14 ms·
Over the last two decades I've seen a dramatic increase in stressful academics at schools: More homework, more intense classes, ect, ect. I went to a "college
by gwbas1c 7y ago
Over the last two decades I've seen a dramatic increase in stressful academics at schools: More homework, more intense classes, ect, ect.
I went to a "college prep" high school that was harder than my college. As I became independent, I realized that intense academics stole my childhood and didn't have the value that the adults believe they have.
At the same time, when I lived in Palo Alto, I used to hear about how one of the high schools, (Gunn?) had a very high suicide rate due to the stress of academics. Someone (Caltrans?) put fences around the train tracks to try and stop suicides.
(I wish commenters wouldn't immediately blame social media.)
- codezero 7y agoThe fences and guards have absolutely helped. When I first started the commute we had something like 12-14 deaths one year. Since those fences went up it’s dropped dramatically.
- sametmax 7y agoIt helped the trains, not the kids.
- codezero 7y agoThat’s too bad. I hoped they added programs at the schools as well as guards. Did that not happen?
- forgottenpass 7y agoSchool anti-suicide (or any of their social intervention) programs mostly accomplish teaching the targeted groups to blend into the crowd and avoid attending the school's hamfisted intervention programs. But maybe that's the point.
- antisemiotic 7y agoI imagine it helped the train drivers a lot too.
- close04 7y agoPreventing suicide via one method doesn't turn people away from suicide, just from that particular method.
- codezero 7y agoIt sounds like "it's complicated" is a better way of thinking about suicide prevention. It's pretty hard to measure a localized "it's no longer happening," when measures for suicide prevention are put in place. Things effective one place, are less effective in others because of "sociocultural" reasons [0], but there is some evidence to suggest denying people access to the tools to commit suicide, and reducing media coverage (social contagion/clustering) seem to help. With that said, yes, you are right, just changing one thing doesn't do much, there needs to be a bigger picture approach that addresses many factors. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1414695/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1414695/
- enraged_camel 7y agoMy understanding is that there are two types of suicides: premeditated ones, and spur-of-the-moment ones. Putting up fences next to train tracks won't do much for the former, but I suspect it will reduce the frequency of the latter (which it did, in this case).
- close04 7y ago> (which it did, in this case). It reduced the frequency of "suicide by train". But suicides overall went up 30% from what the article states. It's more likely that the people who could no longer use this method as a spur of the moment thing just chose something else. Transportation related suicide accounts for 0.4% (or ~170 in 2012) of suicides in the US. [0] "Fall", another spur of the moment method, accounts for 6 times as much. You can only build so many fences. As someone with a bit of experience on the topic I can tell you that when suicidal ideation reaches the tipping point you need more than a fence to stop them. But I'm not saying "don't put up the fence". I just found GP's remark that "The fences and guards have absolutely helped" either a bit cynical or unrealistically optimistic. The only thing we can say with certainty is that it helped keep the trains going. I'm not sure it definitively saved lives. For that we need to do a lot more than build a fence... [0] http://lostallhope.com/suicide-statistics/us-methods-suicide http://lostallhope.com/suicide-statistics/us-methods-suicide
- rygxqpbsngav 7y agoStress at schools? I hail from India and when I was a kid in 90s, I carry 10Kg bag to school and has to do homework in 7 subjects, and get beaten by stick if I fail to do any of them separately by respective teachers, and has to spend time till 10pm after school (ends at 5 pm) at tuition to finish the homework. My view on social media and parents giving smartphones to kids is the primary reason. When kids start overusing phones and digital world, everything seems binary, they can feel like they can control people in real-world as if thy do a 3d character in their latest game. And can get depressed when others don't behave as they intend to. A friend becomes a removable entity in a list or circle(google+) they can add or pluck out anytime, without considering the emotional factor others feel. I can talk on this topic whole day, i believe kids don'e need smartphones etc. and I will never bring my kids near them at-least till they reach their teen years.
- Kaiyou 7y agoStress is very different from physical things, like carrying heavy stuff or getting beaten. Pain, you just have to endure once and then it will slowly go away until the next time you receive pain. Stress accumulates. Forever. Getting stronger and stronger over time. If you can't deal with it it will devour you.
- sandworm101 7y agoThe stress in the US system is very different. Indian schools (basically the oldschool british system I grew up with in boarding school) are hard but not stressful. Performance metrics are clear and students know what they have to do. US schools have become strange minefields of nebulous collage prep. Grades are given, everyone gets As. So students are forced to pad their resumes is other ways. You don't see indian students picking sports based on whether they can make team captain. You don't see average Indian students participating in 4+ team sports during a given week. I've talked to Canadian kids who, when caught using steroids, have said that their performance on the field was part of their entrance plan. They had consciously decided to take drugs not to become pro athletes, or even to win a scholarship, but simply to get into a proper university. Similarly, I haven't heard of many indian students taking "learning drugs". I heard an ivy league admissions person talk about the sports thing. She spoke of a boarderline case involving an athlete who had competed at the Olympics. He had failed to medal. THAT was part of the schools decision, whether they metaled or not actually mattered.
