6 ms·
I do love the irony of a luxury car company trying to be more green. I'm all for electric cars. I think BMW will make some great electric cars and I will want
by sandworm101 7y ago
I do love the irony of a luxury car company trying to be more green. I'm all for electric cars. I think BMW will make some great electric cars and I will want to buy one. But the real green decision is to not buy the luxury car, to go with a less energy-intensive option such as a smaller/simpler car.
- gman83 7y agoOr just don't buy a car.
- SEJeff 7y agoThat isn't an option for 90% of the country (in the US at least).
- lorenzobr 7y agoThe real option is autonomous cars which you can call with a Uber-like app when you need it. That way we would have less cars but we would maximize the utilization rate of the ones we'd keep on the roads.
- gman83 7y agoDon't something like 80% of Americans live in urban or sub-urban areas? I live in a suburban area in Europe and have no problems getting around with public transportation. I get my groceries delivered by the shop.
- colanderman 7y agoMost American suburbs are not well served by public transportation. Personally, I've lived in many cities, suburbs, and rural areas in the northeast US (population-dense, relatively friendly toward ecological initiatives) and tried to use public transit whenever possible. My experience is that public transport outside cities is practically nonexistent. In cities, there are only buses and they're annoying/slow/don't go where you need them. Only now that I live in the immediate vicinity of Boston do I have useful public transit options, yet still, owning a car is a necessity to get to anything outside the city.
- AgloeDreams 7y agoSub-urban America is not 'no car' America, lacking public transport, the downright scale of American cities, and a car-focused traffic/zoning design makes bikes, walking, and bussing simply just not practical.
- ckuhl 7y agoThe definition of what a suburban area is in North America vs. Europe are so different they really need different words. A typical suburb in the US will have no public transportation, and be so sprawled out that bicycling or walking between places would be impossible for a working adult.
- WorldMaker 7y ago"Exurb" isn't used enough to describe American suburbs, but is certainly appropriate. Suburban sprawl got so bad that the original suburbs of a lot of cities, that were built with public transit in mind, today Americans think of as "city core" or "inner city" and don't even recognize as suburbs anymore. Meanwhile most of what Americans imagine suburbs to be are more accurately exurbs, and exurban living is seen as more normal than the traditional relationships between cities and their suburbs for a number of unhealthy reasons.
- sp332 7y agoYeah it's only 90% of the county by land area. If you count by people it's probably a lot lower. But keep in mind that public transportation is terrible even in dense places where it could make a huge difference in the US.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoI'm an American in Munich, suburbs here are still walkable, bikeable, and often have a solid S-Bahn connection to the city center. In America, most suburbs are bad for walking, actively hostile to biking, and have either no public transit or nearly unusable public transit. The cities are usually not much better, either. Only a handful in the US have public transit that can even be called decent, let alone good.
- SEJeff 7y agoThis so much ^
- rplnt 7y ago> (in the US at least) In the US only.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI suspect that HN User gman is trying to make exactly that point. (I could be wrong though.) I wonder if 30 to 40 years from now, we'll be having the same convo about electric cars that we are having about recycling plastic? Something that seemed good on the surface, but masked all kinds of externalities. I mean, at least electric should be a bit better than ICE in daily use. But will making these things at scale in the first place cost too much in the way of carbon production? Or other forms of pollution that we as consumers don't even know about yet? You may say, "well it was your job as a consumer to know the impact your purchases were having." But I'm just not that knowledgeable about that stuff. I don't know if a billion electric cars are bad or good? And it might not even be the cars, just the fact that we have to make the roads may be polluting somehow? Or whatever? It's just too much for a consumer to know. Should I be buying electric? Or supporting mass public transit? Which is better? Or is it just a question of which is worse? There's a lot to think about there. Or maybe it's just me?
- lorenzobr 7y agoI bet you don't believe in climate change either, do you?
- andyhmltn 7y agoThat's a hell of an assumption to make
- bilbo0s 7y agoJust for full disclosure, I believe in climate change. But I'm not sure I believe that having electric cars is better than having electric trains or buses? I honestly don't think it's stupid for me to ask whether or not having electric cars is the best strategy for dealing with climate change.
