9 ms·
Two centuries of rapid global population growth will come to an end
- Nursie 7y agoThat is interesting. But I wonder how the model would be affected by, say, the mass availability of a significant longevity increase, brought about by some sort of medical breakthrough?
- IAmEveryone 7y agoSince people would presumably not use that extra time to have more children (they aren’t time-limited now), the result would just be a linear increase in population. The important part here is the change from the exponential models of Malthus etc.
- jacquesm 7y ago> they aren’t time-limited now They mostly are actually. Barring the occasional exception there is a definite 20-40 or so age band where most females that have children will have them. This is in part because of society and custom and in part for very valid medical reasons, the chances of children having birth defects go up quite fast past the age of 35.
- tntn 7y agoI think that 'IAmEveryone likely means that people aren't lifetime-limited. Most people aren't reproducing after 40, but expected lifespan is much more than that so even if it doubled there wouldn't be more children.
- jacquesm 7y agoThere are several factors here: the age at which people realistically will still want children and the fact that they themselves will simply be alive for a longer time. Medical breakthroughs tend to affect the latter rather than the former more, though the fact that people live longer has an effect on the age at which they start with having children. In my grandparents generation it wasn't rare for 19 year olds to be married and to have their first child on the way, my parents generation had their children when approaching 30 (on average), and the present day generation has their first child later still. There is some correlation here with education levels and of course from country to country there are still huge differences but overall those seem to be the trends. So a significant longevity increase brought about by a medical breakthrough will likely cause people to have their children at an even later age (with all the associated risks, possibly resulting in much more screening), somewhat offsetting the effect of those people themselves being alive for longer. Social security would be a real problem, especially if the time that people could work productively would not increase at the same rate as the longevity.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoThat depends on the kind of longevity. - If it's "stay old longer" then yeah, that's a problem (most of our present advances are this since they don't address ageing, just save people from its consequences). - If it's "stay young longer (or indefinitely)" that will change a lot of assumptions. But it might also make people put off children until really late, like, "if you're less than 100 why are you even considering being a parent?"
- jacquesm 7y agoStay young longer is SF, stay old longer is already happening.
- pferde 7y ago"Stay young longer" is healthy lifestyle and a bit of personal responsibility.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoBasically the problem of ageing is a gradual accumulation of "damage" of assorted kinds. An ideal regimen of exercise and diet and non-stressful life and so forth can reduce the rate but not to zero. Thus, even healthy people get old and die. Actual therapies would go in and undo the damage, not stop it accumulating, but clean the existing damage down to a level where ageing symptoms would be reset back by decades. And could be repeated, leading to indefinite lifespans.
- pferde 7y agoYes, of course, I agree with you. However, the quote I was replying to had the word "longer", and not the word "forever" in it. And that's exactly what healthy lifestyle gives you - not miracles, but a definite increase in quality of life, and prolongation of the active part of it. The downvotes to my comment above amused me, there are apparently people in denial here. :)
- python_gt_r3 7y agoStopping African fertility is the world's number one priority. Much more important than climate change. Waiting one generation may mean 1-2 more billion people we can't afford.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoThis is one of the major cause of the destruction of the environment we're seeing globally. All forecasts predict another 60% (!!) increase in global population before it stabilises. Forget about banning plastic straws or flying less (which are feel-good measures more than anything else) with such numbers... We need to take dramatic and effective steps. There are 80 years left until the end of the century. This increase is far from being inevitable! But, again, we prefer to ignore these key issues and focus on marginal, feel-good measures instead.
- roca 7y agoPerhaps you didn't read the article, because its main point is that the official UN forecast is for world population to essentially flatten out at 10.9B around 2100, which is 40% more than today, not 60%.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- NotPaidToPost 7y ago11B from 7B is a 60% increase... But that's the usual sterile nitpicking. Do you want to argue about decimal points or address the actual point? The important point is that this is a large increase when we already cannot manage now.
- Retric 7y ago10.9/7.53 = 1.45, but that 10.9 has high error bars. The U.N. estimation is a 80% chance it’s between 10 and 12 Billion in 80 years. https://population.un.org/wpp/Graphs/Probabilistic/POP/TOT/900 https://population.un.org/wpp/Graphs/Probabilistic/POP/TOT/9... That’s quite a bit of uncertainty to make any real definitive statements beyond continuing growth expected.
- beat 7y agoAs a point of comparison, the global population has almost quadrupled in the previous 80 years. So even in the worst case scenario, population growth is dropping spectacularly.
