14 ms·
One of the trends that I can only hope continues is getting rid of this idea that home ownership (especially single family home ownership) is the American dream
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
One of the trends that I can only hope continues is getting rid of this idea that home ownership (especially single family home ownership) is the American dream.
I live in and own a detached single family home (was a compromise with my spouse) and to be honest, I hate it. I hate having to take care of the yard, to deal with unreliable tradespeople when things break, to deal with the huge expense of minor home repairs - and this is even after outsourcing as much of that work as possible.
Compare that to renting an apartment, which I loved. If something broke, I just called the super, and that was that. This ridiculous idea that renting is "throwing money away" is absurd. I'm paying someone to deal with all the shit I absolutely don't want to deal with, and more importantly I'm paying for the freedom to easily up and move if something else fits my fancy.
- maxsilver 7y agoI also hate maintaining a detached single family home with a yard. I also hate being responsible for the fixes. But that situation is still far better than renting. When we rented, we were subjected to eviction at any time, for nearly any reason, for basically no notice (60 days, which in the US is effectively zero notice). Your subjected to every whim the crazy wildly-irrational housing market throws at you (we've had 12% yearly rental increases for a decade straight now, despite living in bumblefudge-nowhere Midwest). Renting in the US today is capital-e Evil, and just wholly broken. Unless we're ready to implement some guaranteed nationwide rent controls and guarantees against unjust eviction and harassment, making housing ownership possible for all citizens has to be the number 1 goal. Because home/condo ownership is the only way to gain any sort of housing security in most of the USA today.
- Balgair 7y ago> we've had 12% yearly rental increases for a decade straight now, despite living in bumblefudge-nowhere Midwest Quick math for the rest of you out there: That means they paid 1000 in 2009 and now pay ~3500 in 2019. Also, yes, I feel you there. Our rental agreement states a mandatory 10% increase if you rent from year to year. I've no idea why the company is this stupid though. The rents around us are falling or staying steady these days. So we just move to the block over every year and the old place stays empty for 3 months before then being rented out for the same or less than we paid. I'm sure there is some tax thing involved here that makes it so they don't have to care all that much. Also, yeah, we don't have a lot, and we can just move houses in about a weekend in my 4-door.
- andechs 7y agoIt's similar to a telecommunications giant - as the customer, you need to pay a cost of switching (moving expenses, hookup fees etc.). So it's in their best interests to try to squeeze customers when possible, even with the occasional person that moves out, they'll net a lot more from tenants who just don't bother to dispute the increase.
- Balgair 7y agoTrue! We've decided to be nimble, and it does take a toll (no pool tables, no big patio furniture, smaller couches, etc). But saving the cash is worth it to us. 12% on 1000k/mo rent comes out to an extra 1440/year that could be saved. To us, such a thing is worth the weekend of moving hell.
- malvosenior 7y agoDon't you also lose a lot of the deposit money you put down on the old apartment and the services that went along with it though? Not to mention that moving is more than a weekend of shuttling around possessions (if you don't own much), you also have to change your address with everyone, sign up for new utilities... I always burn a lot of money and time when moving.
- Balgair 7y ago> Don't you also lose a lot of the deposit money you put down on the old apartment and the services that went along with it though? Wait, what? It's a deposit, you get it back at the end of the lease. Like, granted, if you have a lot of damage to the carpets, sure, you're gonna be out $80 for the cleaning of them. But I've always gotten it back in full after a month or so. For me, moving is litterally a weekend (maybe including a Friday afternoon). We really don't have much to move. I'm not joking. Also, my state allows you to just forward the mail to the new address for free. It only lasts a year, but you can re-up that at any time. We've just done that without much worry and we also have a lot of online stuff that works through the phones and whatnot. I guess I'm just old hat at doing this kinda moving stuff. It's not much stress for me, though you are right, it is some extra stress. For us, it's worth the savings.
- LarryDarrell 7y agoThe thing I've noticed is that in my area all the modest neighborhoods (2 bed, 1 bath, sub $200k) are being bought up by landlords. This leads to a neighborhood of renters, which is a lot different than a neighborhood of owners. The Havers can buy a lot more houses than the Have-Nots and I'm left wondering what the price of single family homes would be if renting them was illegal and they were all placed on the market.
- Animats 7y agoYes. That's a "private equity" thing.[1] Blackrock can borrow at lower rates than homeowners. So they can buy up houses and rent them out at a profit. Plus they can keep raising the rent. And they outsource maintenance. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/02/single-family-landlords-wall-street/582394/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/02/singl...
- nroets 7y agoThe agency cost of any landlord is much larger than the savings in capital cost. For example, for a tenant there is an incentive to complain over the smallest problem instead of fixing himself or just living with the problem. Management agents charge a fortune to deal with these issues.
- treis 7y agoIt's another example of the high cost of being poor. The rent on my town home is several thousand more per year than what a mortgage (5% down), taxes, HOA fee, PMI, and home insurance would be.
- drtillberg 7y agoThink of it instead as a player closer to the money printing machine that is the fractional reserve banking system. This is the inflation the Fed created directly, and these institutions probably are thinking: 'housing prices only go up, so the duration of my borrowing doesn't matter, borrow short term buy long term, it's all gravy!' If you're over 30 and feel like you've heard this story before, you have....
