4 ms·
"Soon enough the CIO sniffed out the project and called her in to a disciplinary council." Somebody has apparently lost touch with who the customer for IT is.
by tyingq 7y ago
"Soon enough the CIO sniffed out the project and called her in to a disciplinary council."
Somebody has apparently lost touch with who the customer for IT is.
- chrismatheson 7y agoI've seen this over & over, i always think of it as a sort of a god complex from "admin" rights.
- burfog 7y agoIt's fear of copyright lawsuits and even having the Business Software Alliance convince federal marshals raid the business. It's fear of malware. It's fear of data being locked up in the format used by an employee's personal tool. Above all, it's fear of being held responsible for any of the above. It's also a fear of being not needed.
- raverbashing 7y agoAnd the best way to avoid all first 3 is doing your job and giving them the correct tools the employee needs (even for the things they don't "strictly" need for work but might be useful)
- SerLava 7y agoYeah, it seems like the VP's choices were A) risk IT security or B) guarantee total personal career failure Having the resources to install a CRM for someone this year is a fundamental part of any properly equipped IT department. Can you call your IT security strong if you are dangling irresistible incentives to break the security?
- spydum 7y agoNo, CIO role often carries responsibility for security. VP violates policy is like skirting regulation - yes it cost less money, but for all you know they are not compliant with policy and aren’t doing the whole job. However it does often seem like IT doesn’t consider SaaS solutions - they always want to build something their selves without doing cost analysis.
- tyingq 7y agoSure, you need security. I would, though, expect to be summarily fired if I proposed something like a "disciplinary council" for when I had a disagreement with my customers. If you need rules to force the business to engage with you, you've failed.
- lightbritefight 7y agoIf a large part of your job is security, and your "customers" had opted to start stealing product off the floor because it was "easier than waiting in a line", you would be fired for not bringing it up. Thats the situation the CIO had to respond to. Just because its not part if your role to consider security implications of these SaaS services doesnt mean he's out of line for doing so.
- tyingq 7y agoTo true up the analogy, they are waiting in a line that's 3 years long.
- thisisnico 7y agoIT Does consider SaaS solutions. When the business executives see the cost of the solutions, the business leaders decide to roll your own. SaaS isn't the end-all be all for everything. It's all about value add and achieving a goal at the end of the day. Trust me IT would much rather roll a SaaS solution, far, far less of a headache and less overhead for the department.
- burfog 7y agoI have to use SaaS solutions for work, and the security situation terrifies me. I have to put my corporate password, with access to all sorts of important stuff, into a sketchy 3rd-party web site. This looks mighty bad.
- syshum 7y agoProperly implemented no you would never do that, you would use a trusted SAML auth server to Authentication with your Domain Creds, Something like Azure AD, ADFS, or 3rd party (that you assume to trust) like OneLogin. In all cases you would never enter your password into the SaaS service you are redirected to a secure portal controlled by the Auth Service, a token is then issued back to the SaaS service Further it would be recommended not to use an elevated account and certainly not something like a Domain Admin account for those services
- thisisnico 7y agoTo be honest, I find it odd when you treat it as if everyone else that you work with is a customer. I don't believe in this philosophy. The business is my customer. The business is what IT is trying to protect. If you have individuals that are not following policies, they would be disciplined like HR would discipline for not following policies. It's all in place to protect the business and what's best for the business. Sure you'd like admin rights to your own machine, that will help you individually, but will it help the business as a whole if we get hit with cryptowall again?
- mc32 7y agoAgreed. Everyone is beholden to the company and its principles, not the CEO or manager, though there should be alignment, but when there isn’t, then it’s the company.
- kyriee 7y agoDid you miss the line where it was written "before we started the program, we were losing revenue. Now we increased it by 1MM$ / month"? It seems that the whole point of the article is that while IT thinks that it is serving the customer (the business), it actually lost track of what it was needed to: helping it succeed.
- bob33212 7y agoIt goes both ways. Is the business user taking inappropriate risks to get his own work done quicker? Or is IT denying access to vendors to minimize his personal responsibility?
- scarface74 7y agoI find most “IT security policies” that hamper developers to be mostly security theatre. No matter how many policies they put in place, since they aren’t developers, one junior developer can write: var sql = “select * from Customer where firstname = ‘“ + firstname + “‘“; And thwart all of your security “best practices.” I was the lead dev at a medium size non tech company, and the hoops I had to go through to get anything done dealing with the “security team” was ridiculous and of course I didn’t have access to production to troubleshoot for awhile. I had ultimate control of all the code that did go through the process. If I were to do something stupid or purposefully malicious, while I didn’t have access to the environment - my code did. As far as someone mistakingly installing a “crypto wall”, if a user can download a program that doesn’t require admin access, that program has access to the user’s files. The system can be restored much easier than the user’s data.
- mc32 7y agoIt depends. If the company has instituted SSO and MFA and someone goes out and uses a solution that is outside of that, they could be exposing the company to liability.
- tyingq 7y agoIt's the fact that something like a "disciplinary council" exists, and that it was the first tactic the CIO went with that bothers me. There's a reason they went around the CIO. I suspect if the CIO had met with this person they could have learned and helped.
- mc32 7y agoThe problem is bureaucracy and unwillingness of IT to be agile and responsive. Their weapon is procedure which quashes initiatives. At the same time though, going outside like that can have major effects on compliance if they are subject to audits, aside from the security considerations.
- PeterisP 7y agoIn the situation described in the article, the manager had gone to the CIO but CIO refused to help them. "The CIO admitted that he had been approached and explained that he had informed the VP that IT already had a project with SAP to deliver what the VP needed. “Yes, but that won’t be ready for me to use for three years, and I need something today,” retorted the VP." The manager had a valid and valuable reason ("increased revenue $1M per month") to require a service that CIO and their organization was unable to provide in a reasonable timeframe, but other companies on the market were.
- imtringued 7y agoThe "customer" doesn't care about IT and wants to do things behind the back of the CIO. The "customer" goes to extreme lengths to hide the fact that he is violating company policy by purchasing SaaS with his own credit card. If that employee leaves one day, all the data inside the SaaS is gone because nobody else knew about it. A malicious employee could also use it to extort the company.