- jacquesm 7y agoSuch long term predictions have relatively little value due to the sensitivity to the initial inputs. Any small deviation from reality will result in a huge deviation in the longer term and 80 years is much too long to predict with any accuracy. Typically the only useful info you can get out of such long term studies is the sign of the change and the order of magnitude.
- Certhas 7y agoThis is absolutely incorrect, and you have no idea what you are talking about. There is no sensitive chaotic model behind this, it's completely straightforward dynamics. The fertility rate is about 2 kids per woman now. But the generation of 20 year olds is much larger than the generation of 40 year olds. So even though the generation of 0 year olds is the same size as that of 20 year olds, in 20 years time we will have replaced a small 40 year old generation by a large 20 year old generation. There are only two factors here: Fertility rate per woman, and death rate. This prediction is not terribly sensitive to either, and both are easy to measure accurately and on quite stable long term trajectories: https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate
- jacquesm 7y ago> There is no sensitive chaotic model behind this, it's completely straightforward dynamics. Sorry for the poor choice of words, no chaotic model was implied or intended. > Fertility rate per woman, and death rate. No, there is also technological development, wars and so on. So any prediction that looks 80 years out that only looks at fertility rate and death rate is going to be found wanting. It's a bit long for a long bet, but I'd be more than happy to take one for a 30% or more deviation from the prediction. The degree to which people are willing to believe simplistic models without further qualification is astounding to me, given the past 80 years in development of medical technology, electronics and our ability to wage war any predictions about the next 80 years should come with huge error bars. And that's before we get into the consequences of Climate change.
- Certhas 7y ago
- peteradio 7y ago>> This new equilibrium is different from the one in the past when it was the very high mortality that kept population growth in check. In the new balance it will be low fertility keeps population changes small. What is the reason for low fertility prediction?
- ausbah 7y agoHigher standards of living?
- comboy 7y agoPoverty decrease: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility Well it's a simplification. Better education also correlates with lower fertility. And yes, I'm not showing causation. But anti-conception does require some basic money and education.
- sago 7y agoCulture. It's principally cultural not biological. It's perhaps clearer to say it is a decrease in fecundity rather than fertility. Worldwide experience has been that increasingly developed nations have lower average fecundity. There are various likely reasons but the correlation seems to be quite robust. In most countries it seems that the causal link was from development to fertility. It is arguable that China reversed the causation, politically limiting fecundity. This is a uniquely human dynamic. Pretty much every other species in the world drives its population to its Malthusian limit.
- Creationer 7y agoExcessive taxes and expensive housing. In much of Europe it is simply impossible to buy a house on a single income, if you obey 100% of tax laws. These taxes are used to pay for the elderly, their welfare (pensions) and healthcare. If you are in the US you may not appreciate how heavy the tax burden is in Europe. It varies by country but its normally something like: 30% payroll tax paid by employer. 30% income tax paid by you. 20% sales tax paid by you. Then, very expensive housing due to the high population densities and limited room to expand. Additionally in Europe, many parents want their children to be educated in English, however the language of instruction is usually the local language. This is partly why the migrant stream into the Anglosphere is so high. The alternative are private international schools, which are hideously expensive.
- dzdt 7y agoA major point the article is missing is that after population peak comes population decline. The pattern of "demographic transition" is that as lifespans extend, infant mortality declines, and lifestyles change the birthrate drops. But it doesn't drop just to replacement rate, it drops much below replacement rate. Most developed countries are in this state now where their population would be declining but for immigration. When today's fast-growing countries reach the same point in their demographic transitions, the whole world's population will enter decline. This could happen even earlier than around 2100 when the UN estimates; other demographers are forecasting a date more like 2065. [1] What will the economics be of a world in population decline? How will culture and policies change to eventually stabilise the decline? Lots of questions... [1] Lutz et al 2018 : https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/sites/jrcsh/files/lutz_et_al_2018_demographic_and_human_capital.pdf https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/sites/jrcsh/files/lutz_et_al_2018_d...