- esoterica 7y agoPrice controls do not work. High home prices are a symptom of a lack of available housing and the only way to fix the lack of housing is by building more housing.
- mcguire 7y agoHigh home prices are often a symptom of easy money and inflation localized to that sector. (Specifically, the houses described in the article seem to be poster children of this type.) That was the whole 2008 thing, right?
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> we've had 12% yearly rental increases for a decade straight now That was part of the motivation for buying my first house. The rent was going up $50/month every 6 months, and the mortgage was going to cost only $100/month more than the rent. I figured in a year I'd break even, and in 2 years I'd be ahead.
- anthonypasq 7y agolol at assuming mortgage is the only expense to owning a house
- thousandautumns 7y agoMore like lol at assuming your rent doesn't cover the other expenses of owning a house. You think your landlord is just taking the loss? When you rent, you are paying, if not directly, for every expense associated with the house, plus extra for the landlords profit margin.
- refurb 7y agoThe rental market and the home buying market as separate and not perfectly correlated. In SF right now, it's cheaper to rent than to buy, so yes, if a landlord bought today and rented it out they'd be taking a loss. The thing is that landlords may have purchased the place a long time ago. They can still make a profit with rent being less than what a mortgage+ would be today.
- cblum 7y ago>housing security There is no such thing unless your home is paid off. If you have a mortgage and are hit by a catastrophic life event that leaves you without a job and depleted of your emergency fund, your home is gone.
- elsonrodriguez 7y agoIf you stop paying rent your ass is on the street in days. Stop paying your mortgage and it can be months or years.
- jnwatson 7y agoIt takes at least 60 days in most areas of the US to evict a tenant.
- radcon 7y ago> If you have a mortgage and are hit by a catastrophic life event that leaves you without a job and depleted of your emergency fund, your home is gone. That risk exists regardless of whether you rent or own. The risks he mentioned are unique to rentals. It's very common for leases to essentially say "We can kick you out if we feel like it," no justification necessary. Even if the lease stipulates some justification, they'll find a way around it ("Our maintenance crew noted your excessive noise on 37 separate occasions. You also have a wreath hanging on your door, which is another violation of the lease."). It's extremely rare for a mortgage to contain any sort of terms that allow you to be arbitrarily kicked out of your home.
- saltminer 7y agoThe mortgage might be more secure, but an HOA can turn your life upside down if it's run by power-hungry busybodies and they can destroy the property values of the whole neighborhood while they're at it.
- mcguire 7y agoI've lived in several HOAs in the past, and yeah, they can be a pain. But in my experience, they are mostly concerned with not destroying the property values. In practice, they're only interested in stuff that's egregiously stupid. (Say that crazy old lady with the weird, creepy Halloween decorations including the beheaded baby that stay out from Labor Day to New Years.) Plus, it's easy enough to avoid HOAs.
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoWere you a month to month tenant? If not, why would you sign a lease that lets the landlord break it with 60 days notice? Doesn't that kind of defeat the purpose of having a lease in the first place?
- jandrese 7y agoEvery lease I've seen has a provision that allows the Landlord to kick you out if you are deemed to be a nuisance. IIRC there are renters rights in many areas that make this more difficult, requiring a court order typically, but not all areas have this and Landlords will put those clauses in the lease regardless just in case the tenants aren't familiar with the law.
- tathougies 7y agoI mean, most HOAs will kick you out if you are deemed to be a nuisance, as can a city council.
- jandrese 7y agoHOAs don't have the power to evict you from your own house. They might act like they do, but they don't. Their power basically ends at sending sternly worded letters and in exceptional cases putting a lien on the property. If the homeowner just ignores their letters they can't do much.
- tathougies 7y agoYes, they can? An HOA is added to the deed agreement. A typical HOA will be allowed to put a lien on the house if you do not pay them the agreed upon fee, and -- crucially -- whatever other fees they determine. Thus, if an HOA wants to kick you out for any reason, they mostly just have to continue to fine you until you can no longer pay, at which point they ask a judge, and take the house.
- jnwatson 7y ago
- madengr 7y agoFrom a different perspective, 60 days is too long if you are a landlord trying to evict a drug user who has not paid rent in 60 days. I’d like to invest in rental property, but would never want to be a landlord. My mother rented out a house and the renter trashed it.
- imgabe 7y agoI know landlord-tenant laws vary a lot, but how could you be subject to random evictions with only 60-day notice? Most places I've lived, you sign a one year lease. The landlord can't evict you while the lease is in effect as long as you are abiding by the terms of the lease.
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoYou must not live in Georgia or the South.
- imgabe 7y agoRental contracts are not valid in the South and one party can unilaterally end the agreement for no reason? That really sucks, if so.
