10 ms·
I don't know about 8chan but when it comes to 4chan, there's a certain sport in what people comment in threads. There's countless threads of people claiming to
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I don't know about 8chan but when it comes to 4chan, there's a certain sport in what people comment in threads. There's countless threads of people claiming to be planning something awful (terrorism, suicide, robbery, eating Taco Bell, etc.) And in the comments you'll see people say all kinds of things, that if taken at face value, are pretty horrible (and maybe even criminal conspiracy.)
But the crux is that these people are not serious (though I'm sure some are), they're just saying it for the sport of calling the bluff of anonymous people they perceive as trolls or brooding teens.
It's like the scene in Futurama where Hermes is threatening to jump off a building to his death and Bender says, "Do a flip!"
This doesn't make it right. And doesn't absolve them of the legal hot water they'd find themselves in. But I hope these individuals, if charged with a crime, get lawyers who will vigorously defend this point.
Edit: I want to re-state that I emphatically do not hold any opinions on this topic. I'm just trying to share a bit about what these image boards can be like.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> But the crux is that these people are not serious (though I'm sure some are), So which is it? Serious or not? How do we know which is which? > they're just saying it for the sport of calling the bluff of anonymous people they perceive as trolls or brooding teens. By what definition of the term is this sport? If anything it's callous, and probably illegal in most jurisdictions.
- microwavecamera 7y agoIt's all fun and games until someone gets shot.
- xwdv 7y agoEven then, it’s still fun and games if you know where to look these days.
- happytoexplain 7y agoI agree thoroughly with this prudent assessment. One thing I'd like to add is that, after far too much of my life spent on 4chan, I believe the line between a total joke and an expression of a sincere sentiment is much blurrier even than it seems. It's much more subtle than a crowd of irreverent kidders dotted with occasional cold blooded misanthropes.
- arkades 7y agoIt’s fundamentally the long-tail problem coupled with the low bandwidth nature of message boards. In real life, pretty much everyone you meet is kidding, and the whackos usually send many additional red flags. On 4chan, you collect the more extreme humor, plus the nuts, minus the additional information that you would use to distinguish them in real life. The internet has in some ways damaged my sense of humor: I’m so much more prone to taking people’s extreme comments at face value than I used to be, because at some point, the Internet has introduced me to a more extreme view genuinely espoused.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoSo you thoroughly agree with the parent comment, but add the disclaimer that the line between joke and sincerity is blurry. It is, therefore, unclear, what exactly, your point is. Do you agree, or disagree? Is it a reasonable assessment to both agree and disagree?
- floatingatoll 7y agoTheir lawyers may try, but if their speech is found to have encouraged law-breaking, they can still be convicted and jailed — regardless that they only did it for sport. https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-time-to-stop-using-the-fire-in-a-crowded-theater-quote/264449/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-tim... > In 1969, the Supreme Court's decision in Brandenburg v. Ohio effectively overturned Schenck and any authority the case still carried. There, the Court held that inflammatory speech--and even speech advocating violence by members of the Ku Klux Klan--is protected under the First Amendment, unless the speech "is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nothal 7y agoI'm not convinced that's the proper reading of that law. FWIW, I'm not a lower just a person with an appreciation of legal questions. I was under the impression that the word 'imminent' implied you had to reasonably be aware those people were going to commit a crime immediately. For example if you're at the front of a mob of angry people and tell them to go loot a shop. I think it would be hard to convincingly say that on a website where 99% of users are joking that posters were inciting crime directly.
- pas 7y agoKnowing is a very fuzzy bar here. There are/were people who turned to 4chan's /b/ (or other boards) for a very twisted way of guidance. ("Should I kill myself?", "shoot up the school", do "an hero" etc.) Of course in these cases the Internet Hate Machine's response is the same, but the intensity and effectiveness varies. Is any single commenter legally responsible? Probably not. And not because they lacked intent, but because 99.9% of these threads are empty trolling. So they could be almost sure knowing nothing would happen. However, if someone does this for years in the hopes to participate in a thread that is not a dud, well that's of course a different state of mind, but it'd be hard to prove.
- 7y ago
- anigbrowl 7y agoI don't know about 8chan but Welp, they're not the same, and /pol/ isn't the same as /b/, or the end of that particular rabbit hole either.
- tenpies 7y agoEven /pol/ isn't /pol/. It's a fascinating place in that you can have an openly Neo-Nazi thread right next to the Pro-Zion thread, right next to the Christian thread, followed by the Islam thread. The Yang Gang thread is right next to the MAGA thread which is right next to the Bernies Bros thread. As much as it is a terrible place, it is also probably the most diverse place in the internet and I sometimes wonder if by exposing each other to diametrically opposed ideas, they temper each other out. I really hope some sort of researcher is archiving it for posterity because I don't think there has ever been an experiment like it.
- krapp 7y ago>I sometimes wonder if by exposing each other to diametrically opposed ideas, they temper each other out. I mean... you're posting this in a thread about a /pol/ user committing mass murder due to his racist and anti-semitic ideals... and he wasn't even the first to do so. So... no?
