6 ms·
I can't help but be sceptical about the suggestion that Iran attacked the oil tanker. They're trying to be friends with Japan, but they attack a Japanese vesse
by lordnacho 7y ago
I can't help but be sceptical about the suggestion that Iran attacked the oil tanker.
They're trying to be friends with Japan, but they attack a Japanese vessel while the PM of Japan is actually visiting? Really?
They aren't a superpower, and the US has bases all the way around Iran. Maybe I'm a strategic simpleton whose entire diplomatic experience is playing Civ, but it just doesn't seem smart.
Plus you have to wonder about the evidence for the Iraq war. That seemed pretty flimsy too. And it involved some of the same senior staff.
If international diplomacy were a reality TV show, it would make sense though.
- codr7 7y agoThe reason it doesn't make any sense is that its all a bunch of lies and excuses to start a war, its not like the US hasn't been barking up this tree for quite a while now. And there were no weapons of mass destruction, all lies. It's public information but you'll have to search for it yourself because it will never be reported in the mainstream media, people might start asking the wrong questions.
- hurrdurr2 7y agoThe US going to war with Iran is John Bolton's wet dream.
- codr7 7y agoJohn Bolton should do the world a favor and strap himself onto one of Musk's rockets if you ask me, I wouldn't mind if it explodes either just to make sure. This imperialist crap is getting soo old, we're all in the same stupid canoe and its about time we started acting like it.
- SantalBlush 7y agoMy hope is that ordinary citizens across the globe will become more connected via the internet, and as a result, will develop a strong distaste for war in general.
- codr7 7y agoAnd here we are :) Ordinary (?) citizens, connecting over the internet to share our distaste for war and hope for a better future.
- SantalBlush 7y agoHN isn't very representative of the general population, but this is a good start. I'm thinking along the lines of someone in Wisconsin chatting about fishing with someone from Indonesia via an online forum, for example. That kind of thing could really help dissolve blind nationalism.
- svachalek 7y agoThat was the idea 20 years ago. Now search engines, social networks, and national firewalls are more effective propaganda machines than television ever was because they're individually targeted. It's going to take a new generation of people who are not just ready to swallow anything they read in their newsfeed.
- ajmurmann 7y agoEven from an imperialist point of view makes no sense to me. It would be a huge distraction from actual threats to US imperialism, Russia and China. Sitting presidents are more likely to stay in office during wars though.
- sittingPres 7y agoOddly, I think Trump is ready to throw the next election, and could take it or leave it. It seems likely that he's deeply motivated to eschew war, especially considering the perspective that he avoided military service via bone spurs or "feet" or whatever it was. I don't think he fancies the martial aspect of the oval office. It's really weird when you think about it from that angle. He probably doesn't want war, but branches of the pentagon, advisors and DoD/spook corporations are trying to crack open the gates. He probably would happily lose the re-election, but his idiotic NASCAR-watching political base is going to rail against opposing candidates and shoe horn him back into a second term. I don't sympathize, but I really do think Trump is probably over it, in a "been there, done that" sense.
- jules-jules 7y agoIt makes sense if you consider the interests of some of the other Middle Eastern nations the US is friends with. Remember the US doesn’t act alone.
- pvg 7y agoIran also has a complicated internal power structure the players in which are not necessarily always in agreement or in full knowledge of each others' actions. It makes it a trickier state to deal with compared to your run-of-the mill unitary dictatorship.
- jdm2212 7y agoThis is a (correct) view that is frustratingly underreported.
- mrkstu 7y agoIronically this was very true in imperial Japan. I recently listened to Craig Nelson's "Pearl Harbor: From Infamy to Greatness" and this was stressed repeatedly. The factionalism, not just between the civilian government and the military, but between the Navy and the Army was vast. There was no unitary government, in any sense. Their Navy never thought they could defeat the United States over a protracted war, but the internal factionalism forced their hand.
- joyeuse6701 7y agoIt ought to make it easier to divide them in war, and come to a swifter resolution in conflict.
- mikeash 7y agoMilitarily defeating the Iranian government would be easy no matter what. The hard part is winning the peace. And by “hard” I mean “essentially impossible, and trying to do so will wreck us.” This is what the assholes who want a war with Iran either fail or refuse to understand.
- pvg 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War
- eternalban 7y agoIRI's political dynamics is no way informs its ideological military arm: http://iranprimer.usip.org/resource/revolutionary-guards http://iranprimer.usip.org/resource/revolutionary-guards
- RappingBoomer 7y agocoughMOSSADcough
- partiallypro 7y agoWe do have video of what appears to be Iranians removing an undetonated mine from one of the ships. It is entirely possible, and it is known, that the Iranian military isn't exactly cohesive like other countries. There are fractures and some rogue elements. It's entirely possible a rogue element did this, or it's possible it came from the top down. Iran knows that the US public doesn't believe its own US intelligence after Iraq, so it could easily be behind the attacks knowing that the US is on a leash of public opinion to do anything about it.
- eternalban 7y agoEven taken at face value, removing something in full view of US Navy (present at the scene for 4 hours) is not the same thing as "attaching" mines. It may well be that they were collecting evidence, on the record helpfully provided by US. It is also interesting that a 3rd world country's navy has better camera equipment than the premiere power.
- killjoywashere 7y ago> It is also interesting that a 3rd world country's navy has better camera equipment than the premiere power. Defense acquisitions at it's finest. Various bits of that camera have been certifiably touched by workers in all 50 states, and it took 10 years just to work out the contract details. That thing is bomb-proof but will fail catastrophically when exposed to a firm sneeze, and the CMOS sensor was "commercial off the shelf" tech from the lunar landing era.
