8 ms·
I'm not sure the author's suggestion that potential students be diverted to trades/coding bootcampts etc., will solve too much, and instead may simply shift the
by ineedasername 7y ago
I'm not sure the author's suggestion that potential students be diverted to trades/coding bootcampts etc., will solve too much, and instead may simply shift the problem into those trade industries as well. Somewhere in the ballpark of 2,000,000 students earn a bachelors degree each year. Let's say 25% of students should be diverted into trade schools instead. That will mean an additional 500,000 student per year entering those fields, which will then have the impact of making those jobs ever more scarce and probably depressing wages as workforce supply outpaces demand.
That's not to say diversion of this sort wouldn't help at all, only that it is not a cure-all. I think we're simply approaching a point in economic history where fewer workers are needed to produce more value/gpd/products/whatever. I'm not sure what the solution to that problem is though.
- dfilppi 7y agoThe problem is the government subsidizes loans.
- ineedasername 7y agoThat may be a problem, but it's a bit beside the point I was making. Whether or not college costs & therefore debt is increasing as a result of easy loans says nothing about the job prospects of graduates from bachelor programs. Even if we posit a world where the loans didn't exist, college costs were lower, and therefore just as accessible as it is today then we still have the same underemployment problem. If such a change instead resulted in more students learning a trade, we still have to same downward pressure on trade wages because the labor supply increases relative to demand. With or without government subsidized loans, there is a jobs market issue.
- JamesBarney 7y agoUnless most majors generate signal instead of human capital.
- castlecrasher2 7y agoIt's a problem for sure but education costs have been high-inflation for a long time. See here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866194
- icelancer 7y agoIt is that in addition to the fact that they cannot be discharged in bankruptcy under the majority of cases (nearly all).
- matt-attack 7y agoYou can’t mandate that banks must give loans to all student applicants regardless of collateral, and at the same time permit bankruptcy of those loans. Those two things are in direct conflict. Literally every graduate would simply declare bankruptcy (Since anyone who is both a graduate and borrow would by definition be broke). You’d be a fool not to. There’s literally no downside to bankruptcy if you’re a broke 22 year old with a brand new $250k debt and a degree in anything. Your choice are: 1. everyone can get a loan regardless of wealth, but they can’t file bankruptcy 2. Let banks only give student loans to qualified applicants (i.e. rich kids with co-signing rich parents) but permit bankruptcy.
- jseliger 7y agoThere are two books that cover this subject well: The Case Against Education: https://jakeseliger.com/2018/03/12/the-case-against-education-bryan-caplan/ https://jakeseliger.com/2018/03/12/the-case-against-educatio..., which argues that most "education" is really signaling, not human capital acquisition, and Paying for the Party: https://jakeseliger.com/2014/04/27/paying-for-the-party-elizabeth-armstrong-and-laura-hamilton/ https://jakeseliger.com/2014/04/27/paying-for-the-party-eliz..., which argues that many schools have evolved some substantive majors and some non-substantive majors. If we can move people from non-substantive majors into trades and the like, that will likely be a win for just about everyone. I also don't think we're going to see a cure-all, but it's hard for almost any intellectually honest person in the non-elite parts of the higher-education industry to look at what's going on and think it's great. I think we're simply approaching a point in economic history where fewer workers are needed to produce more value/gpd/products/whatever Then we'd see soaring productivity, which we don't see: https://twitter.com/paulkrugman/status/1140259227908411392 https://twitter.com/paulkrugman/status/1140259227908411392
- wwweston 7y agoKrugman's point is not uncontested: http://www.scottsantens.com/our-paradoxical-economy-courtesy-of-technology-and-the-lack-of-basic-income http://www.scottsantens.com/our-paradoxical-economy-courtesy... Additionally, even if we're not peering around the metrics for dynamics hiding behind them, there's the question of how much of the by-Krugman's-metric still rising (if not "soaring") productivity it would take to soften the labor market. I'd like to think he knows the answer to that question, but it isn't clear.
- JamesBarney 7y agoHis central argument is that IT is only increasing productivity in open source software and does not cause any productivity improvements in businesses, which is a strange argument. But low demand also explains everything he talks about. When you hear hoof beats think horses not zebras.
- 7y ago
- mars4rp 7y agoThat is not so bad to depress some of those wages, my plumber is making $2k/Day. I don't know too many people making that kind of money even in tech, let alone other disciplines!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kittiepryde 7y agoI think your plumber has additional material and labor costs you're not seeing.
- geggam 7y agoPrimary cost of labor is your health. Those kind of jobs aren't done by people over 45. The human body degrades during that sort of work.
- mars4rp 7y agohave you heard about age discrimination in tech?
- geggam 7y agoI have 50 decades of life and work in tech. You tell me ?
- Sophistifunk 7y agoLook, Methusela. I doubt you were working in software in the 1500s.
