11 ms·
The cost of raising a child in America has soared (2018)
- freejulian85 7y agoThere is no inflation, fake news.
- gavanwoolery 7y agoI'm having identical twins, classified as high risk. The cost is mind-boggling. I've already paid $7000+ out of pocket, and they have not even been born yet. Costs are mostly related to having to do ultrasounds all the time, and one MRI.
- why-el 7y agoI am really sorry to hear this. :/ You are bringing two wonderful human beings to the world and the system is failing you badly.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoWhat insurance plan can result in $7k out of pocket for unborn children?
- irrational 7y agoA very poor one it sounds like. Even a high deductible plan shouldn't have an out of pocket expense that is that high.
- djdidf 7y ago7000 deductible is pretty common
- EvanAnderson 7y agoAll my plans since 2013 have been $12K+ deductible. (Self-employed in Ohio.) Every medical event is a major shopping and price comparison exercise, and nearly every provider refuses to quote hard-and-fast prices. (You also get treated very badly by some practices who act terribly put-off that you'd have the lack of decency to ask about prices. You get that treatment double when it's about a procedure for your kid. P/A in the ER was a straight-up asshole when I questioned if a x-ray of my daughter was strictly necessary.)
- pkaye 7y agoCurious what is your yearly premiums? Is it a high deductible plan?
- EvanAnderson 7y agoThe current year is a high deductible plan (as all of mine have been since starting self-employment in 2004) but is not HSA-eligible. (Most years we've had an HSA-eligible plan, but some years none were available or they were vastly more expensive than the non-HSA eligible, which makes no sense.) We found a way to get an employer-sponsored plan thru my LLC this year and that dropped the premiums to just under $12K w/ a $13.6K family deductible. The marketplace plan we were on last year, had we renewed for 2019, would have been $17.5K in premiums w/ the same deductible. Neither is HSA-eligible.
- pkaye 7y agoI was punching some numbers into Covered California marketplace and for $12K you could get some pretty good plans. And if you qualify for the subsidy it is much lower. Some of the HMO plans have no or low deductibles.
- EvanAnderson 7y agoSounds like California has a much nicer market than we do in Ohio. I had one provider to choose from in the Marketplace for my county in 2019. Their "Silver" plan was what we had in 2018, chosen over the "Bronze" because the lower-priced "Bronze" was 20% co-insurance on inpatient care versus 100% coverage after deductible on "Siler". Aside from that company's plans those who purchased on the Marketplace in my county for 2019 had no other choices.
- guntars 7y agoAny high deductible plan will do that, but he’s covered after that. It’d also be conducive to his wallet if they get born before Jan 1st.
- EADGBE 7y ago> It’d also be conducive to his wallet if they get born before Jan 1st. Agreed. Also, being born even on December 31 2019 qualifies you for having another dependent in your household for the entire 2019 taxes, so it's a double whammy. A due date after September-ish ensures you're only paying the medical treatments/screens/hospitalization/etc for that year and that year only (vs, as you mention, a due date that happens potentially anytime between Jan-August). It's tricky. Unfortunately.
- pkaye 7y agoHigh deductible plans for one.
- asark 7y agoAside from the high deductible plans mentioned, even a fairly modest one can reach that if you split the pregnancy over two years :-( Yes, folks outside the US, we here in America try to time pregnancies over bullshit details of how our insurance plans work. At least anyone who's thought about it does. Those who haven't get a nasty surprise, and pay (up to) double.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoIt helps me to think of healthcare costs here as a tax. On average, the US pays a bit higher taxes than the EU with this consideration :)
- TuringNYC 7y agoI can only speak about NYC but this was a common cost range even with diamond plans from corporations. A lot of it can be fine print and delta balance billing.
- BeetleB 7y agoMany high deductible ones, where you are covering multiple people (e.g. a spouse and a kid). And almost everyone where some medical professional, somewhere in the chain of hospital visits, happened to be out of network - someone you had no idea would be involved. Examples would be where the doctor sent lab results to another doctor for analysis, etc.
- slavapestov 7y agoWe have a United Healthcare PPO through Apple, it's considered a "good" plan. We paid about $6k out of pocket for a pretty standard hospital birth.
- lanrh1836 7y agoIf you knew you would be having a baby one year, wouldn’t it make sense to pay a higher premium for a better plan with a low or 0 deductible? Or does the math still not work out?
