4 ms·
I appreciate how sympathetic Cloudflare is to the root-cause party because they answered the phone and undid what they shouldn’t have done. (If my understandin
by Scoundreller 7y ago
I appreciate how sympathetic Cloudflare is to the root-cause party because they answered the phone and undid what they shouldn’t have done.
(If my understanding is correct, they shouldn’t have told Verizon about the better routing, while Verizon should have known better)
- laughinghan 7y agoI don't think your understanding is correct. I think they're supposed to be allowed to "optimize" the BGP routes that they advertise to their customer (Allegheny). I'm unclear on whether Allegheny should have relayed that advertisement to Verizon, but it's clear that Verizon should definitely not have then broadcasted that to everyone else.
- saxonww 7y agoI read this as Allegheny's fault, actually. DQE published to Allegheny (DQE's customer), who in turn re-published to Verizon (Allegheny's other provider). While most of the 'prevention' section talks about what Verizon didn't do, it doesn't seem to mention that Allegheny should not have re-published the DQE-published routes up to Verizon. It's startling that Verizon doesn't appear to have any leak mitigations in place, but I feel like Allegheny is getting a pass here because they are small, or something.
- steveklabnik 7y agoAllegheny is a steel company. I don’t think most people expect them to have the same responsibility for internet health as Verizon, even though they are a $4B company. (I’m from Pittsburgh, my grandfather and a bunch of my relatives worked for this company for decades. I’ve been kinda giggling about this intersection of my past and my present all day. I don’t work in the parts of Cloudflare that deal with this kind of thing; I’m glad my co-workers were on top of it.)
- Scoundreller 7y agoI had to do a double take because they seem to be selling themselves as a technology company nowadays. I guess “steel” in your name isn’t good for share prices.
- steveklabnik 7y agoTech or healthcare, that’s the way of things now.
- LIV2 7y agoNo customer should be able to bring down the internet due to misconfiguration this is all on Verizon imho Any ISP worth their salt has route filtering on any customer connections, nobody should be able to announce prefixes they don't own if the ISP is doing their job properly.