12 ms·
Burning lignite is the most ridiculous thing you can do. It would literally be better for the climate to import coal from Australia and burn that. There is no p
by adrianN 7y ago
Burning lignite is the most ridiculous thing you can do. It would literally be better for the climate to import coal from Australia and burn that. There is no point in delaying the end of lignite mining until 2038.
We need a massive buildout of wind and solar and we need it now. There are no technological problems left, we just need to spend the money. The 20k coal jobs in Germany would pale against the workforce needed for a rapid switch to renewables.
- viraptor 7y agoCan we keep up with large scale battery production yet? (For places which can't use other energy storage systems) I remember that being a problem a few years ago.
- adrianN 7y agoThere is a tradeoff between a better grid and more storage requirements (it's always windy somewhere, and with a sufficiently smart grid you can match demand to supply better). You probably only need a day or two of battery or hydro storage and can use power-to-gas for long winters. Strategic gas storage infrastructure is already available, and power to gas is a proven technology (with fairly terrible energy efficiency). But you need power-to-gas anyway, because replacing all the old gas infrastructure for heating with heat pumps will take too long. If you speak German, there is a very informative interview with Prof. Quaschning of Scientists for Future here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3EoCKgzLo4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3EoCKgzLo4
- glogla 7y agoSadly gas here means Russia. A lot of people aren't happy about it, since it gives Russia power and more power for Russia is bad for everyone in the world, but especially for Eastern Europe.
- adrianN 7y agoPower-to-gas means independence from Russia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-to-gas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-to-gas
- imtringued 7y agoIt gives Russia a rapidly shrinking amount of power and since those gas dependent countries can always switch back to coal, the risk is basically zero except in a war.
- wtdata 7y agoWell, no, because in Portugal - for instance - the environmentalists are also protesting against Lithium mining.
- vjcbe 7y ago>Burning lignite is the most ridiculous thing you can do. It would literally be better for the climate to import coal from Australia and burn that. It would literally be better to destroy thousands of jobs and depend on another country for some of your energy needs? Well let me dispute that. According to Wikipedia, "27 percent of Germany's electricity came from lignite power plants"
- adrianN 7y agoYes it would literally be better for the climate, as I said. If you don't want to depend on another country for your energy needs, how about you use the abundant resources of wind and solar? They have the benefit of not destroying the livelihood of future generations. Right now about 100k jobs in the wind energy sector in Germany are in immediate danger because the government essentially stopped all new construction. Already 80k jobs in the solar industry are lost to China. So please don't tell me about the 20k jobs in coal (or 60k or whatever if you count secondary industries).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- paganel 7y agoIf those thousands of jobs have big negative externalities then the answer is “yes”. Mining of lignite has very big negative externalities.
- alkonaut 7y agoObviously if you shut fossil plants and import fossil energy that’s a failure. I don’t understand why “jobs” is even a part of the discussion here. What percentage of the workforce is in fossil energy production? Has to be tiny.
- _ph_ 7y agoIt is certainly less than the jobs being created when using reneweable energies. "Jobs" would be a great argument in favour of reneweables, all environmental reasons aside.
- StavrosK 7y agoWe need a massive buildout of nuclear and we need it thirty years ago. Wind and solar aren't nearly as good as nuclear.
- adrianN 7y agoI totally agree. A massive push for nuclear thirty years ago would have been great. Unfortunately it is now too late for this. Nuclear power plants take too long to build, especially in the current political climate in Germany. We also don't have enough nuclear engineers to staff them. Training them also takes years. Nuclear is also more expensive than renewables at this point.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoWhat is the part of nuclear reactors which takes so long to build? If we could somehow high jump the red tape and public backlash how long would it physically take to build? The steam generators, turbine, electric generators, condenser and cooling systems are all more or less the same as they would be in an equivalent coal plant. While I'm sure these things have significant lead times they are essentially off the shelf parts. The secondary containment structure doesn't seem any harder to build than say a suspension bridge. The only real challenge the seems to be the primary containment structure and potentially other elements of the primary heating loop. I heard it mentioned that possibly only Japan had the ability to make these at the moment.
- adrianN 7y agoI'm of course no expert on this, but pressure vessels are very difficult to build and there are just a few locations worldwide that can make them. But you don't need anything particularly difficult to build for construction to take forever. Look at Stutgart 21, or Berlin's airport.