- ljcn 7y agoIt is an interesting question. The best option is almost certainly to not use a car (walk, cycle, or bus instead). The emissions are much lower[1] (absolute and per-distance) and you might get some health benefits. If a car is needed it depends how you're planning to power it. This answer[0] does a great job of looking at the energy inputs of building a car. I thought the up-front cost would be higher but the emissions from producing a car are comparable to the emissions of using the car for a few years. So if the choice is between a used ICE car and a new EV and charging it with renewable energy, it's (surprisingly) probably worth buying the new EV. If you're planning to charge it with power from a coal plant though you should probably get the used ICE car. [0] https://www.quora.com/How-much-energy-is-required-to-build-an-electric-car https://www.quora.com/How-much-energy-is-required-to-build-a... [1] https://ecf.com/news-and-events/news/how-much-co2-does-cycling-really-save https://ecf.com/news-and-events/news/how-much-co2-does-cycli...
- stephencanon 7y agoMeh. We live in a town of 12,000 people (big town for the area, but in a very rural part of the US). My wife and I share one car, and walk/bike/take transit more often than we drive--the car is mostly for getting our daughter to daycare in the winter and for when my wife is on call at the hospital. There are plenty of folks in the area who don't drive at all. There are certainly parts of the US where a car is necessary, but 90% is pushing it. It may well be that 90% of people think that they need a car, though.
- pyromine 7y agoYou may find that due to your socioeconomic status it may be more feasible to be a one car-transit using family, but for many americans who may work two jobs with a hour break between them (or situation similiar) they seriously may only manage to be able to make their schedule work with a car. (Just an example situation) Being car-less in America is hard, I lived in a the suburb of a main city and if I was to use transit options to get to work I would have spent 3 hours a day on commute alone. That's simply not feasible. Similarly I used to work a job from midnight to noon (and a year later noon to midnight) and there simply was no feasible transit option for such a schedule, and with the sprawling nature of the suburb carpooling wasn't much of an option either.
- neuronic 7y agoThis is the real problem that needs to be addressed instead of churning out different cars.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoOr make the car very efficient (Tesla) and fuel it with renewables or other low carbon energy sources. Compromise is not always necessary. My year old Model S is already surpassed by the new Raven powertrain architecture, providing another 40 miles of range per full charge versus the “old” version (330 miles->370 miles).
- sfifs 7y agoThis is the "Reduce" philosophy. Not all agree with that philosophy - especially in the developing world who feel unfair if development and conveniences that the west got is denied to them. I personally moved from a energy non-intensive use country (India) to an energy intensive use country (Singapore) a few years ago and even though economic strata wise I've likely gone down a few notches, I wouldn't trade-in my current lifestyle & convenience for what I had back in India. "Reduce" for the sake of reduction is just poor behavioral economics & hence hasn't actually demonstrably made much of a difference to this world. Reduce as a side effect of a true benefit/efficiency (think how much lesser power is consumed per unit compute today vs. even 5 years ago) makes a lot of sense.
- adwww 7y agoIt's how you plan society as well. Singapore is dense and has great public transport. America conciously builds sprawling suburbs that require private cars to get around. We can choose to build a society that does not need as much car use.
- sfifs 7y agoTrue and Singapore's government has been very systematic about broadening public transport access - not just for energy reasons but also for economic participation & health reasons (people walk a lot more). But Singapore also air conditions everything which is a fairly heavy energy use in tropical climate much like how heating is a massive energy use in northern climates and spends a lot of effort/energy on keeping sidewalks, grounds and pavements manicured, watered & in good repair. As the founder of Singapore argued, the lifestyle gain - though at the cost of consuming more energy is a massive competitive advantage in productivity and in attracting, developing & retaining talent. https://www.vox.com/2015/3/23/8278085/singapore-lee-kuan-yew-air-conditioning https://www.vox.com/2015/3/23/8278085/singapore-lee-kuan-yew...
- komali2 7y agoIs there anything that can be done to keep an office a reasonable temperature in a tropical climate like Singapore? I guess if we were all hanging out under open air roofs with our flip flops and swimsuits on, but other than AC I don't know how they could do "business people" office stuff.