- partiallypro 7y agoThen what do you make of Iran showing up afterwards and forcing a ship that actually saved some sailors to hand over said sailors at gun point before the US could get there, therein making it seem like Iran rescued the sailors? Or the photo of what looks like a mine, and the Iranian boat being in the exact same place...then that item just disappearing? Seems like a lot of coincidences. That's even excluding a huge surge in activity of the Houthis, which are Iranian funded. "It is also interesting that a 3rd world country's navy has better camera equipment than the premiere power." I also don't know where you're getting this, the video the US Navy has is clearly taken from a drone miles and miles away from the ship, completely out of view of anyone.
- mikeash 7y agoThe phrasing of your first paragraph confuses me. “I can’t help but...” as if this sentiment were hard to justify. The US government is notorious for lying its way into wars, and the current administration is full of psychopaths who would love a justification to invade Iran. It’s like finding a notorious serial killer standing over a body holding a knife who says, “a ghost did it.” “I can’t help but be skeptical about the ghost....” It was painfully obvious bullshit in 2003 and we must not fall for it again. If we do, it’ll make the disaster of Iraq look like a fun little game.
- lordnacho 7y agoI guess it's a nuance of what that phrase means. It seems to me there are many reasons to disbelieve that the Iranians would do this. Reasons that can't be ignored no matter what logical contortions I were to make.
- 50656E6973 7y agoWhat reasons?
- Stratoscope 7y agoIt sounds like the phrase did confuse you. "I can't help but be sceptical..." simply means "I am skeptical..." Try that substitution in your example and it should be more clear: > It’s like finding a notorious serial killer standing over a body holding a knife who says, “a ghost did it.” “I am skeptical about the ghost....”
- zyxzevn 7y agoJapanese Tanker Owner Denies Ship Hit By Mine, Says Crew Saw "Flying Objects" Before Attack https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019-06-14/japanese-tanker-owner-denies-ship-hit-mine-says-crew-saw-flying-objects-attack https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019-06-14/japanese-tanker-ow... I think this means that someone else tries to ignite a war. Could be similar to the USS Liberty incident, but it all needs an investigation by neutral parties. Does the US needs all that oil?
- thephyber 7y ago> Does the US needs all that oil? The USA doesn't need to use the oil for the USA to claim there is either a "national security" or world geopolitical rationale for going to war to "protect" it. Petrodollar Warfare[1] is a theory that the US can and does attack (or otherwise undermine) any oil producing country that tries to transact its oil in any currency (or commodity) other than USD. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrodollar_warfare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrodollar_warfare
- ssvss 7y agoI found this argument on why Iran would attack, in r/geopolitics to be plausible. https://www.reddit.com/r/geopolitics/comments/c0gi8b/why_iran_benefits_from_these_attacks/ https://www.reddit.com/r/geopolitics/comments/c0gi8b/why_ira...
- tlear 7y agoI think this a perceptions issue. IRGC done VERY well recently, successes in Syria, Houthis, Iraq, much closer ties and success in Gaza/Hamas. They feel good about themselves and view US as impotent(as in Syria). It could be a threat and demonstration of what they can do. These are hard experienced and utterly committed men. They do not feel weak at all. Trump is a bit of a joke to them as Obama was before.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoIf Iran didn't attack the ships who did? It would be impossible for the US Govt to orchestrate this and keep it secret. Enough people inside government would be horrified that it would 100% leak immediately if not beforehand. If not Iran, why is there video of an Iranian navy vessel pulled up alongside the attacked tanker?
- smnrchrds 7y ago> If Iran didn't attack the ships who did? Iran's regional rivals, Saudi Arabia and UAE have been staunch proponents of a US attack on Iran and they stand to gain enormously if such an attack happens: a major oil supplier gets removed, increasing demand for their oil; the war increases the price of oil; their only serious rival in the region gets destroyed; and to top it all, it will be at no cost to them—US will pay for the war with money, lives, and reputation and they stand to gain all the benefits. It would be very convenient if Iran does something to legitimize, even force US to destroy the country to rubble, wouldn't it? > Enough people inside government would be horrified that it would 100% leak immediately if not beforehand. Saudi Arabia does not have the same limitation. If they could orchestrate and get away with Khashoggi murder in another country, a tanker attack in their backyard is a piece of cake for them.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoif they could orchestrate and get away with Khashoggi murder in another country They totally didn't get away with it though. They were incompetent, bungled it and totally got caught. Faking an Iranian mine attack, including getting an Iranian navy vehicle filmed at the scene is orders of magnitude more complex and difficult. No way a gulf state could do it. US could do it, but couldn't keep the secret.
- tlear 7y agoThing is that SA is incompetent. Really incompetent. You can say many things about IRGC but they are not incompetent. The only possible actors are..(without taking video into account). Iran, Israel(incredibly unlikely but they could do it and keep it secret for a while), Houthis(same thing as Iran really). US is just incapable of an operation like this and keeping it secret.
- Taniwha 7y agoHonestly I can't get past the idea that somehow an image of Iranians removing a mine from an oil tanker is somehow a smoking gun proving that they put it on ... It all screams fake news, information warfare, to me. As far as who would like the US to go to war with Iran (apart from Bolton) Saudi Arabia and Israel spring to mind ... Remember how we were railroaded into war with Iraq using fake news about weapons of mass destruction (from the Whitehouse that time), fool us once shame on you fool us a second time shame on us.