- mcguire 7y agohttps://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/the-eviction-process-georgia-rules-landlords-property-managers.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/the-eviction-process... Georgia: "If a landlord does not have cause to terminate a tenancy early and evict a tenant, then the landlord must wait until the lease term has ended before expecting the tenant to move. In some cases, the landlord may still need to give the tenant written notice to move. "Month-to-Month Tenancy "If a tenant is in a month-to-month tenancy and the landlord wishes to end the tenancy, the landlord needs to give the tenant a written 60-day notice. This notice will inform the tenant that the landlord is terminating the tenancy and the tenant must move out of the rental unit by the end of 60 days. If the tenant does not move out of the rental unit by that time, then the landlord can file an eviction lawsuit with the court (see Ga. Code Ann. § 44-7-7). For more information on this topic, check out Georgia Notice Requirements to Terminate a Month-to-Month Tenancy. "Fixed-Term Tenancy "If a landlord does not have cause to evict a tenant who is in a fixed-term tenancy (such as for six months or one year), then the landlord must wait until the end of the term before expecting the tenant to move. The landlord does not need to give the tenant written notice to move unless the terms of the lease or rental agreement specifically require the landlord to do so. The landlord can expect the tenant to move by the end of the term."
- rifung 7y ago> When we rented, we were subjected to eviction at any time, for nearly any reason, for basically no notice (60 days, which in the US is effectively zero notice). Your subjected to every whim the crazy wildly-irrational housing market throws at you (we've had 12% yearly rental increases for a decade straight now, despite living in bumblefudge-nowhere Midwest). Not saying you're wrong but at least where I've lived, I could very easily find a new place to live in 60 days. I think usually landlords give the terms of a new lease much less than 60 days away from the end of the current lease, and most people usually don't decide to move or stay before they know how much their current place is going to cost.
- whenchamenia 7y agoFor a family, 60 days to pack everythig you own, and move, while supporting everyone is not easy at best, and untenable at worst. When I was single this was not the case.
- realityenigma 7y agoThis doesn't pass the BS test, especially if you are local. I have moved across town; with a family and a day job, in around 15 days, with most of the move taking place the first 7. Out of town, I can see 30 - 45. It would require planning and a UHaul (if within 250 miles) and a semi-truck moving company if further out than that. It literally just takes a bit of planning and follow through.
- jstarfish 7y agoThere are a lot more hoarders in this country than anybody will admit. Some people will never move at all because the thought of having to "go through all our stuff and pack it all" is too daunting. I do not see how this possibly applies to renters though.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI'm right there beside you - I'm coming on two years of home ownership, and I'm not terribly enjoying it. I love the neighbourhood, but I just don't think I'm cut out for home ownership. I've had more problems in 2 years of home ownership than I had in a decade of renting. It's cost a ton more money. Is it an investment? Possibly, but I've sunk a fair bit into it as well. I now wake up on Saturday mornings with a list of things that I "really need to get to". It's been terrible for my mental health, and I don't know if my bank account will ever reflect the extra mental strain.
- radar 7y agoIt's not an investment if you live in the property.
- scarface74 7y agoYes and no. I don’t consider a home an investment in the traditional sense. I do consider a paid off house to be worth the amount of money that I would have to save to have a safe rate of return to live somewhere minus maintenance and property taxes. If a paid off house will save me $12000 a year. The value of that house to me is $12000/.04 Also, a house is a great inflation hedge. Rent goes up with the market. The mortgage stays the same. Property taxes and insurance can go up.
- nostrademons 7y ago> Also, a house is a great inflation hedge. Rent goes up with the market. The mortgage stays the same. Property taxes and insurance can go up. It's actually even better than that: if inflation goes up, you pay back the mortgage with cheaper dollars than you bought it with. If you're expecting higher inflation in the future (and it hasn't yet been priced into interest rates) a house is a great purchase. The flip side is that if you get deflation (say, an economic recession hits and a lot of people in your area lose theirs jobs, possibly including you), a house is a leveraged asset, and you can quickly lose everything. As many homeowners found out in 2009.
- justjash 7y agoYeah, just sold our home this month in the Midwest and moved into a townhouse that we rent for now. We did end up making a little money (bought in 2016) due to the great market we were in but I think that was just luck for the most part. The issue with fixes gets even worse when you live in an older city and most of the homes are 80+ years old. It was a nightmare when you start to think about all the little things that are eventually going to need repaired/replaced in the not so distant future. For now I am happy not having to do any yard work and only having to pay and electric and internet bill. The simplicity is great but I do miss having a little more space for storage/hobbies.
- scarface74 7y agoThose two complaints are easy to fix. Get a yard service - I pay $150 a month for them to come twice a month. Get a home warranty - it’s about $600 a year and they fix everything - appliances, hot water heaters, plumbing, etc. I haven’t purchased one for current home because it’s a new build, but I did for furnished rental property I previously owned. In the grand scheme of things for an owner occupied home it’s probably not a great deal but it’s worth the peace of mind for some.
- LeifCarrotson 7y agoDo not get a home warranty. It's about $600 a year and they do nothing when you report an issue. When you call to complain, they send a contractor. Who doesn't show up. When the third contractor they promise to send finally shows up, they're the cheapest contractor they could find in 100 miles and they make the problem worse. Finally you threaten to sue and they close the policy and give you cash in lieu of replacement and you take care of it yourself. It very often costs a lot more than $600 to maintain a home for a year. The warranty service only makes money if they can spend less than that on the home. As a result, the biggest and most profitable warranty companies are the ones that promise the most and spend the least.