- user17843 7y agoAdditionally the data points for the low-fertility countries are extremely reliable, while the data for the few countries with supposedely rapidly expanding population is only guesswork. Most of the projected population increase in Africa is based upon a small number of countries like Nigeria, where most of the people live on the countryside, and there never have been reliable census to accurately predict the future population. The only thing we know is that Africans moving to cities stop having many children, and that the fertlity rate in the richer African areas is rapidly decreasing. In Northern and Southern Africa the fertlity rate is already below 2.5, approaching sub-replacement levels. [1] Which means it is definitely possible that the entire world will be entering sub-replacement level in the coming decades. Unfortunately the African coutries with a high-fertility projection haven an interest in lying about their numbers, because it means more NGO money and political influence. [2] The country with the lowest fertility rate in the world is South Korea, which has a fertility rate of <1. [3] South-Korea is facing extinction. [4] Additionally there are hints that China is lying about their population numbers as well. [5] India, which is the most populated country in the world, has already fallen to sub-replacement levels in almost all counties, and stands at a fertility rate of 2.2, as of 2017. [6] [1] https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate [2] https://qz.com/africa/1221472/the-story-of-how-nigerias-census-figures-became-weaponized/ https://qz.com/africa/1221472/the-story-of-how-nigerias-cens... [3] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/sep/03/south-koreas-fertility-rate-set-to-hit-record-low https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/sep/03/south-koreas-f... [4] https://www.businessinsider.com/south-koreans-could-be-extinct-by-2750-2015-6?IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/south-koreans-could-be-extin... [5] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/china/china-has-been-overstating-its-population-numbers-since-1990-says-us-academic/articleshow/58835756.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/china/china-has-be... [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_and_union_territories_of_India_by_fertility_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_and_union_terri...
- ElonsMosque 7y agoExcept in Africa. The population is expected to double until 2050 and potentially double again by 2100.[1] [1] https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-health-global-gates/africas-rapid-population-growth-puts-poverty-progress-at-risk-says-gates-idUKKCN1LY0GQ https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-health-global-gates/africa...
- igravious 7y agoThat's okay, because the population density of Africa is very low (it's comparable to that of the Americas, much less than Europe/Asia)[1], it's currently only 15% of the world's population[2], and Africa is an enormous continent[3] the fact of which the Mercator projection distorts[4]. [1][2] https://www.geolounge.com/continents-population-density/ https://www.geolounge.com/continents-population-density/ [3] https://io9.gizmodo.com/africas-true-size-will-blow-you-away-1441076531 https://io9.gizmodo.com/africas-true-size-will-blow-you-away... [4] http://www.petersmap.com/ http://www.petersmap.com/
- danmaz74 7y agoIt's an enormous continent, but a lot of it is covered by deserts and other inhospitable environments
- ElonsMosque 7y agoYou're right there, however I'm afraid the issue won't be density but a much different issue: Unemployment. [1] Reason this could be a worldwide issue is the opportunity cost. Can we afford not to have a billion or more minds on board to solve some of the worlds most pressing problems? China is trying its best to industrialize and capitalize on the growth. But many are claiming their tactics are almost neocolonialist. [2] [1] https://mo.ibrahim.foundation/news/2018/african-governance-progress-lagging-behind-demographic-growth-expectations-youth-population/ https://mo.ibrahim.foundation/news/2018/african-governance-p... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/02/magazine/is-china-the-worlds-new-colonial-power.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/02/magazine/is-china-the-wor...
- beat 7y agoAs Hans Rosling pointed out in Factfulness, the birth and literacy rates in Sweden in the 19th century were on par with the poorest of African countries today, resulting in fully 20% of the population becoming refugees in North America to escape famine. And today, 150 years later, it's... Sweden. The ideal of modern civilization. He said he was born in "Egypt", by which he meant the economy of Sweden in the late 1940s was similar to Egypt today. With that in mind, is there any reason that the poor countries of Africa today can't be the Sweden of tomorrow? It's more irrational to say they'll stay poor and overpopulated than it is to say they'll become wealthy and modern with zero population growth.
- comboy 7y agoRelated to that, I highly recommend Factfulness[1]. You can try to answer 13 a/b/c questions here[2]. Most educated people score lower than if they would have just chosen answers randomly. It's really hard to discuss population and poverty if most people worldview is so skewed. Btw, I've been wondering how population stabilization (it pretty much already stabilized in the US and EU) will influence real estate. Historically real estate have been a remarkably good investment. But historically population kept growing pretty fast. I'd love to hear some thoughts or recommended reading on that topic. 1. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34890015-factfulness https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34890015-factfulness 2. http://forms.gapminder.org/s3/test-2018 http://forms.gapminder.org/s3/test-2018
- gibspaulding 7y agoWow, I just took the quiz and it was rather enlightening. I ended up scoring reasonably well (9/13), but only because getting the first few wrong taught me to stop taking such a dismal view of the world. If I hadn't been shown the correct answers until the end, I probably would have done even worse. I might have to look into that book!
