6 ms·
"The weapons could even suddenly pierce the steel decks of one of America's 11 multibillion-dollar aircraft carriers, instantly stopping flight operations, a vu
by pmoriarty 7y ago
"The weapons could even suddenly pierce the steel decks of one of America's 11 multibillion-dollar aircraft carriers, instantly stopping flight operations, a vulnerability that might eventually render the floating behemoths obsolete."
Aren't they already obsolete?
- timClicks 7y agoNot at all. They enable the USA to have an almost unparalleled naval capability.
- colechristensen 7y agoIn a real shooting war they are very vulnerable high value targets which exist more for the egos of the upper ranks than for usefulness in combat. They work to intimidate adversaries and defeat much less capable opponents, but are too easily destroyed when coming up against a competent military.
- blackflame7000 7y agoYou need to control the airspace to be successful in war and in order to do that you need to be able to project your power across seas so that the fight is on their doorstep not ours. The carriers are there to make sure that if someone wants to cross the ocean with ill intent, they can deny them the airspace far out at sea making them struggle to even get to the country they seek to attack. The US always prefers to play an away game. Also, don't forget carriers are never alone and surrounded by multiple aegis guided missile cruisers which are the most accurate missile defense systems in existence.
- bhouston 7y agoI think against China or Russia the carriers will be destroyed quite quickly. Against an inferior army like Iran, they will be okay. The purpose of aircraft carriers are more often to launch attacks against inferior nations or highly inferior subnational entities so they are useful there.
- vinceguidry 7y agoThey would have to find them first. That's still non-trivial, even with satellites.
- blackflame7000 7y agoYea, a lot of people underestimate the speed at which a carrier can move. So much so that it would be outside the blast radius of any ICMB targeted at the carriers last known position when the missile is launched. Most ICBMs cant change trajectory mid-flight.
- shdh 7y agoNot a MIRV blanket though.
- chipsa 7y ago/me points to SM-3
- blackflame7000 7y agoProbably need THAAD or GMD for MIRV because of the altitude and speeds
- blackflame7000 7y agoActually yea it can because the more re-entry vehicles you use the smaller the blast radius of each will be. the fireball radius of the largest current US-made warhead is only .71km at 455kt on the Trident missile (W-88). It carries 12 re-entry vehicles which could blanket approximately a 3sq km zone. An aircraft carrier can move at approximately 1km per minute. so you have approximately 90 seconds to launch and hit the target with one of the US's best weapons.
- gruez 7y agoWhy? They are massive objects that has zero camouflage against the ocean. How hard could it be?
- nothrabannosir 7y agoThis comment is being downvoted to grey, but it seems completely in line with TFA. If we acknowledge that “unstoppable” missiles exist, and that aircraft carriers are high value, doesn’t that imply they will be the first to go in an actual war?
- 0815test 7y agoYou're assuming that finding the handful of "high-value" aircraft carriers you want to target is easy, whilst it very much isn't. If that becomes the bottleneck, there are lots of possible defenses.
- bhouston 7y agoGreat Powers can hit while they still have their satellites. But in a real hot war, there will be a race to take those satellites all out as well. In a real hot war between Great Powers, the ability to destroy will be quite huge, especially against strategic targets, compared to defense abilities.
- reddog 7y agoJust because they are vulnerable in an all out war doesn't mean they are not useful. After all something like 12 USN carriers were sunk in WWII but every military historians would agree they were pivotal in winning the war in the pacific.
- fit2rule 7y agoIt is widely acknowledged in war-fighting circles that America's aircraft careers are only useful in policing actions - i.e. to be used as a threat of war, and not actually of any use in conditions of total war, since they are big, fat, slow moving high-value targets that can easily be taken out with widely deployed missiles designed for the job - i.e. the P-270 MOSKIT (SS-N-22 Sunburn) missiles, which Russia developed specifically to counter the threat. Americans don't like to be told this, nor will they work to understand it beyond a glib "America, Fuck yeah!" style response, but the American naval surface fleet is probably one of the first casualties in an all-out war. The MOSKIT is deployed specifically to target these carriers, and there is - so far - no defence against them. Laser-based defences are being developed to defend against the threat, but are not widely deployed across the fleet. America will lose its carriers in the first minutes of all-out war. http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carriers-will-die/ http://exiledonline.com/the-war-nerd-this-is-how-the-carrier...
- wbl 7y agoThe RAM and CWIS systems are designed to deal with the threat. Also you assume the launch platforms can't be targeted. They can be.
- fit2rule 7y agoOf course, all platforms can be targeted, that is the point of open warfare. >RAM and CWIS Yeah, jury is still out on the MOSKVIT survivability, but hey .. lets hope we never find out.
- mrguyorama 7y agoHow proven and tested is the phalanx and similar against "real" Carrier killers? Hell, even the iron dome isn't super reliable. Compare the price of one carrier to 100 ship killing missiles.
- adrianN 7y agoYes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002
- dmos62 7y agoThat's a remarkable story. Wiki says there's a 2004 documentary about it called The Perfect War. Unfortunately the relevant reference (6) is dead, and I can't find even a mention of this documentary outside the wiki article. I'd love to see it.
- thunderbird120 7y agoNo. The Millennium Challenge is typically cited as an example of a badly botched exercise rather than a real world defeat scenario. It had: Navy ships constrained to small areas to prevent disruption to commercial craft which would never be the case in an actual war Small boats firing simulated cruise missiles weighing significantly more than the entire boats supposedly carrying them. Motorcycle based messengers "simulated" by just using radios except no one bothered to add any kind of message delay or any other kind of constraint a motorcycle messenger might have compared to radio communication. USN ships in the simulation teleporting into the center of a massive armada of simulated small boats due to a modeling error All ship defenses being turned off during the engagement resulting from said error because everything was in the wrong place. None of the USN ships even knowing that they were supposedly under attack until the "battle" was over. Ships being "re-floated" as a result of the above screw up It's generally unwise to try to draw any conclusions at all, positive or negative, based on its results. Also, there's a reason countries all over the world continue to build aircraft carriers. It's because they're useful. A carrier group essentially controls a moving sphere of territory with a radius of around 500nmi. Being able to launch dedicated AWACS[1] allows for far superior battlefield awareness compared to any other naval asset and air launched anti-ship missiles allow for striking range far greater than any other naval asset. Carrier groups are also a lot harder to find than you might think. Nuclear powered carriers are fast, faster than almost any other ships, and don't stay in one place. Keeping tabs on them is difficult, even if you have satellites. In the open ocean they're very difficult to confront because they will almost know more about the locations of opposing forces than the opposing forces know about their location thanks to real time aerial recon. The horizon is as far as radars can usually see and if you're in a plane that horizon is much further away. Carriers are not going away any time soon. They provide far too much utility which is not offered by any other kind of ship. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_E-2_Hawkeye https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_E-2_Hawkeye
- benj111 7y agoDefine obsolete. You could make the case that ICBMs make conventional armies obsolete, and I would guess many people in the 50s/60s did. In a similar vein, videoconferencing, email, telephones should make international business travel obsolete. That shows no sign of happening either. I guess because humans react differently to things that are right in front of them, rather than remote and hypothetical.
- joyjoyjoy 7y ago"Aren't they already obsolete?" Yes. http://www.johntreed.net/sittingducks.html http://www.johntreed.net/sittingducks.html
- imtringued 7y agoEverything is obsolete in the face of nuclear weapons.