4 ms·
>Couldn't violence (both towards animals and humans) be detected in an automated fashion? Even if it could (and parallel posters argue it cannot), there is a m
by dexen 7y ago
>Couldn't violence (both towards animals and humans) be detected in an automated fashion?
Even if it could (and parallel posters argue it cannot), there is a meta-problem: "Who is allowed to post violent content?". Violence is contextual, and also legality of posting it is contextual. Same goes for other objectionable materials (nudity, extreme ideologies etc.).
Point in case, if all users were subject to the same criteria, the big names in media would quickly get banned. And/or would enter war path with Facebook, accusing it of heavy-handed censorship against the freedom of the press.
Same for reportage of popular events with any degree of nudity. A news piece about a Femen protest, a Pride event, a World Naked Bike Ride, maybe even the No Pants Subway Ride would cause a ban.
Likewise, anybody documenting & discussing historical events, and anybody documenting & discussing present-day uprising, revolutions, civil wars, persecutions, etc., would quickly get banned, essentially sweeping a lot of abuse under the rug. Probably even discussion & documentation of domestic violence would have this problem.
As a lighter aside, cartoonish violence (video games & movies) could also easily fall prey to automated violence take-downs.
All in all, Facebook really really wants to give certain users (mostly press & historians) broad, sweeping exceptions to the general rules.
- lallysingh 7y agoTrain with signals about the sender?
- the_duke 7y agoAlso my first thought, but thinking it through, this can easily lead to (potentially valid) criticism of intrusive profiling and censorship.
- raxxorrax 7y agoAnd that would be bad because...?
- dexen 7y agoThat's my point: it would enforce an automated two-tier system. If you are "ingroup", you would be allowed to post virtually anything. If you are a regular citizen, good luck.
- vetinari 7y agoSo Facebook would have their own Animal Farm?
- lallysingh 7y agoIt already is! Like Twitter with checkmark people.
- raxxorrax 7y agoExactly the phenomenon we are seeing today. Random people are accused to forming a hate-mob while main-stream media happily paints a target on individuals. Most of them are even innocent and just have the wrong opinion. I thought the US had finally come to peace with nudity, but that was extremely wrong for every side of the political spectrum as the latest developments clearly show.