- anigbrowl 7y agoYou, can but most of the time you'll have neo-nazi threads next to other neo-nazi threads. Let's look at a sample of the top 50 threads on /pol/ right now (sticky and untitled threads excluded; contains offensive content): Dylann Roof's letter to Tucker Carlson Who's this Katie Hopkins? South Africa accept the jews or you will lose You're buying cryptocurrency, right anon? White men who cant get a white woman should bleach a good looking brown girl. Why should we bother? DOXX REPORT:ANTIFA MEMBER IN NATIONAL GUARD 8ch got a search warrant 6 weeks ago (two months) Join the marines Hungary is BASED 99 turkroach overflight violations on Greek airspace in a single day. /leftypol/ explains why they’re marxists Music Video shows White Kids in Cages, Tortured /SIG/ Self Improvement General Would things be different if America became natsoc instead of Germany? Lesbian NASA Astronaut attack on bus in Camden Town London with her date Ontario Anon Goes Shitposting IRL homeless anon tip thread AJ got framed, again. Rockefellers and the Anglo Industrialist Dynasties Saint Tarrant pleads NOT guilty! RIP Léon Degrelle China Cucks to Hong Kong Brenton Tarrant Memetic Warfare Thread № XII requesting knowledge of the Weimar Republic White Victims of Black Crime - Thread #010: Remember lads, subscribe to Pewdiepie "Durr Trump is a Jewish sellout!" Should the Flyover states just secede From the Union Single Mother Documentary New leaked doc shows the USA and trump gets raped by mexican rapists The implication of Feminism just being a shittest for society. Average jews. If We Don't Globally Collapse Within The Next Two Decades, Humanity Is Doomed to Extinction Holocaust Is Fake History - 8968 Paid Shilling Hours Druid/pol/ #0032 "Esoteric Operations" edition Nick Fuentes sells out to the Jews and tells a Jewish lawyer he denounces anti-semitism We lost 4chan White males Highest Suicide rates in the Country Sol Pais 2nd thread Asian hate/redpill thread 2: kill all Asians edition Yellow Vests protest for 31st straight week in Paris Doctor E.Michael Jones is apparently being blamed for the latest Synagogue Shooting. Was Spanish Caste system the best system /ECO GENERAL/ III - Summer Edition Trans "rights" are child abuse /pol/ WEBM Thread / MP4 Thread /RPG/ Redpill general Antifa wants you to deplatform "fashy farmers" On the topic of race and gene editing. ¯\(°_o)/¯
- jpmattia 7y ago> But the crux is that these people are not serious (though I'm sure some are) Some of us distinctly remember the SiliconInvestor boards from long ago: Some wag started a topic on "I need to sell a kidney". Naturally, few took him seriously. Turns out he was completely serious, and shortly after was in the news: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_O._Barton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_O._Barton
- droithomme 7y agoThe article you link to is of someone who committed suicide and was considered to be a serial killer who executed his family. The article doesn't mention kidney sales, in fact a search of the text for the term "kidney" yields no hits.
- Sebguer 7y agoYeah, the Wikipedia article doesn't mention it, but here's a post from a user named "K44B" on SiliconInvestor circa June 2nd, 1999, and then a bunch of discussion a few months later about it being Mark Barton. Doesn't seem to be any clear proof, but at least it's a rumor that dates from the same year as the murders: https://www.siliconinvestor.com/readmsg.aspx?msgid=10909471 https://www.siliconinvestor.com/readmsg.aspx?msgid=10909471 (also holy shit is the UX on this forum awful)
- jpmattia 7y agoThe original thread is here: https://www.siliconinvestor.com/subject.aspx?subjectid=28684 https://www.siliconinvestor.com/subject.aspx?subjectid=28684 > and then a bunch of discussion a few months later I remember the board got taken down, but was restored. The shooting was July 29, 1999, and the SIers were already discussing it on the restored thread Aug 11. The thread message at the top changed a few times, but it was pretty clear by Aug 16. https://www.siliconinvestor.com/readmsg.aspx?msgid=10974409 https://www.siliconinvestor.com/readmsg.aspx?msgid=10974409 > (also holy shit is the UX on this forum awful) Hard to believe it was a giant step forward at the time (do we think people will look back at our current websites in 2039 and think they're beautiful?). SI was quite the daytraders place in its day, and this NYT article from Nov that year captures the spirit pretty well: https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/library/magazine/home/19991121mag-klam.html https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/library/magazine... (Mark Barton is also mentioned in that article, which was published pretty close to the absolute peak of the internet bubble. What a time.)
- treve 7y agoThe best place to hide bigotry is irony.
- jccalhoun 7y ago8chan really got popular when gamergate people were kicked off of 4chan.
- meruru 7y agoI wish more people realized this is what happens when you attack a group - it gets stronger.
