4 ms·
Can someone explain what this provides to users over, say, a credit or debit card? You don't have the rebellious notions of sticking it to traditional banks, n
by jayd16 7y ago
Can someone explain what this provides to users over, say, a credit or debit card?
You don't have the rebellious notions of sticking it to traditional banks, not do you have (completely imagined) anonymity crypto fans have gravitated to. You don't have any of the intangibles crypto fans like.
It just seems like Facebook wants a central bank. Who's asking for that?
- gst 7y agoDirect peer-to-peer payments: Those are currently a nightmare when you regularly travel. US: Venmo, Europe: SEPA, China: Wechat, etc. If Facebook manages to sign up enough stakeholders from different countries (that provide gateways between Libra and traditional bank accounts in their respective countries) Libra would provide a viable global alternative to the currently very fragmented market.
- hrktb 7y agoCan’t that be done through easily through Paypal ? (or Western Union, I just never tried)
- deif 7y agoYou need a bank account with Paypal still. This is direct payment into your personal virtual wallet (supposedly not linked to your real identity) avoiding all banks.
- hrktb 7y agoDepending on your country you don’t. Paypal needs a bank or a card, and for instance in France cards can be prepaid (supermaket chains can make their own). All of that will be tied to a real identity, but I am not sure Libra will also be completely free of these ties. There must be a point where to use your wallet you’ll have to justify your identity (i.e. above some amount or some kind of purchases you hit KYC requirements)
- gst 7y agoPayPal is not available in a lot of countries (Turkey would be one example). Western Union might work, but the fees are high and there's much more friction. In case you're based in the United States: Would you use Western Union over Venmo / Square Cash. If you're based in Europe: Would you use Western Union over SEPA? Libra has the potential to provide a low friction environment (like Venmo) supported by local companies that's available globally. And while Libra definitely isn't perfect I think the set of trade-offs they chose are pretty reasonable. Another advantage over Venmo, Western Union, etc. is that the Libra will be run by a multiple independent companies, instead of locking you into a single company which is the case with the currently existing solutions (with the exception of SEPA).
- palunon 7y ago> If you're based in Europe: Would you use Western Union over SEPA ? At least in France, people actually use apps like Venmo for person to person transfers (or cash, or cheques, but they're on their way out). We mostly use SEPA for either automatic bill payment authorization, or big transfers. No one will start a bank transfer and ask for their friends IBAN to pay back two beers.
- jayd16 7y agoFair enough. That's a hypothetical at this point though, isn't it?
- Theodores 7y agoIt is unlikely that you will need to sit in a bank and fill out forms to get a card. You will have no more hoops to go through than in-game tokens. Which makes me wonder, why haven't there been in-game tokens made universal yet? I don't do Facebook but didn't they once have a large Zynga game thing on the go, very much tied into the platform? A monopoly on a virtual currency should have happened by now, one that only buys stuff in games, unlocking features etc., transferable to mates. If this had happened then it would not be that much of a leap to make the virtual token be handy for real world things. Crypto-nonsense would not be needed, it could just be like a classic in-game token. If the tokens can be cashed out to hard currency great. But some people might never need to do that. They could buy music and apps with mummy and daddy doing the top ups.
- buboard 7y ago> transferable to mates That would be a big no no and would ring money laundering alarms > If the tokens can be cashed out to hard currency great. Again, regulators, that's why Libra has the association and needs to back up each transaction. In reality the payment processors take so big a cut that a virtual coin would not be very profitable. Plus you have to manage everyone's complaints and chargebacks. Facebook had FB credits but they scrapped it, presumably because it was not good business. There are some smaller companies who manage virtual coins on behalf of games, like superrewards.com . They take a big cut, but also save developers a lot of trouble.
- PeterisP 7y agoIn-game tokens can be legally treated as just part of the game because they can't be transferable to mates and cashed out to hard currency. As soon as (for example) Zynga claims that tokens can be cashed out for hard currency or used to buy arbitrary real-world things outside of that game, that would mean that all kinds of money-related regulations would start to apply for them. For example, many game mechanics that include these tokens and randomness would fall under gambling laws; and money laundering/KYC laws would start to be relevant. That's why pretty much every company offering such tokens will pinky-swear that they're not redeemable for cash and real world things, and take at least some visible action to combat any black market for such sales lest they'd be considered aiding money laundering. In essence, you can't really have your cake and eat it too - there can be a cryptopunk-ideal digital currency but pretty much every legitimate business selling real world things would be prohibited from touching it (at least in nontrivial amounts, if they don't do their own deanonymization of customers like all the legitimate Bitcoin exchanges do); or you can have a digital currency that's usable on a scale (like Libra) but it can be that way only by implementing KYC (i.e. anti-anonymity) and AML (i.e. possibility for censoring payments).
- buboard 7y agobut it is pegged to other central banks, what kind of central bank is that? The only positive that i see about Libra is that it will (hopefully) be exchangeable for some real uncensorable coin.
- jayd16 7y agoIt's only pegged as much as they so choose. If you can change your own exchange rates day to day, the consortium can buy and sell fiat currency in such a way as to cause inflation or deflation. It's all the same power without a physical mint, is it not?
- ilaksh 7y agoVisa, MasterCard, PayPal, and governments are asking for a way to combat real cryptocurrencies from taking over. Because Bitcoin and Ethereum are making major pushes to increase scalability. The payment processors can't profit from real cryptocurrency and governments can't control it. They are mainly trying to catch up with WeChat Pay etc. But they figured it would be good to pretend it is a cryptocurrency because that makes it seem like an alternative to real cryptocurrency which it is not.