- gavanwoolery 7y agoI did switch to the best available plan at the soonest date I could, but that was halfway into the pregnancy
- TuringNYC 7y ago1. Not all companies give you such options 2. A lot of the cost is in fine print of things not covered, e.g. during our delivery two of the many many medical personnel were out of network and we ended up paying a huge co-pay for that — but it wasn’t like we could have checked ids for each doctor entering the room etc for insurance acceptance. They entered, they did something, they billed.
- RHSeeger 7y agoI feel like a law should be passed saying that, for any patient with a medical networks, any out of network related charges must be signed off on; individually. Failing that, record yourself telling the hospital staff (or get it in writing) that any out of network charges will not be payed unless expressly signed for ahead of time.
- whamlastxmas 7y agoOr maybe we can just pass a law saying everyone deserves access to healthcare and have a single payer system to avoid this bullshit
- nkrumm 7y agoTo some extent there is some legislative action (particularly at the state level) that addresses this. The term commonly used here is “Balance Billing”, though that refers to a variety of “surprise” bills.
- souprock 7y agoYou didn't say why, which is fine, but I hope there is something more significant than just "twins" and that there is an actual intent to change treatment based on all that testing. If you wouldn't take specific action based on the results, then the exposure is unjustified. Satisfying curiosity is not a proper justification. See the Chinese ultrasound study. It's a study that is impossible to perform in the USA because it wouldn't pass ethical review. Ultrasounds were proven to cause structural changes in the brain. One can reasonably assume that structural changes are bad.
- analog31 7y agoCertain pregnancies are automatically elevated to "at risk" status, and AFAIK twins are one of the check boxes. Another is maternal age.
- EADGBE 7y ago> Another is maternal age. See: Geriatric Pregnancy/Advanced Maternal Age Pregnancy (Pregnancy after the age of 35).
- gavanwoolery 7y agoFrom the onset, they were classified as high risk due to being mo/di twins (monochorionic/diamniotic). It is now known that these pregnancies are much higher risk due to entanglement and other issues ("high risk" being a relative term). As it turns out, the doctors were right to assume this risk, as one of the twins has already received brain damage from (what they hypothesize) was inadequate blood flow. I'm generally against anything but procedures that are absolutely necessary, and the ultrasounds and MRI certainly were not voluntary on our part. Personally, from all the research I have gathered it seems like ultrasounds are quite safe, although I am not an expert. As for taking action, I had the same dilemma. Before we knew anything was wrong, one of the doctors ordered an MRI based on a hunch. I did not want to do the MRI unless it gave us some sort of information we could act on, and abortion was out of the question, legally and morally speaking under these circumstances. But we did it anyway, and at least the information has prepared us for what to expect.
- DoubleCribble 7y agoIf your hospital is like many/most of all US hospitals despite only one hospital room, only one set of nurses and doctors, only one mother... you get to pay the full price of delivery charges for each baby! They should be required to hang a sign outside L&D, "Half a womb still pays for the full room." just so you don't have a(nother) heart attack when the bill arrives in the mail.
- gavanwoolery 7y agoOh I'm aware of this. They even charge double for each ultrasound!
- pfranz 7y agoSadly, it's infeasible to predict costs in the US. When my wife was pregnant I pulled up our insurance's "example pregnancy out of pocket cost* (*not expected to reflect actual costs)" PDF. It showed something like $650 out of pocket for all prenatal and delivery costs. The actual cost ended up being closer to your's. I called my insurance to ask what I could expect to pay assuming a normal pregnancy after being amazed at the cost already billed. They suggested I a) call my doctor's office and get each billing code for each procedure expected b) call their billing office to get each cost for each c) call my insurance with these numbers and get out of pocket expected costs. I just can't imagine trying to compare costs between multiple hospitals or OBs. I tracked medical costs fairly closely and noticed things like a quick procedure would get 2 separate coded procedures. Someone I know familiar with medical records said that kind of thing was commonplace. So for a laymen, it seems ridiculous to anticipate costs even for routine things.
- golemiprague 7y agoThat's because women left home and went to work outside, they don't generate a real economic value at the workplace as most of them work for the government paid by taxes, as care takers - teachers, social workers, shrinks, nurses etc. or as value transference agents - lawyers, marketing and bankers. They don't grow the economy, hardly any of them generate new businesses, they don't build anything physical and hardly even anything technological and they don't even create much entertainment like music or movies, they just perform. The average housewife used to generate much more economic value and that's why when all the housewife jobs are now outsourced, it is much more expensive than the value the average woman generates at work. All those jobs the housewife used to do, food, laundry, taking care of kids physically, mentally and help them with homework, taking care of the elders, cleaning, gardening. All those things are outsourced and even using slave labour from Mexican illegals doesn't make it economically viable comparing to your average woman doing some secretarial work with a fancy title outside.
