4 ms·
It is generally thought that an incarcerated condemned prisoner cannot consent to anything without the cloud of coercion being present.
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
It is generally thought that an incarcerated condemned prisoner cannot consent to anything without the cloud of coercion being present.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoI'd say it is possibly if there are no consequences to the decision, and the condemned prisoner has trust in that situation. It's hard to construct such a scenario. I am completely against the death penalty, in all circumstances. I still believe that the allegations against China made here are orders of magnitude worse than "just" harvesting organs from executed donors. That would be mainly a violation of the victims post-mortem rights or dignity. The alleged practice involves doctors and hospitals cooperating in the preparation and execution of the death penalty. That is a fundamental violation of medical ethics. In the US, doctors are forbidden to participate in executions. And apparently at least the timing of the executions in China, if not even the decision whether to execute a prisoner or not, seems to be affected by the demand for organs. It's always hard to make a judgement about what wrong is worse, but I'd say here we have a clear "winner".