- hanniabu 7y agoOr even the highway in my town that has been under construction for 8 years to add an extra lane to a 1 mile stretch
- zakk 7y ago> We need a massive buildout of wind and solar and nuclear.
- merb 7y agoin germany we do not have a long term storage solution that can safely withstand over 1000s of years for nuclear waste. also capitalisem will always makes the safest nuclear power plant unsafe.
- Luc 7y agoYou don’t have warehouses in Germany?
- techrich 7y agoIf the contract to build the plant is let correctly, then it can be made to be safe. When something is outsourced and it does not work, most of the time the person letting the contract has done a shit job.
- merb 7y agowell we germans do not have a good track of making buildings correctly and safe in the recent past. it either took twice as long and was twice as expensive or it was a complete mess. and this was with things that needs to be less safe than a nuclear power plant. germany lost a lot of knowledge in the construction space thats why I highly doubt that we can make a safe nuclear power plant that might produce less garbadge. also corporate entities grown in power in germany and they try to safe as much money as possible.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zakk 7y ago> in germany we do not have a long term storage solution that can safely withstand over 1000s of years for nuclear waste. A much simpler problem to solve as compared to other challenges due to climate change. You can build a storage big enough to contain all radioactive waste from current and future nuclear power plants probably in less than one year.
- askvictor 7y agoUnfortunately, Australia (in particular, the state of Victoria) also burns lignite :(
- adrianN 7y agoOh damn. I thought Australia has all this high quality anthracite.
- askvictor 7y agoWe do, and that's what we export, but there are also reserves of brown coal which are cheap* and close to Melbourne. *If you ignore the climate cost and unreliability of the aging plants; coal power (both brown and black) in Australia is quite unreliable as the plants are super old and there has been no investment in power infrastructure due to policy uncertainty due to infantile governments. So on hot days, when demand is higher, coal plants break down due to the greater heat. At least you can predict when you'll have wind and solar power available; here coal power is more temperamental.
- techrich 7y agoWind can cause serous issues to birds flying around, and the amount of land that needs to be used for solar is a lot. And that will bring its own issues. https://e360.yale.edu/digest/planting-1-2-trillion-trees-could-cancel-out-a-decade-of-co2-emissions-scientists-find https://e360.yale.edu/digest/planting-1-2-trillion-trees-cou... We could save the planet this way! But we need that room for wind and solar! Nuclear is the only way to go.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoOn the flip side the UK, or Ireland could probably each power all of Europe if they fully built out offshore wind. I'm sure plenty of other country's coasts have similar potential.
- adrianN 7y agoA wind turbine kills about as many birds as a cat. Climate change kills a lot more than just birds.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThe EU can't even commit to the 2050 targets thanks to Poland and Czech Republic's love of coal that shows little sign of change. Hungary's vote is more confusing as I didn't think they had much coal - they're big on nuclear. I wish there was a lot more urgency in responses, we already had 1 year of the IPCC's 12. Edit: Typo
- bamboozled 7y agoCzechoslovakia has not been a thing like 25+ years, look it up.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoClearly I meant Czech Republic. I'm old enough that I've known Czechoslovakia longer. Don't type either much as it goes. :p
- kzrdude 7y agoCzechia is the successor state, not much to fuss about :)
- dgregd 7y ago> thanks to Poland and Czech Republic's love of coal Do you really think that people in these countries _love_ burning coal? Does this attitude help solve the problem? Poland does not have nuclear power plants, therefore it has a bigger problem with the reduction of CO2 emissions than other countries. In addition, Poland has no conditions to produce energy from wind and solar in the winter. Sometimes when I read such comments, I would like Poland to present a plan to buy nuclear power technology from Russia (RBMK-1000 reactors) and to put it along the western border, 50 km from Berlin. PS. Please take into account that in Poland there was no industrial revolution and that is why over the last 150 years Western countries have emitted much more CO2 into the atmosphere.