- comboy 7y agoOh, I didn't realize it shows answers right away. Previous version didn't do that. 9/13 would have been a great score. edit: I've changed the link to a test that doesn't mark correct answers right away, previous link: http://factfulnessquiz.com/ http://factfulnessquiz.com/
- hanoz 7y agoThe two versions of the quiz claim different correct answers for the population of the continents question.
- comboy 7y agoHuh, indeed, factfulnessquiz.com seems to be selecting wrong answer as correct even though they list correct answer correctly on http://factfulnessquiz.com/answers http://factfulnessquiz.com/answers Pretty serious given that there are only 13 questions and that's what the whole website is about. They didn't even leave any contact. I'll send an email to gapminder. Nice catch, and a really bad job from whoever made the quiz website. Triple checking those answers should be a priority.
- car12 7y agoNews items like these are then used as fodder for higher immigration limits so that the liberal parties keep getting elected further, even as they enjoy less and less support from their already existing citizens.
- wtdata 7y agoActually, almost all of the democratic acts in the West lately (don't mistake the echo chambers which one of us is submitted to in social networks for the will of the majority), show a clear support for parties that - amongst other things - want higher immigration limits. EU parliament elections, EU local elections, USA presidentials, Brazil, and the list goes on.
- bergoid 7y agoI think GP meant with "higher immigration limits" : less restrictions on immigration.
- car12 7y agoI should clarify, I meant: higher numerical intake limits for immigrants to developed countries. Basically, most of the liberal parties have found this "hack" to win elections. Where they wouldn't be able to win elections normally, they simply keep importing more and more people, and these immigrants reliably vote for these parties. Eventually, these places end up becoming one party states. Consider the case of California as an example. It's quite an indictment of the democratic processes.
- wtdata 7y agoBut, liberal parties have been loosing an awfull lot of elections lately, clearly this is no "hack" to win elections because it is not working as you state. It's their ideology and it is up to the democratic process to judge it (favorably or unfavorably). And - although personally I favor controlled immigration only - it is perfectly healthy for a democracy to have parties that defend and present other perspectives.
- Creationer 7y agoGlobal population growth is really just African and West Asian population growth. These regions are marked by ideologies or interpretations of it that are hostile to women, and poor infrastructure. They will also be the worst affected by climate change due to their geographic position and reliance on agriculture. Unfortunately fertility rates in these countries are falling too slowly. In Egypt, approaching 100m people and affected by water shortages and overpopulation, the fertility rate is increasing. We need to shift 100% of our foreign aid to education, contraception and abortion for women. Whilst some women and men choose to have an excess of children, many women simply lack access to contraception. If global conditions and the climate worsen, we may need to consider more assertive measures: $1000 cash for every male under 25 and with fewer than 1 child willing to accept a vasectomy, for example.
- malvosenior 7y ago> These regions are marked by ideologies or interpretations of it that are hostile to women, and poor infrastructure. > We need to shift 100% of our foreign aid to education, contraception and abortion for women. You're essentially advocating for colonialism. Not every culture is the same and some do not want abortion, for example. It's not the west's role to forcibly import our culture into other countries just to lower their birth rate to that of our's (which is too low, not even replacement level).
- notfromhere 7y agoThey can do what they want, but the planet can't sustain large population growth anymore
- malvosenior 7y agoI have no idea what metrics you're looking at to support that argument (Malthusianism has been debunked by the way) but the fact that their population keeps growing proves that you are incorrect.
- 7y ago
- igravious 7y agoThis data should mandatory in all school curricula throughout the world. One of the greatest impediments to understanding the social reality of the world around us is the general population's ignorance of this data. We need people to (a) understand that the world's population is increasing but that the rate of increase will inexorably slow and that (b) this means that the population will plateau. We then need people to ask themselves can the Earth support that level of population of 11 billion. The answer is an incontrovertible "yes". Anybody who claims the Earth cannot support 11 billion people is factually incorrect. Is it going to cause environmental stress? Yes. Will it cause environmental collapse? No. People also fail to understand this other simple fact. Even though there will be more mouths to feed, there will be more hands to make the food. And given economies of scale, it'll arguably be easier to feed 11 billion than 7 billion.