- scarface74 7y agoI had two furnished rental properties and I never had any problems with them.
- theandrewbailey 7y agoThat must be a huge yard, or is there some landscaping involved?
- scarface74 7y agoNot a huge yard by any means. Heck, now that I’m looking, it is overpriced.....
- larrywright 7y ago
- LarryDarrell 7y agoWhen I call the super they drag their feet, do a half-assed job, take a dump in my bathroom, and then I get a rent increase for "improvements" they've made to the property. I used to own a 1000 sq ft cape cod that was built in 1942. I fixed everything myself and since it was small, nothing could really get out of hand. I believe most of the pain involved in home owning lately has come from bigger houses with more complex systems/appliances.
- ip26 7y agoEven worse, they make them bigger for the same price by cutting quality.
- asark 7y agoAnd walls. "Open concept" might look great in photos and provide good "wow" factor, and it's definitely cheaper to build, but it's also a great way to make a lot of square footage feel small when you live in it. Contrast smaller, older houses with lots of smaller rooms, which can often feel as big as much larger, newer houses. Unfortunately, at least in our market, there's not much built in the last 20 years where the builders favored actual rooms instead of just one giant open public space. If you're lucky the basement's finished so maybe you get two of those.
- JeffreyKaine 7y agoWhat would you use all of the extra rooms for? One room for each person to sleep, a laundry room, a couple bathrooms, and a great room with living, dining, and kitchen is all you ever really need right?
- C1sc0cat 7y agoYour paying for the Super as part of your rent/service charge (and get no choice in who fixes your stuff) but you can you know pay some one to do the plumbing if you own your own home.
- roasm 7y agoThis seems like a great area for disruption. You can imagine a property manager for a homeowner who you call for anything. They can charge a monthly fee plus a percentage on top of any (vetted) subs they use. A single person can probably juggle dozens to hundreds of homes; then scale that. It's the services of a rental property manager without the rental part. With adults these days (me included) being more technically savvy but less... handy, it seems perfect.
- cglace 7y agoYou can get a home warranty that will cover a lot of the systems in your home.
- nowarranty 7y agoAs someone who has been through the pain of using a home warranty I highly recommend against it. When we had one we found one of 2 things always happened: 1. Whatever broke wasn't covered by the warranty. For example on a fridge, the most common component to break is the compressor, and that's not covered by a home warranty because it costs just slightly less than the cost of a refrigerator to repair. 2. The warranty company gets to choose who fixes your problem and they choose the lowest bidder, which is almost always a person who doesn't have better work to do because they aren't very good. Every single time I've used a home warranty, I had to have someone come back and re-do the work because it was so shoddy. YMMV, but I've heard similar stories from others who have used them. I now consider a home warranty to be a negative rather than a positive because I've had to pay another person to come in and fix something correctly that was done improperly by a home warranty repair person.
- cglace 7y agoAll the time I used my warranty the work done was fine. You do have to pay a service fee for them to come out which is annoying.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoSuch things exist. I hear ads for them on the radio. They pitch themselves as "maintenance insurance" or some such, but I think it would do what you're asking.
- newsoul2019 7y agoAm I the only one who has always seen renting as a temporary arrangement only? If you don't own something, somewhere, doesn't that mean the same as being homeless? Not trying to offend anyone. Genuinely wondering, are there people who really don't want to own real estate ever in their lives?
- mulmen 7y agoI've been renting for a long time and I have never considered myself to be homeless. When it rains I generally stay dry. I'm not sure how renting implies or is in any way similar to homelessness. I still have the means to provide shelter for myself. I could even rent a hotel room for quite a while, long enough to find a new place for sure. I don't see how the risk of being evicted (is this something people worry about?) is any greater than the numerous possible disasters that could strike a place you own in ways renters don't have to worry about.
- pnutjam 7y agoHow many kids do you have? I have 6 and moving in the elementary school district is a huge pain. There aren't alot of rentals and big surprise, nobody wants to rent to someone with 6 kids. Not only is 60 days notice not enough time. The landlords require 60 to 90 days notice and of course every rental wants you to move in immediately. In my experience, it's rare to find someone advertising a rental more then 30 days out from availability.
- stale2002 7y agoNo? It give me freedom to rent. At any point that I feel like it, I can pick up and move. Whether it is to a place across the street or on the other side of the country. I wouldn't have nearly that much freedom if I had the misfortune of owning my own place.
- newsoul2019 7y agoDo you see this as a temporary or permanent situation in your life? What is your "end game" so to speak?
- robrtsql 7y ago> paying for the freedom to easily up and move if something else fits my fancy. There is something to be said for this. However, there is also something to be said for the ability to not be kicked out of your living space directly ("we have decided not to renew your lease") or indirectly ("should you renew your lease, we will be increasing rent by $500 and installing smart locks in every apartment").
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoI totally agree with you. Certainly there are tradeoffs to both owning and renting, and different people will find the tradeoffs stronger in one direction or the other. However, the reason I made my original comment is I feel that so often, at least in the US, the downsides of home ownership are completely minimized (I think people usually vastly underestimate maintenance costs, both in time and money) while the downsides of renting are blown out of proportion (the "you're just throwing money away" false comparison).