- nemothekid 7y agoYou can hardly describe it as "attacking a group". At the time moot got tired of these people crying 24/7 on /v/, the video games board. moot has frequently exercised his unique power to ban a topic to prevent a single topic from overrunning a board. And, like the other chans before it, those most invested in that topic have a huge persecution complex and believe they are being censored when they are simple being told to take their soapbox elsewhere.
- meruru 7y agoCall it whatever you want, it's painfully obvious to me that things like feminist activism have fueled the rise of the alt-right. I say this as someone who was a regular on 4chan during the gamergate fiasco and watched it happen.
- donttreadonwe 7y agoI'm not sure I agree with your argument. People say a lot of things on these boards "for the lolz", or so they say. I don't know how far the defense gets you. Can swatting be for the lolz?
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoSWAT-ing has an imminent intent to invoke deleterious action; pretty easy to differentiate from simple speech.
- maxheadroom 7y ago>SWAT-ing has an imminent intent to invoke deleterious action To be fair, if the incidence of escalation to use of lethal force weren't so prevalent as to be an almost guarantee in the states, the results of SWAT'ing wouldn't even be a problem but more of a nuissance, in the first place, yeah? In other words, if the resultant actions of the police forces - whether believing they were acting in the interests of public safety or not - weren't so haphazardly deleterious to the public at-large (see the baby with burns because of tear gas thrown in it's crib, as an example), this wouldn't have been a viably dangerous exploitation surface to begin with. Whilst I can understand that such an action (SWAT'ing) is bad and I am not trying to argue against, dissuade, nor assuage the realities of it, I'm merely trying to point out that the realities of the dangers of it's byproduct solely exist due to societial declination; particularly, in the devaluation of human life, as a whole - which has given carte blance, as it were, to the use of lethal force. In other words, if lethal force weren't such a foreseeable outcome of SWAT'ing, would it even be something considered deleterious or would it be moreso considered merely a waste of time and resources (which, in and of itself, could have secondary or tertiary effects that are possibly damaging [e.g.: we couldn't respond to 'x' critical situation because we were dealing with 'y' critical situation])?
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI like where you're coming from, but it doesn't quite work IMO. Even having the police just knock on your door might be deleterious enough: The point is the outcome is known, expected, likely, and almost certainly has an observable (by third parties that the person ordinarily associates with) negative effect. Saying something nasty to someone in an online forum, that if ignored will have no effect, is still markedly different; and is readily differentiable. A first test might be "if I didn't see the speech would it still have an effect".
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoI’ve found that some people are often much more serious than they let on. These “jokes” provide perfect camouflage.
- trentlott 7y ago"In every joke is the seed of truth" Unless you're a professional, jokes mostly just reveal the things going on in your brain If you have a soft spot for jokes about dumb women or dumb [race] or encouraging kids to harm themselves, well...
- Retra 7y agoIrony stops being ironic and starts being an honest picture of what you are the moment you start doing it out of habit.
- IAmEveryone 7y ago> Edit: I want to re-state that I emphatically do not hold any opinions on this topic. The most astonishing part of your post is that you consider what you're writing "not an opinion". Because it is nothing but opinion: it's the theory that thousands of non-antisemites would somehow find pleasure in some sort of "sport" of "pretending" to be vile anti-semites (and racists etc). To repeat this lame excuse is to amplify it, and one wouldn't do so without considering it convincing. I don't see it is as convincing. I'm just as much not an anti-semite as these people pretend to be, and I see absolutely no mechanism how I would enjoy pretending otherwise. And even if, somehow, there's a psychological explanation of how spewing insincere hatred provides these people pleasure: would that somehow make this behaviour worthy of public support? Even in the best case of not having any effect on the real world, aren't these people are just stewing in their ("pretend") hatred, wasting whatever time and potential they might have on malevolent low-brow attempts of lame humour? But of course there are effects on the real world. We've just seen two such tragedies and there have been countless smaller ones. If posters there really are fundamentally of sound mind and not intending to be part of actual harm, can they just continue as before? Doesn't the proof that some people actually do commit violent crimes for fame and lulz somehow destroy this excuse of it all just being an act?
- bitL 7y agoThere was this lady that encouraged some weak boy to commit suicide, for the sport as well, and succeeded. It's tricky to find the line between teenage shitposting (hey TSA, my new song is da bomb!) and premediated psychopathic enticement on weak prey to commit something horrible.
- bradleyjg 7y agoWith apologies for coarseness: The Rule of Goats: even if you say you're only fucking goats ironically, you're still a goatfucker —-Popehat
- grawprog 7y agoI dunno about now, but back when I browsed on 8chan for a bit the people on there genuinely worried me. There was a board dedicated specifically to doxing and messing with people's lives, there were multiple successful raids on social media websites carried out and the slower pace of the boards meant there was more time for genuine collaboration on things. 4chan people always seemed like they were playing, 8chan people got shit done and many of the things i seen on 8chan actually tended to be more genuine than 4chan. They really took pride in the hatechan nickname. The place left me with a really bad taste. There was some genuinely nasty people there. Not to mention the fucking pedophiles. So many fucking pedophiles. That place really made me believe there's no hope for people like that.