5 ms·
The real issue we are facing is that everything that we thought was not going to be pattern matching and tree search has turned out to be pattern matching and t
by roenxi 7y ago
The real issue we are facing is that everything that we thought was not going to be pattern matching and tree search has turned out to be pattern matching and tree search. I remember my father telling me computers were never going to be able to play Chess, because it required creativity for example. Nowadays a neural network with tree search plays chess that looks remarkably human. A lot of problem domains have fallen to what is basically pattern match and tree search.
Extrapolating the trend of the last 30 years, there is evidence that computers will be able to solve every task a human can using pattern matching. If that isn't AGI, it might turn out to be better than intelligence.
The technological future is unknowable, so believing AGI is certain is too much. But believing it certainly isn't around the corner is also too little. If computers can do anything a human can intellectually, they have reached AGI. The list of discrete tasks (games, decision making once the parameters are defined) a computer can't do is a very short list.
If someone finds an objective function for deciding what decision parameters are important AGI could be upon us very quickly. As a postcript, I think people radically overestimate human intelligence.
- jbay808 7y agoI'd be interested in knowing what coungerarguments the people downvoting this comment might know of, which I apparently don't.
- nineteen999 7y ago>> The list of discrete tasks (games, decision making once the parameters are defined) a computer can't do is a very short list. > I'd be interested in knowing what coungerarguments the people downvoting this comment might know of, which I apparently don't. I didn't downvote, but I will cite artistic endeavours. How long until a film crew of computers can shoot, edit and score a documentary or film that would be interesting to humans to watch? How long until they could develop an AAA computer game worth playing? How long until we could assemble an orchestra of computers that can interpret sheet music with feeling well enough to impress a human audience? I could go on and on finding other examples of human endeavours that computers/robots/AI will suck at for an extremely long time, if not forever. As we've seen recently, we are further from completely autonomous self driving cars than was hyped over the past few years. In my experience, programmers typically like to underestimate the breadth of human endeavour outside the domain of programming, particularly where the arts are concerned. And larger groups of humans working on larger artistic endeavours will take even longer to be displaced by AI, IMHO.
- pfisch 7y ago> How long until we could assemble an orchestra of computers that can interpret sheet music with feeling well enough to impress a human audience? I think AIs making music will come long before AAA games and movies, both of which encompass music as an art and then throw in like another 5 artistic pursuits on top. I think AIs will be making music inside 10-20 years or less. Honestly I think it could happen in like 1-2 years if a company with lots of AI resources chose to focus on it.
- atoav 7y agoNote that the parent comment wrote interpret music not make it. I am a musician and there were already impressive algorithmic compositions in the 70s using Markov chains, and today we use machine learning to create something that resembles the works of J.S. Bach. But how is that creativity? Creativity means coming up with new and interesting things (and fair enough many musicians make quite uncreative decisions all the time). These statistcal improvisators can come up with some interesting combinations but they are completely unaware of them and don’t repeat it ever again. IMO we didn’t even solve composition, because it also requires a good feel for how humans react to a piece and how a given piece or instrument fits culturally and what emotions it envokes for what reasons. Interpretation is yet another thing, it means interacting with an audience in one way or another. To think we managed to solve composition by scrambling together some melodies from an input of thousand melodies and thinking we are done with the hardest part is hubris at it’s best.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoCreativity and purposeful manipulation of human emotions are orthogonal concerns, even if often bundled together under the term "creativity" in context of arts. To disentangle them I propose a simple test: take these 'impressive algorithmic compositions that resemble the works of J.S. Bach' and play them to people, telling them they were composed by a gifted human. Then ask what they think of their creativity, and of emotions the author intended to communicate. That's creativity. As for purposeful manipulation of human emotions, this is harder and would require an AI with a theory of (human) mind, or some equivalent of that. Doesn't sound insurmountable though.
- rhacker 7y agoI kinda see it this way: AGI is Data in Star Trek TNG - trying to be human, making decisions to want to be alive, eventually dreaming and finally using an emotion chip. Another alternative here would be Moriarty or the various doctors in Voyager. AI is the Ship in TNG - lots of heuristics to figure out what the user is trying to do. Past usage of commands and relating major events outside the ship with algorithms for battle, life support, etc.. Events categorized by importance and automatic handling to save lives when necessary. Basically an extremely advanced Siri that doesn't really misunderstand you - while at the same time not really caring about you or knowing anything about being alive other than the priorities built into its software. I think for the next 100 years we're going to have AI progressing like the ship in TNG. I don't think we'll have AGI until maybe 100-200 years. Then again when I was born no one had a fucking clue eventually we would have something like the iPhone and talk to someone in China with <1 sec lag. So my estimates could easily drop to half.