- Kaiyou 7y agoPretty much the only value you get from formal education is the paper you receive at the end. It's all pretend play nowadays. Teachers pretend to still teach and students pretend that school is important and since everone keeps up the charade, it's hard to notice that school has become a huge waste of time negatively impacting the lives of students.
- okaram 7y agoI completely disagree. I learned a lot throughout my schooling, and made sure my students learned a lot when I was a teacher.
- tracyshaun 7y agoWho's "you"?
- DanBC 7y ago> Someone (Caltrans?) put fences around the train tracks to try and stop suicides. Reducing access to means and methods is the best way prevent suicide, and that includes physical security around frequently used locations, especially if they involve trains or high places. There's often a strong resistance to this and I don't understand why. See this rather old English government advice: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/769006/Preventing_suicides_in_public_places.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... (See in particular case study 2 and case study 3 on pages 22 and 25)
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoIt’s dystopian to prevent only suicide and not the causes. It invokes a feeling of being somewhat like a farm animal: you exist to consume and work for the benefit of others, and if you’re unhappy that’s your problem. You certainly can’t decide to escape in any way, by design.
- radcon 7y agoI remember watching a documentary on assisted suicide where they said that many people who are approved never follow through, but knowing they have a way out provides a great deal of relief. With that in mind, I can easily see how things like fences might make the problem worse as you said. People will feel even more trapped and helpless when what they need is the opposite.
- DanBC 7y agoBeing polite: we know fences work.
- radcon 7y ago> Being polite: I'm sure you're already aware of this, but condescendingly stating that you're being polite is the opposite of being polite. > we know fences work. No, you don't know that. You may know they solve the visible problem (suicide), but you don't know if they do anything to alleviate the conditions that lead to suicide. Is there anyone who believes fences make people happier or less depressed?
- entropea 7y agoPersonally, what depresses me is that at 28 and in an excellent job making a little more than my train engineer (designing & fabricating train engines) father was in the late 90's and he had 3 kids, a house, two cars, and had no other sources of income or money. I can't ever see myself owning a home except somewhere extremely rural and requires a lot of costly basic remodeling, we've had changes & commodification of dating, loneliness, a planet becoming inhabitable with nobody really doing anything to address it. I did what I was told would lead to success, I've worked in multiple places with 5-7 years of experience in my IT field now, and I'm in the same spot I grew up with my grandparents in, barely making it with like an extra $40/mo for ramen & beer with a friend or two one night for entertainment. No debt. It's such a common story among my similarly aged friends too. What do we really have to look forward to?
- iamnotacrook 7y ago"What do we really have to look forward to? " More extreme weather, less water, more migration from countries where people have it worse than you, rise in political parties suggesting protectionism and anti-immigrant policies to combat the above, lower quality goods that don't last as long as people chase that margin down, less interesting and interest in art as people lack the spare time to come up with anything remotely non-mainstream, increasingly censored internet, rise in "tropical" diseases such as dengue fever & ebola in non-tropical countries due to climate change, more religion, more random civilian deaths at the hands of marginalised people and the police, people being prevented from travel/shop/work due to unchallengeable blacklisting by corporate CCTV networks with face/gait recognition resulting in homelessness. Yep, there's a storm comin' alright. The only solution I see to this is the richest 1% or so paying everyone else to have no children. It would sort out just about every problem in about 50 years. I don't see another solution.
- Balgair 7y agoAt the risk of talking about suicude and increasing it's potency, the OP is talking about the cluster that occured before 2015 in the Palo Alto area [0]. The linked article is unfortunately paywalled (for me at least). Other clusters have occured since then. Though I cannot find the citation, I remember reading an article that stated that suicide is considered contagious, in that it seems to look just like any other contagious disease. That article further mentioned that suicude in the social media age is much more virulent, I think by ~2000% more contagious. Recently, in Colorado Springs, CO, a teen suicide cluster was allowed to fester for a number of years in the evangelical community. The coroner, respecting the religious wishes of the bereaved, listed the teen suicudes not as suicides per se, and these victims were not included in official stats. The religious community believed that death was not the end and that the victims would live on in heaven. The victim would be lionized and become the 'most popular kid in school' for a while. Finally, the memorialization of the victims was wide spread via social media and the religious community, and was also very public with lots of people attending funerals. The combination of these factors allowed the suicide rate to spike 4900% there [1,2]. Though stress is undoubtably a trigger for suicide, it seems that suicide is very complicated and individual, despite the cluster nature of it. More research has been helpful in preventing this horrible 'disease' from spreading further, and awareness of the issue is being increasingly taught to our youth. If anyone reading this is feeling suicidal, please reach out! In addition to the hotlines (1-800-273-8255), I would like to personally help you. Let me know a good email address and we can talk offline. I really, honestly, do want to help you. [0] https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/12/the-silicon-valley-suicides/413140/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/12/the-sil... [1] https://www.newsweek.com/2016/10/28/teen-suicide-contagious-colorado-springs-511365.html https://www.newsweek.com/2016/10/28/teen-suicide-contagious-... [2] https://gazette.com/education/teen-suicides-spike-in-el-paso-county-in-recent-weeks/article_11dce698-d645-11e8-a3d1-777dded8771c.html https://gazette.com/education/teen-suicides-spike-in-el-paso...