- epicureanideal 7y agoFree startup idea: property management for your own single family home. "I want to own, but I don't want to deal with all this stuff."
- ip26 7y agoI hate mowing. I don't care about lawns. But I like being in control. No more moving every year to keep rent low. Update & customize to meet my desires & save money. Grow a garden & wildflowers. Remember the names of my neighbors (because the neighborhood isn't a revolving door). But, I've always loved the long game. Plant trees for shade in ten years. Build a pergola (more shade, cooler house). Replace the old crappy X with a higher quality model that will pay for itself in five years. So on & so forth. You do have to learn to do some of the work yourself, because tradesmen are more trouble than they are worth for small jobs.
- lazyjones 7y agoIf you hate mowing and have the space, consider getting some https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouessant_sheep https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouessant_sheep ... They’re cute too.
- Frost1x 7y agoHome and property ownership are deeply tied to some of your fundamental rights given as a citizen in the US. Many freedoms granted to you can be superceded once property is owned by other private entities because they require a spatial context. Take gun ownership or something less controversial: a grill. If you own the home, you can grill to your heart's content. If you rent, there's likely all sorts of rights you forfeit in a contractual agreement (lease) and using a grill is often explicitly banned (it's a fire hazard and doesn't effect the property owner to disallow it, only helps them). Thankfully, many states have enacted protections that override what can be contracturally restricted for living dwellings, granting new explicit rights but these are by no means exhaustive and vary from state to state and even by municipality. In the case described, you're choosing convenience over liberty. "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." In this case I would support home ownership over dealing with mild inconveniences of maintenance (then again, I'm used to performing maintenance). At the same time, many don't have that same choice and its not about choosing prefered conveniences. Renting is the only option for many because they can't even imagine starting a mortgage or gathering the necessary downpayment. On-top of that, as mentioned by others, property ownership becomes a huge financial liability that in today's economy and job market for many makes juggling finances even harder by reducing socioeconomic mobility. Maybe they wish to own and could currently afford it but the liability is too great to consider due to volatility in the job market. With ownership, slightly better income opportunities often have to be passed by because once relocation fees, market flux, and logistics of a current mortgage are factored in, many opportunities turn out to be large setbacks. Unfortunately many must choose between renting and flexibility for enough income to live reasonably vs many granted rights they're forced to give up in order to survive--I dont consider this a convenience choice. This should not be the case, but IMHO, it's a result of the ongoing further and rapid concenteation of wealth and power in the United States that lead to these scenarios. We are losing our country to a very few peoples' gains. Perhaps its always been this way but it feels like a more recent trend from my limited view
- mti27 7y ago> ... and using a grill is often explicitly banned ... Don't know if it is still the case, but last time I was in an apartment (early 2000s) there were also limitations for Internet and Television. DirecTV was popular at the time, I was the first to put a dish in a bucket on the balcony. The apartment managers said I had to take it down and use Comcast. Fortunately, when presented with a printout of the FCC rules they reneged and dishes started popping up all over the complex... Which didn't do great things for the brochure :)
- baron_harkonnen 7y agoI've gone the full cycle from renting -> own -> renting, and I can tell you that you're forgetting about a lot of the limitations that come with renting. There are a huge number of things that are out of your control and hobbies you simply can't have. Especially if you want to compare apartment to SFH. You can't paint the walls, keep a bicycle outside, grow plants you want, have any loud hobbies, BBQ, even keep your muddy boots outside your door! Also the quality of repairs completely depends on your land lord. I've had some great ones, but on average I much prefer having the ability to repair what I want when I want. You can do a ton of home improvements yourself and save a ton of money, or work to build relationships with reliable trades people (they exist) and pay someone else to take care of all of that. If you rent your entirely at the mercy of your land lord. The trend should not be to "give up on the dream of home ownership" but make it easier and more reasonable for most people to achieve.
- mulmen 7y agoI can paint the walls in my apartment and we have several free BBQs as well as ample event and leisure space. I also live within walking distance of all the shops and restaurants I could want. And I have easy access to public transportation. Leaving my boots out isn’t worth half a million dollars and my spare time. I’m not muddy often enough to even consider where I leave my footwear. I worked in agriculture during college. It was literally never an issue. My bicycle is in a secure storage room near my car and motorcycle. A security guard checks on them regularly, even when I am out of the country. I have hobbies that I pursue outside my apartment. I even rent a garage with a friend for one of those hobbies. Why does home ownership have to be made easy for most people? From where I’m sitting home ownership and “the American Dream” appear to be incredibly wasteful and not particularly appealing. There’s a long list of things I would rather do than home improvements, regardless of how easy those improvements are. Can’t we all just make the decisions that are best for ourselves?
