4 ms·
The paper does not have any redeeming qualities and the title and abstract do not even align with the content. In my opinion, conversation and other high level
by ilaksh 7y ago
The paper does not have any redeeming qualities and the title and abstract do not even align with the content.
In my opinion, conversation and other high level skills are sort of the icing on the cake of general intelligence. I believe that the key abilities that enable general intelligence are those that humans share with many other animals.
So I think that a research goal of animal-like intelligence will give the most progress as long as the abilities of more intelligent animals like mammals are the goal.
I think that people who have worked closely with animals or had a pet will more easily recognize that.
Animals adapt to complex environments. They take in high bandwidth data of multiple types. They have a way to automatically create representations that allow them to understand, model and predict their environment. They learn in an online manner.
No software approaches true emulation of the subtleties of behavior and abilities of an animal like a cat or a dog.
Obviously it's another step to say that leads to human intelligence. I'm not trying to prove it, but will just say that it seems mainly to be a matter of degree rather than quality. If cats and dogs are not convincing for you, look at the complexity of chimpanzee behavior.
So this is just a half baked comment on a thread, and I would not try to publish it, but I don't think that the paper is actually much more rigorous and yet we are supposed to take it seriously.
arxiv is amazing and we should not change it, but you have to keep in mind that there is literally zero barrier for entry, and anyone's garbage essay can get on there with the trappings of real academic work. So you just have to read carefully and judge on the merit or total lack thereof.