- toejam69420 7y agoI would just like to point out that suicide hotlines can and do call the cops on you if they think you are capable of suicide. If you enjoy bodily autonomy, do not call them. Quite kind of you to offer personal help. I understand you must like participating in the "attention economy" and you should understand that term considering you read The Atlantic. But I'd like to know: what experience do you have with depression and suicide?
- asark 7y agoI went to a totally normal high school and found it to be way more time-consuming and stressful than college. 7+ hours in school and one to two hours of homework much of it due the very next day plus some longer-term stuff you really ought to be working on? It was a very rare day in college when classes, coursework, and studying combined college took up 9 entire hours, and often it was way under that. High school was pretty much always 8 hours, minimum, five days a week. College was so much easier it was kinda shocking. Especially the required 1xx level classes outside my major, which comprised so much of my first year. It was like a vacation. My high school was horribly inefficient, in other words, which ended up being stressful. I gather this is the norm. Meanwhile adults were telling me those were the best years of my life—I mean I wasn't really bullied and had a pretty decent high school experience and now that I'm older I sorta get what they meant but god damn, if that'd actually been true I should have offed myself. The "real world", and college, are easier than high school, which was difficult mostly because it was both hyper-authoritarian and wasted phenomenal amounts of time.
- Aloha 7y agoI remember being so confused when someone told me these would be the best years of my life, I was like "this is it?"
- asark 7y agoI think the worst thing about it was that you could never just chill. It was friggin' relentless. Every day in high school's got a very do-or-die thing going on, for some reason, while at the same time feeling like the lowest-stakes thing possible. It was like stress for the sake of stress. Meanwhile those days are relatively rare in college and real life. Certainly not 5 days a week, every week, unless you seek out jobs like that. Granted the lower end of the job market's a lot less flexible and easy-going than, say, software development, but even that's usually not as bad as high school, which is pretty damning.
- Aloha 7y agoI remember being asked as early as 13 where I wanted to go to college, and what I wanted to do for a living, I'm 36, and I still cant give you the answer to that last question.
- bg4 7y ago"intense academics stole my childhood and didn't have the value that the adults believe they have" Exactly right. We put people on the moon and we did it without grinding 8 year olds with hours and hours of homework. These parents are absolutely relentless on their kids. It's a really sad expression of 'keep up with Joneses'.
- andrey_utkin 7y ago> We put people on the moon and we did it without grinding 8 year olds with hours and hours of homework. Really? Do you mean that typical NASA engineers, astronauts, and other hard-working and gifted people involved in the Great Space Race, typically were not intensely trained, but just had all childhood time full of playing?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wayoutthere 7y agoCompletely agree. There was a big shift in education in the early 2000s that brought business-like accountability to schools in the form of metrics. I think that change alone has led to a hollowing out of our education system that turned it from a nurturing, educational environment into a stressful, performance-focused environment. When you introduce business-like accountability, you need a way to “stack rank” your resources. This process alone is misguided — not all public schools have the same mission, so whatever criteria you come up with removes control of that mission from the local level — and has a lot of second-order consequences. Even in business, all this heavy measurement and reporting causes a ton of overhead — and in schools, this takes the form of standardized testing. This causes a lot of schools to abandon their primary mission — educating students — to pursue a mission of improving standardized test scores by X%. Test prep is hammered home with mountains of homework so teachers don’t get dinged for not challenging students enough. Using business-like incentives (the best-run schools get more budget) is counterintuitive in education: the worst schools need more support, not less. Closing down a low-performing school furthers the goal of meeting the metrics, but often not the goal of educating students. A lot of attention is paid to the impact of this in low-performing schools, but when you give high-performing schools bigger budgets, they just pile more work on the kids as parents apply pressure for intense college prep. So you end up with 2 kinds of schools: one that provides basic services focused on test metrics to keep the little funding they have, and another that has test scores covered through demographic advantages and focuses on college prep because the parents are better educated and more involved in their kids’ lives. Kids are stressed out in both schools — instability and violence in the former, massive expectations and workloads in the latter. But I think the cause is the same: by forcing our kids to operate in a business-like environment, they end up looking a lot like the stressed-out employees of big companies.
- kolbe 7y agoThat anecdote can hardly be considered relevant, no? We're talking about national suicide rates, and you're bringing up a story about a fence that (maybe?) happened at a school in one of the wealthiest districts in the US.
- e40 7y agoI totally agree. Even if you have completely normal parents, the issues you cite are enough to give kids a lot of anxiety. However, if you add to that list any other external problems (tiger mom, deadbeat dad, financial hardship, bullying, etc), it really compounds things and makes it harder to have a positive outlook.