- q845712 7y agoThe article points to housing as one of the largest factors of raising a child, and mentions healthcare as well. To my very limited understanding, we calculate inflation from some fixed [per comments below: not entirely fixed] index of consumer goods prices [per comments below: which include some notional aggregate of rent]. Is it possible that instead of saying "The cost of children, housing, healthcare, and education have risen sharply" we should instead be saying "Inflation has increased substantially more than previously calculated because the price of a loaf of bread has been fixed by subsidies"?
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> we calculate inflation from some fixed index of consumer goods prices CPI includes housing, healthcare and tuition. The basket isn’t fixed, e.g. 1999 CPI didn’t include cell phone data costs.
- djdidf 7y agoIt includes rental, not purchasing homes
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> It includes rental, not purchasing homes Home prices work their way in through owner-imputed rent, i.e. the rent offset by owning the home. Home purchases include a utilitarian portion (the housing) and a speculative portion (the investment gains). We don’t include the stock market in inflation; we similarly don’t include housing prices beyond the housing utility. Nobody has to purchase a home; everyone needs a place to live. Every study that tries to include housing prices finds an inflation figure lower than CPI [1]. [1] https://seekingalpha.com/article/4173463-cpi-housing-prices https://seekingalpha.com/article/4173463-cpi-housing-prices
- wtvanhest 7y agoThis is correct. To expound on this, bay area housing is very expensive vs rent because the market believes that the price of housing will appreciate. In other markets the cost of owning is nearly flat with renting after factoring in the down payment. In those markets, the market of buyers believes that housing will not appreciate to the same level. You cannot include for sale housing in the index because the price paid is a speculation/estimate by the buyer (future looking) Rent is a snapshot of today's price.
- mistrial9 7y agoMedical guilds, unions and financial players are mature, strong and in-place. Many if not most, are well paid across the spectrum, and therefore can afford their own services. Why bring prices down ? ps- if you think this is an endorsement of the situation, think again; simply a cold-blooded game theory thought on a most emotional topic
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoYour guilds will get disrupted with a OBGYNer or BirthBnB at some point.
- souprock 7y agoMost of this is totally optional. I have a dozen kids, and I'm sure not spending that kind of money per kid. Births are usually cheap. You can go it alone for $0 or get a midwife for $2000 to $6000. Most of us have health insurance with an out-of-pocket maximum. For example, mine tops out around $11,000. Crazy bills can usually be negotiated, with the hospital very aware that you might just not pay at all. Child care is sort of free (though an opportunity cost) when done by family. That choice also strengthens the family relationships. It scales well, with older kids assigned to help younger kids. Housing isn't bad unless you insist on a bedroom for each kid. You need a house for yourself anyway, and most houses have 3 bedrooms. Homeschool to avoid the school district bidding wars. Food... is a bit of an issue. I go through about $4000 per month, but I'm not living on beans and rice. Being more frugal, $100 per kid per month should be possible for a large family. Transportation can be mostly avoided. Clothes become cheap due to hand-me-down policy. Sports can be cheap. You don't have to sign up for hockey. Play stick ball.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoAre you home schooling? In CA, depending on where you live, it costs the state and tax payers 10-14k/annum per child. That’s for 12 years. Dozen kids would cost about 1.6 million for 12 years of public education. ETA: I just saw that you mentioned homeschooling. If it’s ok to ask, how much are your expenses per month and do you own your home?
- souprock 7y agoI get dual-enrollment for free here in Florida, which most of my kids use to get AA degrees, so the state/county is paying something. I spent about $1000 for AP Chemistry labs and possibly about that much on all kinds of textbooks. Expenses are primarily food, at about $4000 per month. The rest isn't usually notable unless something is broken, such as when our 4-ton air conditioner is low on coolant or gets the fan stuck. Normally somebody needs surgery (cracked skull, rib cage correction, etc.) so my medical bills hit the yearly out-of-pocket maximum at around $11,000. We probably do 100 to 200 miles per week, fuel being $2.25, so that is pretty much nothing. I paid off my home in 8 years. It's 3500 square feet on 0.39 acre, about 0.9 mile from the beach. I got it for about $310,000 after the crash.