- geggam 7y agoLOL um... typo :)
- 7y ago
- rossdavidh 7y ago1) if it does turn out to be true that we need "fewer workers", that's great, we just move to a 30-hour work week (or 20, or whatever). We once had 6-day work weeks, or sometimes even 7, and it was productivity gains that allowed us to move to 5. We can move again. 2) But, I'm not sure it's even true. We mostly got to where we are by having all the manufacturing done in 3rd world countries for pennies. It's not that it doesn't take a lot of hours, it's just that we pay little for it. Which is great, if you're one of those who has a job, but bad in lots of other ways. 3) Regarding automation, it should be noted that the manufacturing did not, by and large, go to the countries with the best robots, or even the most reliable electricity for automation. It went to where the environmental, health, and safety laws were laxest, and the cost of labor was lowest. This suggests that there is still plenty of labor that needs doing, we just are run by an elite that doesn't want to pay for it.
- frankbreetz 7y agoI like the idea or shortening the work day, unfortunately the commonman jobs are the ones being automated out of existence. There will only be a smaller percentage of people who can actually do the majority of the jobs. Education may help some with this but only to a certain degree. The days of assembly line work are nearing an end. I don't know what will happen to the population who are unable to work, perhaps more specialization is the answer
- rossdavidh 7y agoSee point #3, above. The "commonman jobs" did not, in fact, get automated out of existence, they mostly got moved to countries with LESS automation than the advanced economies, which is the opposite of what one would predict if automation were the issue.
- vageli 7y ago> 1) if it does turn out to be true that we need "fewer workers", that's great, we just move to a 30-hour work week (or 20, or whatever). We once had 6-day work weeks, or sometimes even 7, and it was productivity gains that allowed us to move to 5. We can move again. Shorten the work week and it is hourly workers getting screwed. Unless we think, for some reason, corporations will take it upon themselves to pay more for less, especially since the labor pool would be more competitive with increases in automation.
- fiftyfifty 7y agoWe just need to reduce or eliminate government backed student loans and the problem will take care of itself. This "crisis" is almost a replay of the housing crisis we just had, government backed loans encourage lenders to lend out money to people who are not qualified for the loan. It doesn't make sense to keep loaning out tens of thousands of dollars to 18 year old kids that have no income [yet] and no real plan to make any money for the next 4 years. Can you imagine if someone submitted a business proposal asking for a $100,000 investment or loan and the proposal was "think I'll take some classes and then figure out what I want to do with the rest of my life"? We need to end the insanity and turn the spigot off. Then the institutions will be forced to lower their prices and manage their budgets again. Maybe one day we'll get back to the point where a young person can pay for in-state tuition with a part-time job, like it was about 25 years ago.
- chii 7y agoBut without the student loans, the under privileged will not be able to afford said education - I don't want to see a society where only those who can afford it go to university.
- icelancer 7y agoThis simply isn't true. Schools offer crazy financial aid and there are junior colleges / state universities that offer 100% of aid to impoverished individuals. The people taking malinvestment (student loans for unproductive means / negative ROI) are firmly in the middle class bracket, both lower/upper sides of it.
- FussyZeus 7y agoAnd who decides what constitutes malinvestment? I'm guessing there will be plenty of funds made available for tech work, what with Twitter, Ubereats and Facebook being so critical. How about the arts? How about history and culture, you know the stuff that makes living worthwhile beyond your usefulness to line the pockets of capitalists? Or how about we just confront the problem dead on, remove the money and profit aspect entirely, and offer free college like dozens of other nations do, and have for many years, somehow without their economies imploding? Why must we sacrifice yet more of our society on the altar of profits? Fuck good investments. Fuck investors. Fuck this entire screwed up system that decides that anything that cannot be monetized is worthless.
- darepublic 7y agoThat's why you should learn things you enjoy and find intrinsically valuable because there is never a guarantee of employability
- AlexCoventry 7y agoThat's a harmful attitude. Of course there's more reliable merit in studying things your community will value you and reward you for. If you do your own thing, hoping that it leads to something fabulous, you'd better take responsibility for the risk of failure.
- graeme 7y agoThis is potentially the lump of labour fallacy. There isn't a set amount of work to be done. If we have a mass of students learning no useful skills and divert them into useful fields, then the overall productivity of the economy will go up. Obviously if everyone floods into a single field there's some limit: you can't productively employ 10x the plumbers without a matching increase in buildings. But in general, better skills should lead to a better economy.
- jackcosgrove 7y agoGermany has been better managing its human capital for generations with its apprenticeships, trade schools, and cheap universities. There are problems of course with switching lanes and with second tier universities, but on the whole it seems to work better.
- CapricornNoble 7y ago"If we have a mass of students learning no useful skills and divert them into useful fields..." What do we do if a significant portion of the students who already aren't learning useful skills lack the neural plasticity to become productive in other endeavors? Or in other words, how do we incorporate humans into the economy when those individuals are objectively inferior at EVERY task compared to an automated (robot, AI, etc...) alternative? Especially as we consider things like climate change and austerity, and how humans are supposedly the greatest threat to overall environmental longevity?
- graeme 7y agoThat's a good question in the medium term. But, the US education system presents a clear misallocation of skills that can be fixed. It won't solve the underlying issue you address, but it will improve things, and waste less societal resources in the educational process too.