- TomVDB 7y agoYour comment reminds me of this xkcd cartoon: https://xkcd.com/1425/ https://xkcd.com/1425/ It's 5 years old now (coincidentally the time span quoted to develop a solution), but recognizing a bird was already considered a solved problem 3 years ago, less than 2 years after the publication of the cartoon. Predicting the future is hard.
- AstralStorm 7y agoSurprisingly, recognizing a bird is much harder when you count rare species and running birds. Thus, sparse data. Does it recognize penguins too? AIs today still fail at it. Some folks were trying to train one to match endangered species and they had to pull mighty tricks to have some 70% accuracy. I think it was here on HN some time ago, but can't recall a link.
- visarga 7y agoAnd yet, average humans can classify even fewer species.
- mindgam3 7y agoAlthough I will admit to have used/benefited from the myth that chess skill is related in some way to general human intelligence, it’s a myth. Key differences between chess and real world: perfect information game, finite problem space, well defined rules. It blows my mind that serious people believe that ability to outperform human chess players using massive compute is some kind of major step towards AGI. If only it were that simple. It’s not that people overestimate human intelligence, it’s that they underestimate the meta-cognitive reasoning that we call common sense.
- roenxi 7y ago> perfect information game, finite problem space, well defined rules Chess isn't reality, but the things you list are all mostly things that humans can't deal with either. Take imperfect information - humans can't make decisions using information they don't have any more than machines can. Humans certainly can't deal with the infinite (and their approximations to do so are probably measurably worse than those a computer uses, because a computer can use honest-to-goodness probability formulas). Operating without rules is not clear cut, but most people do invent a whole heap of funny rules because they can't operate without clear rules either. Humans often literally hate and fear things that look different or don't follow all the funny rules they come up with. These are the same arguments as are deployed against self driving cars - if a computer doesn't have the information needed to make a decision then neither will a human in the same situation. The threat, opportunity and potential of AGI is very real. Once technology settles down and stops changing then we'll know that the situation has stabilised. But even as it stands what we have now would easily pass muster as AGI for the 1910s and it is still improving extremely rapidly.
- atoav 7y agoI remember when I was a teenager: a moonless night in the woods and my bicycle light was broken. It was so dark that I literally couldn’t see my hand in front of me. I could drive (slowly) because I knew that part of the street by hard and I knew there is a gravel patch on each side of the road. So I every time I entered gravel from the left I just turned a little more to the right and vice versa. And I knew I entered gravel by ear. There was also a faint red light from a memorial site candle that I could use as a orientation point. The thing was that I have never done this before (or after), nor did I think I ever would ever find myself in such a situation. I drove through that very road often at night also often without light because I had shitty broken bicycles, but this night was truly exceptionally dark and the darkest night I ever had seen since. The question is, what would an AI have done in a similar situation (sensors go dark for some reason)?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thom 7y agoMy fundamental problem with this viewpoint is that people appear to radically underestimate the amount of training data (all of it incredibly rich in context) that humans have had access to over the course of their lifetimes.
- glitchc 7y agoThe pool of accurately labelled, relevant, sufficiently diverse, training data is actually rather small per problem.
- dboreham 7y agoAgreed (with the analysis, not necessarily that we're anywhere close to achieving GAI). Nice to finally see proof that John Searle was 100% wrong with his assertion that intelligence couldn't possibly be algorithmic though.
- goatlover 7y ago> Extrapolating the trend of the last 30 years, there is evidence that computers will be able to solve every task a human can using pattern matching. If that isn't AGI, it might turn out to be better than intelligence. Only if the trend lasts and is applicable to every human task. Those are pretty big assumptions. > If someone finds an objective function for deciding what decision parameters are important AGI could be upon us very quickly. And if that function doesn't exist, because the real world (not a board game) is messy, dynamic and complex? > As a postcript, I think people radically overestimate human intelligence. Individually maybe, but as a group we're pretty damn impressive. I think you're radically underestimating the species. But this has been the case for strong AI proponents since the 1950s. AGI is always 20 years and one good algorithm away.
- otabdeveloper2 7y ago> The real issue we are facing is that everything that we thought was not going to be pattern matching and tree search has turned out to be pattern matching and tree search. Absolutely false. It just seems that way because you read biased research and articles. There's a boatload of problems that cannot be solved with pattern matching and tree search. Even really simple ones. One example is estimating/predicting binomial proportions adequately.
- marcosdumay 7y agoI don't know when your dad used to say that, but any researcher from the 50's would quickly tell you that Chess is just a giant tree search problem. We have a huge number of unsolved pattern matching problems around, so AI still has a lot of value to bring. But we don't have that much evidence that it suffices for everything.