5 ms·
> Gerontologists are not hoping to end death, he says. Instead, “We’re interested in people not getting sick when they get old.” Yes, an increased healthspan i
by clouddrover 7y ago
> Gerontologists are not hoping to end death, he says. Instead, “We’re interested in people not getting sick when they get old.”
Yes, an increased healthspan is a better initial goal than an increased lifespan.
- raducu 7y agoFunny because there's bible psalm (psalm 90 in the west, 89 in the eastern orthodoxy) stating the lifespan of humans is 70, above that and all you get is pain and tiredness (I think the western translations are stating that all life is like that).
- haylel 7y agoI'm not christian so I don't know the topic well but what about the people who lived 900 years like Methuselah and Noah?
- raducu 7y agoI was not talking from a religious perspective, I thought it was funny because I found the 70 year-good-life (health-wise) to be very accurate even in modern times; to me it seems the psalmist simply recorded what he saw around him (just like the Book of Ecclesiasticus is a very sobering/"uninspired" perspective of a "simple" man, very much unlike most of the bible). The religious explanation for the longer lives of early humans, I think it is that there were very few people and they needed the longer lifespans in order to reproduce more and somehow humanity became more degenerate down the line; also back then people could marry their sisters so I suppose there were very few recessive genes (guess that could also contribute to the longer lifespans) :) ? So perhaps the DNA could be somehow cleaned up and people could live 900 year life-spans ? Also, in a post messianic age, in the Old Testament it was written than people dying in their 120th year would be considered to die young (I vaguely remember reading that just because in the christian post-messianic age you wouldn't die at all)?
- Erlich_Bachman 7y agoOf all the good and useful things that religious texts are (and there are a lot), surely it would be a hard argument to sell that exact factual depictions of life was one of them. These texts are used as stories to pump up the spirit, teach connection, oneness, useful life skills and outlooks, but do you really think it was accurate descriptions of how life was? If so, why? What data have you seen to assume that when a religious text writes about someone who lived for 800 years - it is not just a poetic device? There is nothing we have seen in biology or evolutionary science that this was possible.
- harperlee 7y agoIt was quite surprising for me to read (in Angus Deaton’s The Great Escape - Nobel laureate) that most of the advances on living longer that we have achieved are basically focused on not dying young (baby, infant, adolescent); but that the overall limit has been fixed in its place since hundreds of years ago. Look at the shapes of this and to what do they converge: https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2017/08/Survival-Curves-UK.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2017/08/Survival-Curves-U... (That comes from this article by the way: https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy) Im trying to find a chart of the evolution of age-specific mortality rate that very clearly shows that we have a mortality plateau up until about 30-35 years, and then the rate increases linearly. It is quite humbling. EDIT: This is the best I found: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Gerardo_Chowell/publication/233908090/figure/fig8/AS:306540503420932@1450096359545/The-evolution-of-observed-age-specific-all-cause-mortality-rates-scaled-per-1000.png https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Gerardo_Chowell/publica... It is from Canada. The aforementioned book shows time series of several countries and periods, and helps driving the point home that (non-intentional) adult mortality has been more or less fixed since a long time ago.
- JaumeGreen 7y agoI read somewhere that those years could have just been lunar cicles, so 900 cicles would be about 75 years. Sorry, too long ago to remember the source, and if it has any backing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Erlich_Bachman 7y agoIt is suprising how widespread this misconception is. ALL of (*ok maybe 99%) of "life extensionalists" or longevity enthusiasts are working on extending the useful lifespan, not just the technical heartbeat-covering lifespan. This is a given. What they mean by extending the total lifespan is that it is done using integral methods, improving the overall health of a human, meaning that it will increase total lifespan also, but since it is working on the general health, it will also by extension increase the useful lifespan, because the health at every point in life will increase, and points which were not useful (healthy) before interventions would become useful. This is not something longevity people just "forget", there is no crusade for a mathematical birth-to-death age increase, these people are not stupid.
- Nuzzerino 7y agoI was fortunate to meet him in 2007 at a local futurist meetup. I think you could say he is the epitome of "success through persistence". He's always been good at what he did, but if you go back 10, 20 years you wouldn't normally expect the level of success today to be reachable by his foundation, given how much negative skepticism there has always been around the research.
- nradov 7y agoBut he hasn't actually achieved any success yet. So the negative skepticism is warranted.
- maxander 7y agoWell, yes, in that no one has lived forever yet. :) But that he has established a substantial research foundation and normalized a subject that was virtually fringe science a few decades ago is tremendous success in itself.
- Nuzzerino 7y agoYeah, this is what I was referring to, thanks for clarifying!
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoI'm convinced at this point that most of the conditions and diseases we associated with "old age" are actually a result of lifestyle choices, or at least aggravated by them. Just eat a balanced diet, get regular exercise, and maintain a healthy weight and you'll be better off than the majority.
- melling 7y ago“science progresses one funeral at a time” Many people believe things that simply aren’t true and you can’t convince them otherwise. A new generation comes along and challenges entrenched ideas and progress is made. Perhaps we can grow past this way of thinking? What does the science say about your thoughts on the subject?
- antepodius 7y agoHow much of that effect comes about because people's brains stop being flexible due to age?
- Erlich_Bachman 7y agoThis is for the most part, incorrect. Please see this video of Aubrey de Grey, where he explains that those lifestyle choices you describe, while very helpful, can only increase your chances for your regular long life, and have a relatively small effect at that. They can sometimes have large effect on the negative side, where if we measure effect in people in poor conditions, where they have severely bad lifestyle choices, due to malnutrition or poisoning for example, or complete lack of vitamin sources, etc. Poor lifestyle can severely diminish base lifespan, but a good one cannot increase lifespan by a lot. If your genes are telling you to live to 70, you will not live to 100, no matter how many cabbages you eat or how many days spend hiking in the woods. To really increase lifespan beyond that we need actual new technology. There is no rational model in which the effect of good lifestyle choices would be an argument for not pursuing genetic and otherwise interventions to increase real lifespan. [1] https://www.codereactor.net/aubrey-de-grey-poor-nutrition-takes-a-big-toll-on-your-lifespan-but-excellent-nutrition-only-adds-small-benefit-compared-to-an-average-one/ https://www.codereactor.net/aubrey-de-grey-poor-nutrition-ta...
- melling 7y agoYes, we discussed a similar article a few weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20093668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20093668 For some reason, we converge on the same few observations, most of which have nothing to do with actually increasing the human lifespan.