. Spinners are particularly bad. Conventional toys are much, much better. Are you kidding? The plastic manufacturing techniques available today put 70s toys to pale. Computer modeling also makes more complicated designs possible. In the 70s, action figures were lucky to have a blocky head with eyebrows painted on in about the right place. Modern GI Joe figures have full naso-labial folds and neck musculature. It isn't even close. In 1985, Optimus Prime was able to transform from a blocky truck to a truck rotated vertically with a robot head and arms that kinda swung out. You had to add the fists and you lost them almost immediately. Modern Optimus figures transform from an aerodynamic semi-truck into a fully articulated robot samurai that looks better than the one drawn in the original cartoon. Have you compared a modern plush to one from the 80s? Take a look at the stitching. You can get plushes for $10 now that would have cost $80 in 1985 and had less facial detail. Toys are mostly better made now. We just don't care about them as much and they fade into the generic plastic darkness.
- autoexec 7y agoToys are very much hit and miss. Unless you're willing to spend > $50 for the stuff intended more for adults like the G1 transformers reissues. I haven't seen a better Optimus prime yet personally. Even at that high price point you can't always get something quality. Compare the "die cast" Voltron of today which is 90% plastic to the one from the 80s. We definitely have options for high quality stuff, but companies don't always bother. There's some great models out there, but the market is also full of funko pop which is about as low effort as you can get.