- larrywright 7y agoI came here to make this same comment - renting forever is probably fine for people who are willing to accept a certain kind of lifestyle, but for most people it's too limiting. Got kids and want a playset in the backyard? Not in an apartment. Want a wall where there isn't one, or remove a wall that you'd rather not have? Again, nope. Want a home theatre with a big subwoofer so you can watch movies at home (one of my favorites). Nope, not unless you want some angry neighbors. I don't think for a minute that owning a home costs less month-to-month over renting - with maintenance and upkeep, repairs and new appliances periodically, it's probably a break-even at best. But, at the end of it in 20 or 30 years I can sell the house and have that money (to buy a smaller house, or move into something senior-citizen appropriate, or a condo or whatever). With renting, that's not the case. It also helps that I live in the Midwest, where property prices are not insane. I just sold my first house (made almost $30k over what I paid 18 years ago), and now I'm buying a 5-bedroom, 3k sq ft house in a nice neighborhood... for $230k. Is it for everyone? No. But there's no way I'd rent, at least not at this stage of life.
- rayiner 7y agoSo don’t buy a house with a big yard, etc.? We’ve got a house in a waterfront area that was laid out in the 1920s. Back when Americans were still free and there were no zoning codes. The houses are detached, but the lots are tiny (less than 3,000 square feet). No yard to take care of, close to neighbors, etc. And because people own rather than rent, you’re not getting a new set of neighbors every year.
- orpep90nxkfo 7y agoLol building codes sure are the epitome of authoritarian state behaviors that’s for sure In the 1920s when the world was better for us first world white guys.
- asark 7y agoAround here you sacrifice school quality, hard, for almost anything other than a typical big yard, large house, boring suburb house. The intersection between older neighborhoods or any trendy newer ones built more "urban" style and places with schools you'd be happy to send your kids to is practically nil. YMMV in other places, but that's why we're in a non-walkable boring suburb with dumb, giant yards making the distance to the nearest pools and parks (and everything else) further than they need to be.
- rayiner 7y agoWhere we live it’s illegal to make tight neighborhoods where children can walk around. Minimum lot siZe is 1/4 or 1/3 of an acre. We got lucky because we’re grandfathered in.
- EpicEng 7y ago>This ridiculous idea that renting is "throwing money away" is absurd. I'm paying someone to deal with all the shit I absolutely don't want to deal with, and more importantly I'm paying for the freedom to easily up and move if something else fits my fancy. Yet you'll almost always come out ahead financially, so not ridiculous at all. Real estate is a great way to build wealth, and owning your home comes with all sorts of financial advantages. Also, you're paying that super. Nothing is free; it's a part of your rent. You may get lucky and have a responsive management company... or you may not, and that is likely tied pretty closely to how much your rent costs each month. It's not hard to get in tough with service people and, you know... you can always just learn how to fix things yourself.
- pgm8705 7y agoI have a love/hate relationship with the responsibilities that come with home ownership. I hate the feeling of having an ever-growing todo list and knowing that I am going to have to spend my free time on the weekends doing chores, most of which have significant costs that go with them. But on the flip side there is a huge feeling of satisfaction and pride when you accomplish certain tasks or home improvement projects. You've bettered the property you own and often have learned new skills. It also makes the beer taste even better when you're finally ready to relax.
- 5555624 7y agoI rented for years and it was easier than owning a home. In my case, though, my job moved two years ago and, now, renting would be "throwing money away." An apartment half the size of my house would be twice my mortgage payment. Luckily, growing up, my father made sure I could do just about every possible home repair. I may not do them all now; but, I can and I know enough to avoid being ripped off.
- cblum 7y agoGlad to see this near the top and glad to know I’m not the only one who thinks like this. Like you, I only own a place as a compromise with my wife. And like you, I hate everything that comes with homeownership. People don’t realize there are a lot of hidden costs in owning a home. When you rent, if you secure a 12 month lease, you know exactly how much you’re spending in housing over the next year. When you own, all bets are off. This year for example we’ve already spent a couple thousand dollars on appliances that broke. There are things around the place we know are gonna need repairs soon and those are gonna cost us a few hundred more. Our situation is compounded by being under an HOA, so special assessments are always a possibility. I know two people who sold their homes and went back to renting specifically because they couldn’t put up with maintaining a home anymore. I saw renting as paying for a service. I know I wasn’t building equity, but I saw it as paying for not having to worry about all the crap I have to worry about now. Any issue was a phone call and $0 away from getting resolved and the maintenance folks were always awesome at the place where we lived.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> When you rent, if you secure a 12 month lease, you know exactly how much you’re spending in housing over the next year. Only for exactly 12 months though. After that, your rent could double for all you know, and there’d be nothing you could do. You can move, of course, but now you’ve been forced to upend your life. I live in a rent stablized apartment, and I feel lucky not just because my current price is lower than market rate overall. But of course, that’s not a scalable economic solution.
- cblum 7y agoTrue, but from my perspective moving is a small, point in time hassle that you go through every couple years as a renter, as opposed to a lifelong stream of issues that you have to deal with as a homeowner.