- foxfired 7y agoIn January of this year, I was blessed with two beautiful fraternal twins. Twins come out earlier and are expected to be preemies usually. The problem was, they were due on March 15. We spent two months in the NICU (newborn intensive care unit). The nurses couldn't be more amazing. They took care of those babies like they were their own. And along the way, they took care of us. They made sure nothing was ever missing. My sons got new pacifiers every time one got dirty. If their covers ever so slightly touch the floor it was thrown into the laundry basket. Their feeding tubes were constantly changed. I was grateful. My sons were born barely weighing 2 pounds, but they came out of the hospital as plump babies. Then the bill came. We have insurance. In fact, a very good insurance. The bill for the first born came a couple weeks later and it was in the amount of 1.25 million dollars. (I fainted) We called the insurance. They told us to wait, that the insurance will kick in. It kicked in and the bill came back rectified with the amount of 250k. The adjusted bill for the second child came shortly after. To give you an idea what is inside the bill, they moved the babies every couple days to a different section of the nicu. The bill showed that some section charged up to 20k a night. Those pacifiers that fell on the floor each cost 35 to 50 dollars. The formula they provided when we didn't bring breast milk cost hundreds of dollars. I don't have any credit card debt, I'm frugal when it comes to trivial purchases, I pay for what I can afford. I even have insurance. But then, there is a bill to pay. To this day, we are trying to get the bill to be a reasonable price. And so far, it seems like it's going to happen. We are very hopeful.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoI am very sorry that you have to deal with this while celebrating the birth of your children. Have you considered legal help to navigate this and have someone advocate for you?
- foxfired 7y agoWe did, that's why today I am not as worried as I was in those first week. We were advised that, with the insurance and Medical, it's possible we won't have to pay a cent for the babies. My wife medical bills were more reasonable and we already managed to pay them.
- paulcole 7y agoArticle doesn’t even touch on the environmental costs. Probably the worst thing you can do for the environment is have a kid. Edit: Why downvote this? It’s like talking about the cost of driving while ignoring all the costs being externalized and offloaded on everyone else.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoI agree. Tragedy of the commons scenario.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWhy downvoted? Maybe two reasons. First, it's off topic. You look like you're trying to find a way to sneak your hobbyhorse into the discussion, even when it doesn't really fit. Second, by the same logic, the best thing you could do for the environment is go on a murder spree and then commit suicide. That should appall you. You should respond "No, because..." (If you don't, seriously, please get help rather than committing suicide.) But what's the reason for your "no"? Because the murder spree is immoral? (It is.) Because suicide would hurt too many people around you? (It would.) Or is it because, despite the environmental cost of your continued existence, you feel that you could make a positive (net) difference with the rest of your life? But if you can, so can your child.
- paulcole 7y agoBoy, must have been a fun ride down the slippery slope from don't have kids to go on a murder spree. > despite the environmental cost of your continued existence, you feel that you could make a positive (net) difference with the rest of your life? I definitely do not feel that. I recognize that essentially every person is a net negative on the world (especially myself). But I have already been born and there's nothing I'm willing to do to change that at this time. I mean I get that people like having kids, but at least acknowledge how stupid it is to have one and then recycle or whatever like it makes some difference. This is not off topic at all by the way. The article is on the cost parents pay to give birth. But ignores the fact that parents are getting an unbelievable discount by offloading the environmental costs to the rest of the world. If we were serious about combatting climate change, having a child would be all but prohibitively expensive.
- KumarAseem 7y agoI think it has raised in most of the countries. In India, raising a child now is a very tough one. 1) Health Insurance - Not everyone has it and many who have turns out to be not sufficient. 2) Education - Schooling has become extremely expensive. There is not much regulation and schools apply a lot of tricks to get money from you, mainly under the guise of extra-curricular activities or development. They force the parents to pay, and legal recourse isn't available. 3) Health again - With the bad air, water and food that the children are getting these days, a lot of them get some or the other illness on a regular basis, which forces the kids to visit doctors frequently and take medicines. These all doctor visits don't get covered under insurance a lot of times. Kids of today are not developing a strong immune system. To top it all, many parents don't let their kids play outside. They give them a mobile and think they have done their duty. I forsee a very bad/difficult future for a lot of children.