5 ms·
Even under that criteria, though, I think Julian Assange would've been a much better choice. Most of the stuff FaceBook did to change the world happened around
by nostrademons 16y ago
Even under that criteria, though, I think Julian Assange would've been a much better choice.
Most of the stuff FaceBook did to change the world happened around 2007. Heck, the fact that the movie's coming out now indicates that the important stuff happened long ago.
- robryan 16y agoIf they were recognizing a person in a particular year, but took into account there past accomplishments also I think he is a decent choice. Just this year though nothing person of the year ground breaking has happened, with the movie coming out it's almost delayed recognition, when it was all happening not many actually knew it.
- greyman 16y agoCan you specify in more details what you think is the scale of Julian's impact? From media coverage it looks like the impact has been huge, but is it really? I am not against Julian, I would not object if they selected him instead of Mark, I am just not sure that until now the real impact (of Wikileaks) on how the world operates was that big.
- nostrademons 16y agoI believe he's a harbinger of things to come. Not necessarily in the sense of new leaks coming from WikiLeaks, which has been fairly tame so far. I think, though, that Julian's basically validated the idea that a.) it's possible to collect, vet, and release potentially damaging information about powerful entities and b.) people care when you do. We've had time periods like this in the past (eg. the Muckraker era at the turn of the 1900s, the Pentagon Papers from the early 70s, Watergate), but the last such era seems to have been over 30 years ago. In the last 10+ years, we seem to have accepted the idea that it's okay for government and corporations to spy on us, but not okay for us to spy on them. Julian was just the guy who had the balls to say "Umm, two can play at this game" and follow through on it. He's validated the market. It's like Napster and Friendster: the services themselves failed, but they paved the way for iTunes and FaceBook, which have become huge. Can you imagine what'll happen when some enterprising anarchist hacker hooks up spyware, a botnet, and a spam network? It's not terribly difficult to write malware that scans each infected computer for any documents and posts them as spam comments to blogs or sends them out as spam emails. The thing is - once the information is out there, it naturally gets collaboratively-filtered. The interesting tidbits will be forwarded on or posted to Reddit, while the boring stuff will be deleted as garden-variety spam. I suspect that there's already malware out there that does exactly this, but instead of posting confidential info to random blogs, it just uplinks it to the Chinese government or some Russian mafia syndicate. The impact of WikiLeaks is that it's turned a spotlight on the damage that can be done - and more important, the attention that can be gained - by leaking information. That makes it far more likely that some bright, naughty teenager is going to think "Hey, wouldn't it be cool if everything was out there?" and dump everything out there.
- jhamburger 16y agoI'd give it to Julian over Mark because of the "Somebody would have done it anyway" factor.
- ScottBurson 16y agoThe balance of power between governments and citizens has been changed forever. In 100 years everyone will remember Julian Assange; no one will remember Mark Zuckerberg. And that's true even if WikiLeaks were now to vanish; there will be dozens of replacements (like OpenLeaks).
- rimantas 16y agoI seriously doubt many will remember him three years from now. The most noise about him is related to his Sweden affairs not something truly remarkable he has done. And after listening to him on BBC I started to dislike him rather a lot. I may be terribly wrong, but my gut feeling is that his main agenda is personal fame, or something else, not common good.
- yock 16y agoI didn't say it was a good choice, it's just their choice. For what it's worth, I agree that there were better options.
- edanm 16y ago"I think Julian Assange would've been a much better choice." I have to wonder - Assange has only received serious press attention for the last few weeks. Isn't this just a case of him being more fresh in our minds? Asked another way, looking back 3 years from now, who will most people has made a bigger impact on the world?
- robryan 16y agoDepends, Wikileaks at least seems to credibly have a stack of incriminating stuff on the big banks. Who know's what else people will pass along to them now it's been shown how effectively they can capture the worlds attention.
- hugh3 16y agoIf I had some important secret documents to leak which provided evidence of wrongdoing on the part of government officials, I'd leak it to the New York Times or other major newspaper. They're the best place to go for stuff like that -- they have a huge readership, a staff who will dig into the surrounding issues, and a heck of a strong reputation (as opposed to ugly-website-run-by-creepy-alleged-rapist). I'd only leak to wikileaks if I (for some reason) wanted to leak ten gigabytes of randomly selected secret documents of no particular consequence. Wikileaks is the open mic night of leaking -- it's where you find the random crap, not the big stories.
- jonknee 16y agoThe NY Times would very likely not run with your leak. That's why WikiLeaks came to being.
- hugh3 16y agoNo, they frequently run leaks which they think are in the public interest. And they have pretty low standards for what they think is in the public interest -- ultimately they just need to be able to come up with a good justification for believing it might be in the public interest, since their primary purpose is to sell newspapers. They would refuse to leak random diplomatic cables which don't show any wrongdoing by anybody, though. (Although they're quite happy to publish a story about them if someone else is responsible for the leaking.)
- ankimal 16y agoHe was a runner-up. http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,2036683_2037118_2037146,00.html http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,2... I wonder if certain people and agencies had a hand in this?
- matwood 16y agoInstead of Assange they could have done the 'anonymous' leakers since it's their information that is really on display. Also, given the criteria where is Osama Bin Laden? His actions have done more to change the everyday world for people in the US than any other person in the last decade.
- nostrademons 16y agoI thought he was a runner up in 2001, which is the year he should've won.
- pfarrell 16y agoTime magazine considered Bin Laden, but decided he was a minor leader who got incredibly lucky in his plot. Guiliani got it instead.
- nlogn 16y agoAnd how silly does that look in hindsight? Person of the year, really?
- hugh3 16y agoIsn't it well known that Bradley Manning is the leaker?
- cies 16y agoi also wondered why it was zuckenberg over assange.
- kemiller 16y agoWhat has he actually impacted? Whose lives are affected, really, by what he did? Facebook, for good or ill, actually affects many people lives, and he was in the news in addition.