- scarface74 7y agoIf the rent is going up where you live, it’s probably going up everywhere else you would want to live in lockstep.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoOne way to think about it is the Spread between the cost of owning vs the cost of renting. For example, in SF, the spread is very small and hence favors the renter. Here's an example: In SF, your cost of ownership is roughly 2% per year (1.4% property taxes, 0.5% for Earthquake Insurance, 0.3% for repairs and depreciation and HOA), which comes to a total of 2.2%. The average Rent for an equivalent house is roughly 3% of the purchase price per year. So the spread is just 0.8%. Which means, if you can take the equity you would have put into the house and put it somewhere else, as long as you get a 0.8% real return (easier said than done with the high PEs we're facing), then you'll be ahead with renting. And of course, if you need to do a mortgage as most do, that adds a additional 1-3% to the cost of ownership making it even more in favor of the renter. Now keep in mind, here in SF, it's pretty extreme. Most places have a much larger spread between renting and owning.
- EpicEng 7y agoYou're right, but this also requires the renter to actually make their extra money work for them. Sounds simple, but so many people don't. It's similar to why people like tax refunds; it makes no sense financially, but it acts as a quasi forced savings account.
- djakjxnanjak 7y agoMy earthquake insurance is more like 0.1% and I'm pretty sure the rates are set by the state - where are you getting your numbers? If the cost were 0.5% I don't think it would be worth paying, that would buy a lot of seismic reinforcement.
- bonniemuffin 7y ago+1, my annual SF earthquake insurance premium is 0.06% of the appraised value of the house. It's not even worth mentioning in adding up the total cost of ownership.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoare you sure? That's almost 5-10 times cheaper than the averages posted, above.
- dawnerd 7y agoFlip side, I get most/more of my money back by owning a home so I look at it like free rent for just doing maintenance. Buy a newer home, less problems.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shiohime 7y agoHaving ownership and responsibility is nice imo. Pay off a house, and you have some nice real estate that you can live in, sell off, rent out, transfer to your children/grandchildren later in life. Way more options than having to pay for rent indefinitely. I've lived in way too many apartments in the past decade, purchasing a house and land has been the best decision of my life. There are tradeoffs to both lifestyles - I'd say that apartment / renting is great for 18 - 30 and gets progressively worse the older you get. I'd rather have a dream where I have more responsibility and ownership as I progress in life rather than the dream of eternally renting and owning nothing. Sure I have to deal with shit I used to just call up my landlord and have them deal with it, but learning new skills and how to fix random things is fun too, at least to me. Not everyone's cup of tea I get it, but neither is renting forever.
- brightball 7y agoI agree and disagree. On the one hand, yes, you're right that the repair expenses can be a big deal. If you don't want anything but the basics for the technology in your home, sometimes a home warranty can be a good option too but experiences vary significantly. On the flip side though, after my 15 year mortgage is up I'm not going to pay another dime outside of maintenance on this thing. On a 30 year, you'll still pay a fortune over the life of the loan which makes the renting argument a lot closer. It also depends on the phase of your life. Personally, I can't imagine having kids and dogs without a yard. If I didn't have kids or hadn't found an area where I really wanted to settle down, renting would make perfect sense. At the point that you find somewhere to spend the rest of your life, become a part of the community, get involved, make local friends, raise a family...home ownership makes a lot more sense. I'm a firm believer in outsourcing repetitive work. I've had a yard company since the first 2 months in my first house because the time trade off for me was more than worth it. You also will eventually learn your way around finding good and reliable contractors for the important things (plumbing, electrical, general repairs). Word of mouth is hugely important there. A lot of this stuff is pretty easy to learn too. I was pretty proud of myself the first time I disassembled a toilet to fix it. The more you learn, the less you need to call for help for small stuff.
- rifung 7y ago> On the flip side though, after my 15 year mortgage is up I'm not going to pay another dime outside of maintenance on this thing. On a 30 year, you'll still pay a fortune over the life of the loan which makes the renting argument a lot closer. If you can assume historical returns, renting is a financially superior choice. Well, assuming my math was correct. Both are big assumptions admittedly. The reason is that when you buy, while you are effectively saving by having your money go towards your home, over the long term on average home prices don't increase. On the other hand if you invest that down payment, it will compound. Note that the result is not the same if you buy a place with cash and rent it out to others, because in this case you can reinvest your returns. However if you buy a place to live in, for most people they need a mortgage and their theoretical savings can not be reinvested. Or in other words, O(c^n) is a superset of O(n) for c > 1.
- rafiki6 7y agoHmm, that leads to a really interesting business idea (if it doesn't already exist). The reason a building can have a super is because there's scale. You only really need 1 super to deal with multiple units and overall building issues. Why not start a business where people pay a small monthly subscription fee (effectively as some kind of insurance premium), where a service person can come fix their home issues? This wouldn't be much different from renting an apartment but the key is that with renting your rent includes a portion the landlord should be reserving for maintenance and to pay the super/property manager. This would be the same as condo maintenance/strata fees basically. For major repairs, it's the same thing as being a landlord/owning a condo. Most the time major repairs aren't covered in fees, and you should have a reserve fund. Maybe this business can actually manage that for you and leverage scale of having multiple homes.
- secabeen 7y agoTransportation time/costs. Supers work because they are in the building (generally), and can respond quickly and be efficient in handling multiple simultaneous issues. What you describe does exist, it's called property management, and they generally take some %age of your rent.
