4 ms·
This is a little weird to me. Why purge cancer research? So what if China steals a cure for certain types of cancer and starts making it? Some American company
by mrguyorama 7y ago
This is a little weird to me. Why purge cancer research? So what if China steals a cure for certain types of cancer and starts making it? Some American company makes slightly less profit? It's not a national security issue, like making sure critical infrastructure is only open to the NSA. It wouldn't even be easy to reimport a "cancer cure" pill from china into the American market. And it's way easier to reverse engineer a drug that china produces from research stolen from the US then it is to do that research in the first place.
- StavrosK 7y ago> Some American company makes slightly less profit? I mean, bingo.
- TheOperator 7y ago>Some American company makes slightly less profit? That's a bingo. Now allow me to morally justify this AMERICA style: "When we allow foreign researchers to steal research from healthcare businesses it reduces the return on investment these businesses make. This has a chilling effect on the amount of Cancer research that can be funded. With less innovation by the world leader in Cancer research ultimately more patients will unnessecarily die and suffer"
- mrguyorama 7y agoBut how much does it actually cost to re-steal that IP back from China? Does America actually respect chinese intellectual property?
- johnchristopher 7y agoRe-stealing the IP isn't as profitable as being the first to market. I guess ?
- agumonkey 7y agoIs the chemo market sensitive to first-to-market effects ?
- sjg007 7y agoThis is an interesting argument, but I think there are some logical problems in it. But it is the type of argument you will hear as justification for this approach.
- cwkoss 7y agoAnyone uses "chilling effect on investment" in an argument for something is probably lying through their teeth trying to deceive you. See also: trickle down economics, safety regulations, consumer financial protections...
- DoctorOetker 7y agoI agree, theres some obvious mission creep going on here: >Her resignation, and the departures in recent months of three other top Chinese American scientists from Houston-based MD Anderson, stem from a Trump administration drive to counter Chinese influence at U.S. research institutions. Did she or did she not Chinesely influence the Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center?
- Gibbon1 7y agoAbout 25 years ago I started making the snide comment that our leaders think they own all those factories in China making our stuff. Looks like recently they figured out that's not the case and are now panicking. Or more to the point China is starting to create it's own IP, patents, and trade secrets.