5 ms·
I work for a AAA studio. I even work(ed) on a game that was actually embroiled in a scandal regarding E3. I can probably shed a little insight as to why: 1)
by dijit 7y ago
I work for a AAA studio.
I even work(ed) on a game that was actually embroiled in a scandal regarding E3.
I can probably shed a little insight as to why:
1) Once you show gameplay footage, you’ve promised. This isn’t necessarily the worst thing in the world but a lot of the time the “promise” is a mega polished version of what you want to show, it’s on rails, it’s going to show all the best features of the engine, you control the pacing etc. Even if those things make it into the game (as, my game actually was in 100% parity graphically, but we ran out of budget for animations) then people /perceive/ it worse, regardless.
2) what is shown isn’t actually a game- even if it looks like one. It’s a prototype. And there’s many reasons that the final product has to be trimmed down. Either it’s required because the budget goes towards something else (such as smarter NPCs, or better animations) or it wasn’t ever possible to produce what was shown due to things that were not known at the time of creating the demo or footage. The fact is simply that you’re showing something that may not be able to exist. So that is in direct violation of my first point.
3) we got burned the last console generation, we thought the machines were going to be at least twice as powerful as they ended up being. (You May notice that my publishers “downgrade” scandal happened post-E3:2013). What we had prepared was geared towards significantly more powerful hardware. (So, number of props on screen can’t be as high, number of light sources can’t be as high, issues with streaming “pop-in”) My publisher won’t make this mistake again and with a new console generation around the corner it doesn’t makes sense to underpromise (and use the current gen, which our competitors may not have done this E3) or overpromise, and guess what the next console gen will have.
As an aside: I know it’s a trope that “console gaming holds gaming back”, and there’s a grain of truth there, but I would caution allowing developers to use as much hardware as they can, our work machines have obscene hardware (latest high end Xeon with 64/128g Ram and a gtx2070 is common), if we were not optimising for a limited platform then pc would suffer too, I just don’t know how much it is currently limited.
- dijit 7y agoI forgot to add to point 2, and my edit is locked out: One of the main reasons that things get bleached out of a game (menu's, HUD, rich graphics) is accessibility or localisation. I think a lot of people only look at games in an able-bodied western way, but if you want to sell your game in arabic then your menu's have to support going right-to-left, if you want your games to be sold to people with near-sightedness then you can't have dense darkness or heavy fog for most of the game unless it's removable (thus' more testing scenarios). For demos/proof-of-concept pieces: artists have free reign, until it comes time to actually address accessibility, discoverability or localisation concerns.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoOr “can we actually run this on a base model PS4 at nearly 30fps” concerns, or “can we actually implement this at all” concerns, or…
- rolltiide 7y agoI really enjoy the infinite entertainment and presentation format that consoles provide, but I really question their utility next generation and lol no PC gamers aren't a part of that equation whatsoever I feel like the potential console gaming crowd is so heavily diluted towards mobile and casual formats. any of the good VR titles are also running in wireless mobile formats with good enough graphics I hope there is a differentiating quality to make the 'set top box' format a staple in the 2020s instead of "just" better graphics. I feel like it is necessary
- seventhtiger 7y agoNintendo has differentiated itself since the Wii and exited the graphics rat race. It really does limit the cross platform titles available, but thankfully Nintendo has their own great 1st, 2nd, and 3rd party offerings. I think Microsoft is also deviating now. Microsoft tried to differentiate the Xbox One with Kinekt and an online-only console, but reverted due to backlash. Now they're trying again with Xbox game pass and much more cross platform/cross play availability. There're almost positioning themselves to go up against Google Stadia. But they might revert again. So far I only see Sony sticking with the traditional model. Their marketing for PS5 and PS1 are essentially the same. "We have more games that look better."
- astrange 7y agoSony has changed their console strategy; for PS1-PS3 they made everything weird and complicated to show off. This gave them lock-in and made exclusive games prettier, once people had figured out how to program them, but the consoles were super expensive and cross-platform developers weren't interested. PS4 is just a PC with some useful extras; PS5 probably will be too.
- seventhtiger 7y agoYou're right I have noticed that in all the developer interviews. I was speaking more to the marketing to consumers. It still has the same value proposition and brand as it has all this time. It might be what the market really wants, or they might lag behind.
- smadurange 7y agoI think the points you listed are very understandable from an engineering point of view. On the other hand, there were also games that just looked like downright lying in E3. Not sure if thats acceptable specially when we are talking about experts in the industry are involved. Sometimes, they feel just deliberate.
- dijit 7y agoI wholeheartedly agree, there are examples of egregious behaviour. But I'm talking specifically about things like Watch_Dogs and The Division, where it was never the intent to mislead by anyone involved, even the marketing department (which can be overzealous) thought they were playing it relatively safe, only for the situation to get dicey quickly.
- hoseja 7y agoThe whole downgrade scandal to me felt like a smear campaign, not something warranted and natural.
- pier25 7y ago> we got burned the last console generation, we thought the machines were going to be at least twice as powerful as they ended up being I thought AAA studios would be in close communication with hardware manufacturers (Nivida, Sony, AMD, Microsoft, Ninendo, etc).
- cheschire 7y agoWatching the Watchdogs "scandal" unfold was enough to turn me off Ubisoft for years. It's not that it was unique to Ubisoft, it was just the most grotesque case of under delivery I'd ever sunk money into. Especially when I had just come off GTA V, which was 90% of the same gameplay, but the engine and art were significantly better in every measurable way I could think of. For a small time game dev like Hello Games failing to meet expectations with No Man's Sky, I was generally willing to accept their failure and apologies, and continued to go back and try games. For a major publisher like Ubi, I ended up boycotting them for years.
- Agentlien 7y agoEven when what you show really is what you have and what you will deliver you won't get away from being called a liar. One AAA game I worked on released a trailer for E3 which we were really proud of. Our game looked amazing and that's what we showed. The trailer was recorded in game. The only "trickery" was custom placement of some cameras and rendering to a 4K backbuffer and downsampling (which the final game does support on PC, anyway). Despite the trailer being rendered in real time on a relatively powerful gaming rig using the actual game, the YouTube comments were flooded by people being angry at how this was obviously fake because it cannot look like that in the final game. There were even people explaining why and how this was obviously fake.