- toss1 7y agoI'm not sure it is so much the luxury/economy car as the weight that you need to look at. Weight, often even more than drag, will be a primary driver determinant of fuel inefficiency. While luxury cars are often heavier, and perhaps built without as much presumption that the owners will be concerned about fuel mileage/costs, there are many anomalies where apparently smallish cars are surprisingly heavy. And even 'economy' cars have become quite portly. Just look at the Honda civic hatch, from 1990-now going from 2165 Lbs to 2763 Lbs -- that extra 600Lbs is over 27% heavier -- a lot more mass to accelerate. Or, check out the Nissan Maxima sedan at 3676 Lbs! That's most of the way to my old BMW X5's 4100Lbs. Meanwhile a friend's C6 Corvette weighed in at ~3140 Lbs and got over 32mpg on the highway between the low CD and lighter weight. Look beyond the luxury to the design & build.
- nradov 7y agoHybrid and electric drive trains allow heavier vehicles to be more efficient. For example a hybrid RAV4 uses less fuel than a regular RAV4 even though it weighs more.
- leetcrew 7y agosure, but a hybrid Miata (if such a thing existed) would be even more efficient than the hybrid RAV4. I think that's all GP is trying to say.
- nradov 7y agoThe old Honda CR-Z was basically equivalent to a hybrid Miata but there's little market demand for such impractical vehicles.
- toss1 7y agoExactly! Drivetrain type is completely orthogonal to weight as a performance factor for a vehicle. Weight will affect the efficiency of every drivetrain (unless you have a drivetrain that can zero out the inertial properties of nearby mass). I was only suggesting that luxury is a less important factor than weight to consider for efficiency.
- leetcrew 7y agoluxury doesn't have to mean enormous or resource intensive (in physical materials at least). a car with a well designed interior and good driving dynamics doesn't isn't necessarily worse for the environment than a prius.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThe cheapest Tesla is three times the new price of the car my wife currently drives (£38,000 vs £12,500). That kind of implies the Tesla is a lot more carbon intensive than buying a cheap car, even over its lifetime.
- WorldMaker 7y agoPart of our trouble with climate change is that price is not strongly correlated with carbon, and our economic models are not carbon-sensitive. Cheaper does not mean "less carbon intensive", it just means presumably less demand and/or more supply of that model on the market.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoIn this case it means less material in the car and less costs in the supply chain. You just need to look at the dance the price of oil and the health of the economy go through to realise money and energy are deeply intertwined. It’s not obvious to me that we can completely decouple them.
- WorldMaker 7y agoWithout something like carbon taxes the supply chains and economy will never correctly account for carbon because it is an externality. The price of oil itself has no correlation with carbon output. (Total production numbers might tell you something, but that is only vaguely related to price in market economics, given the competing forces of supply and demand. Total usage numbers would tell you a lot more, but isn't a statistic even tracked by economics and if it has any correlation on price depends on the type of demand [elastic versus static] whether it is following/lagging or pushing the price.) Sure money and energy can be considered intertwined, but not all energy is carbon, don't forget that as much as business tries to underprice it, a lot of the energy reflected in a supply chain is labor (which admittedly people do also produce carbon, but exhalation effort is not something I've ever seen properly reflected in someone's wages). So again: higher prices in EVs and EV supply chains absolutely does not correlate with carbon costs. EVs generally have less material because a) weight matters a lot more, and b) fewer moving parts / simpler drive trains. Price differences likely reflect other market realities such as supply/demand and things like perceived luxury.
- cs02rm0 7y agoNo one who's driven a diesel 1 series thinks of BMW as a luxury car company!
- neuronic 7y agoExcept people who sat in a Tesla right after and wonder how cars with interiors like a Fiat Punto can cost more than the 1 series you just got out of.
- freehunter 7y agoYou're allowing perfect to become the enemy of good. People who buy luxury cars are not going to stop buying luxury cars. So the options are luxury cars that pollute the environment, or luxury cars that do not pollute as much. "The real green decision" is whatever is more environmentally-friendly than what you would have done otherwise.