- cosmodisk 7y agoI grew up in a small house with about 700m2(7500sq ft) land around it. I didn't like moving lawn or watering plans and veg in our small garden.I moved out to live on my own when I was about 19 and have been living in flats ever since.I bloody hate flats.. There's always some bastard neighbor who ruins the whole thing, you can't even go outside and have a bbq,not to mention the lack of privacy or space for kids to play...While I'm not an American, I do see the appeal of house ownership and still not losing hope to have one day at some point in my life.
- gdubs 7y agoWhen you have kids it’s nice to have some security around the school district of your choice. This is difficult in the Bay Area where in some neighborhoods there’s sometimes just nothing suitable to rent in the district.
- yason 7y agoI hate having to take care of the yard, to deal with unreliable tradespeople when things break, to deal with the huge expense of minor home repairs So, how often do things break, then? I've always thought of home ownership as full control of what gets replaced and when. No unnecessary refurbishments unless you like that sort of work, or opt in for preventative maintenance. Most people I know who live in single family houses haven't had to do much actual or imminent repairs. Wirings last for decades. Ditto for pipes and sewers. Heating too. Some have done minor jobs like repainting a few rooms, or painting the roof every ten years. Others couples do a lot of redesign, refurbishing, and redecorating all the time but they seem to like it. In my experience, owning your house is a very cheap way to live unless you like to re-do things all the time. There's the risk of disasters like pipes breaking and flooding walls but those are, honestly, dead rare (and you carry insurance, of course). Ditto for yard. You can make the yard do with minimal maintenance if you choose to do so. Or you can create a varied garden that generates a lot of work throughout the season if you like that sort of thing. But it's quite easy to create a minimal maintenance yard and most home owners I know seem to have opted for just that. Disclaimer: I don't live in USA and maybe things are different there.
- mcguire 7y agoPlus, there are all the benefits of renting an apartment: * If your neighbor decides to throw a party at 2:00 a.m. on a Wednesday, you're automatically invited! * Getting to meet all your neighbor's pets on the 4'x6' area of lawn designated for walking them! * No need to worry about interior decorating; your favorite wall color is always white! (And your favorite exterior color is that weird greenish-beige!) * No need to worry about that hobby that takes up too much space: you don't even need to consider it! * If you're really lucky, the excitement of drug busts and gunfire in the parking lot. Your own action-adventure show!
- 83 7y agoReally comes down to lifestyle - I love having a home. Want to run 220v for a basement milling machine? Easy. Want to knock out a wall to put in a big spa tub? Done. Want to put a spray booth in the garage to paint wooden kayaks? No problem. Much of what I want to do in my spare time wouldn't be feasible in an apartment. Then again, I don't mind doing some minor home repairs so my costs are minimal. You can always get a home warranty plan if repairs bother you that much.
- dmitrybrant 7y agoI think the point here is "to each their own", and there shouldn't be such a thing as "the" American dream, or rather that the American dream is for every person to live their life exactly as they want. My wife and I would not give up owning our house for anything, and would never go back to renting. I pride myself in being able to make minor repairs to all kinds of things around the house, and seeing them as fun engineering challenges rather than burdensome responsibilities. My wife loves gardening and needs plenty of yard space for planting. Most of all (and I may be in the minority here), I really value peace and quiet, and true peace and quiet can only be achieved in a detached house, and preferably even with some generous distance from the next house. If I think back to living in an apartment, I was super easily annoyed by any noise made by neighbors, including pounding footsteps, loud music, screaming children, barking dogs, etc. Of course the house we own isn't exorbitantly large, or not larger than what we need it for, but even if we'll need to "downsize" at some point in the future, it will be to another detached house, and not an apartment.
- marssaxman 7y ago> I really value peace and quiet, and true peace and quiet can only be achieved in a detached house Irony: one of the few reasons I continue to put up with the hassle of homeownership is that it affords me the freedom to play music as loud as I like, as late at night as I please, without irritating my neighbors.
- dmitrybrant 7y agoGood for you for being mindful of other people's desire to live without noise. There should definitely be more of this mindset in apartment buildings and other communal spaces. And to clarify, I like to play music too, sometimes very loudly. It's just when I don't have control of the noise that I have a problem.
- lazyjones 7y agoSomeone should come up with a model for younger people to sell to medicine/an insurance and lease back their body. It would be taken care of much better, it’s such a hassle after all to own something and be responsible...
- Aloha 7y agoEveryone is different man - I'm tired of dealing with rent that only goes one direction, up - I'm tired of neighbors who do shit like bang on my ceiling or seemingly do some sort of bowling in their living room, I'm tired of repairs that take forever too.
- flashgordon 7y agoActually this is a great way if that works for you. But I love a detached SFA precisely for this reason. I love taking care of my own yard. Doing my own repairs with my own two hands (for me there is a certain satisfaction in it - must be pathological). I want absolutely no restrictions to what I can do with my lawn, my walls, my decorations etc. I want to be able to have my own workship with own tools etc. It may not be an American dream (I am not even one) but it is my dream and is the dream for millions of others (americans or otherwise).
- fjsolwmv 7y agoYou are conflating home ownership with house ownership. You can buy a condo and pay someone to maintain it for you, just as your apartment landlord can hire unreliable managers tradesworkers to fail to fix your water heater.