- makerofspoons 7y agoI would love to see a citation for 11 billion people not causing an environmental collapse. At our current population 40% of insects could be extinct in the coming decades, and over the last 50 years 60% of animal populations have been wiped out: https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/22/health/food-biodiversity-report-intl/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/22/health/food-biodiversity-repo...
- igravious 7y agoCitation that it will rather than the typical conjecture?
- makerofspoons 7y agoThe accelerating rate of extinction outlined in the latest UN biodiversity report, out last month: https://www.ipbes.net/news/Media-Release-Global-Assessment https://www.ipbes.net/news/Media-Release-Global-Assessment
- igravious 7y ago
- jlawson 7y agoThese predictions are laughable because they ignore the fact that fertility, like everything else, is heritable. The people who aren't reproducing will die out. The people who are reproducing will do so, and their kids will keep reproducing too. These are separate sub-groups of the population. As a very simple example, the Amish population doubles roughly every 20 years because of their high and early birth rates. It's not hard to calculate that there will be billions of them within a few centuries because of the power of exponential growth. Any analysis which doesn't separate sub-groups by fertility, or handle the heritability of fertility, is meaningless. All we're in now is a temporary state caused by rapid introduction of birth control and porn and other such technologies which suppress fertility. No different from hitting a bacterial colony with a drug that stops 90% of them from reproducing. It reverses growth for a few generations, but the logic of evolution and exponential growth always wins in the end and the population hits its carrying capacity once again. Which for humanity with modern tech, is going to be a very, very ugly situation.
- jessaustin 7y agoIt's far more likely that the Amish will have disappeared altogether in "a few centuries" than that they will number in the "billions". There is no Amish gene.
- jlawson 7y agoYou can just flatly assert that, but it'd be more interesting if you supported your assertion with some kind of argument. What exactly do you think is going to dissolve the Amish that didn't do so already? Do you not think fertility is heritable, and if not, how not? Also, who said anything about genes? Sub-groups can be separated by culture, religion, genetics, or any combination of the above. Amish are separated by all 3. Religiosity is also linked to genetics; this is scientifically established (though not totally proven yet).
- iamnothere 7y agoNot the person you're replying to, but I'll give a hypothetical argument. The Amish have an extremely successful culture right now because their society positions them advantageously versus the predominant culture. Their practices are excellent for building strong communities and providing efficient, effective mutual aid in a form that is lacking in society at large; and unlike what most people think of the Amish, they do adopt some modern technology, but only that which strengthens the community. As the Amish community grows, they will face the same challenges faced by all growing, successful "challenger" cultures: envy and resentment, followed by active undermining of their culture and attempts at assimilation through popular media, fashion, and a hostile legislative environment. (This presents itself as a sort of "embrace, extend, extinguish" effect, with the end product being ethnic restaurants and kitsch once the culture has been fully digested.) The Amish may be able to adapt to face this challenge, but what often happens is that the process of adaptation ruins the good and unique things about the culture, and the assimilation happens anyway. Cultures that resist this effect stay small by necessity. An example of a culture recently reaching this "breakout" point where pushback is encountered is the Hasidic community in New York. A good example of a culture that is left alone due to its small size is the Sikh-American community. An example of a fully digested culture is the Italian-American community, which no longer exists as a separate identity.
- Symmetry 7y agoThe fact that fertility is heritable makes an end to population growth unlikely. [1]https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1090513817302799 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S109051381...
- raducu 7y agoIt could be that we are approaching a great filter: "when an intelligent species has the freedom to decouple the great incentive for reproduction (sexual pleasure) from the actual reproduction, it turns out individuals choose not to reproduce, which leads to the collapse of the whole civilization"
- mensetmanusman 7y agoGreat sci fi novel here
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kharak 7y agoWhere is this from?
- corysama 7y agohttps://wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter is a question intended to inspire a wide variety of possible answers like this one.
- benj111 7y agoFrom what I understand people are having less sex period. I guess its some combination of women's lib (women more likely to say no to sex, relationships and children, wanting careers), people working more (side hustles are now a thing), and there now being more things to do (you can now socialise on the internet without actually meeting anyone).
- adrianN 7y agoSperm counts in men are on decline as well. There might be some environmental factor.
- ptah 7y agoit might actually save our species to have lower population as it will slow resource depletion
- mensetmanusman 7y agoThe population decline projected follows a similar % drop versus time as the Black Plague. Fascinating.
- yters 7y agoThere is always the doomsday argument: we should expect a significant population decline in the near future in order to justify the statistical typicality of our present day existence.