- ummwhat 7y agoRBMK 1000?! The same model as Chernobyl. No thanks.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoThe main thing protecting brown coal mining in Germany is right wing politicians in Bavaria (CSU) who lobbied hard during the last government formation to form a CSU/CDU/SPD goevernment to keep on burning brown coal. However, sooner or later their numbers may drop low enough that they will either be out of government or governing with the green party. All three parties are currently struggling in the polls. Basically, the second the labor SPD walks away from the current government, this issue will be back on the agenda. These protests are targeted at them to do exactly that and the SPD has been bleeding voters to the green party for years. The coal protests are really hurting them. Alternatively, the solar and wind economics may just kill it off way before 2038. Lots of coal plants are already shutting down because of that all over the planet. German ones will not be an exception. Several of the companies behind this stuff have already been aggressively divesting. E.g. RWE knows full well it has a huge problem with rising cost, the probability of fines/fees, and the inevitable outcome of them shutting down this part of their business. They're just buying time to get out without too much damage. Either way, I doubt burning brown coal, or most kinds of coal, will continue all the way until 2038. Nuclear is unlikely to happen in Germany. They just got rid of that. There's no public support for it and the economics are just wrong. It would require billions of investment and take decades to complete. Not going to happen before wind solar deployments catch up with the demise of coal. I don't actually disagree that it might be a good thing to do these investments but I'm realistic enough to realize that this is not going to happen before coal collapses completely in the next two decades. IMHO nuclear fission and fusion may make a comeback some time in the second half of this century; this will be after even the most conservative predictions for solar and wind have replaced coal.
- 08-15 7y ago> Nuclear... would require billions of investment and take decades to complete. As opposed to the cheap and quick Energiewende, which has been going on for a mere three decades by now, cost just 150 billion euro by 2015 and is expected to cost a further 370 billion euro by 2025 (https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article158668152/Energiewende-kostet-die-Buerger-520-000-000-000-Euro-erstmal.html https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article158668152/Energiewende...). Back when Siemens still built nuclear power plants, 500 billion euro would have bought 500GW worth of generation capacity, roughly 2.5x as much as Germany needs to become carbon neutral.
- jseliger 7y agoThere are no technological problems left, we just need to spend the money This is false: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/01/benjamin-zycher-solar-power.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/01/be... and problems include disposal, birds, and the intermittent nature of renewables. Germany has been spending a lot of money and if it had spent equivalently on nuclear it would likely have near-zero power emissions already; a brief note on that: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/01/bit-context-trump-nato.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/01/bi... Europe has the tools to go down towards zero CO2 emissions for power plants but, except for France, has not widely pursued nuclear.
- matt2000 7y agoThere basically _are_ no problems left, it's mainly economic and production volume now. None of those counter points points really hold up under scrutiny: 1) Renewable power _is_ clean. It is also becoming baseload and dispatachable with the addition of batteries. Battery price is on a reducing price curve similar to solar experienced, during which we heard the following progression of arguments: It's too expensive for anything, it's too expensive to matter, it's too expensive for most regions, it's not a solution for everything, ok it's the cheapest source of power but we'll still need natural gas because... batteries are too expensive for anything! 2) Panel disposal is a TINY problem compared to climate change. Panel disposal is also TINY compared to environmental damage of other energy sources. Nuclear would have been nice, but it's probably too late for that now, not worth the downsides, and also we don't need it (see battery price curve).
- tarsinge 7y agoI don’t know if it’s too late for nuclear but in France the pair renewables / nuclear complement each other pretty well without batteries [1] (even if the renewable part can be improved). [1] An interesting twitter thread with an analysis of how the systems adapt depending on the conditions (in French sorry) : https://twitter.com/tristankamin/status/1102620969808658432 https://twitter.com/tristankamin/status/1102620969808658432
- microcolonel 7y ago> There are no technological problems left, we just need to spend the money. With current technology, it is an unimaginable sum of money, if you're talking about building a balance of renewables and batteries to meet current baseline load targets.
- adrianN 7y agoThe damages done by global warming can not be undone no matter how much money you throw at them. I don't think spending a couple percent of your GDP for the next twenty to thirty years on preventing that is too expensive.
- microcolonel 7y ago> The damages done by global warming can not be undone no matter how much money you throw at them. I don't think spending a couple percent of your GDP for the next twenty to thirty years on preventing that is too expensive. Your estimate of the cost is not even in the right ballpark; even if the circumstances are dire enough to call for such drastic spending, renewables are not even a moderately effective way to eliminate fossil fuel dependence.