13 ms·
Apple is making corporate ‘BYOD’ programs less invasive to user privacy
- jchw 7y agoThis is a welcome step. I moved (back) to iPhone recently and one thing I miss from Android is Work Profiles that can be turned on and off and act as pretty much a separated user. It sounds like this is slightly more limited than that, but it’s a good start. At least being able to easily turn work stuff off on the weekend is a huge deal for work life balance (and I feel a bit uncomfortable when my work stuff is effectively not isolated from my personal stuff.)
- DigitalTerminal 7y agoOnce you switched to Android because of privacy? I always wondered why people choose this operating system.
- vageli 7y ago> This is a welcome step. I moved (back) to iPhone recently and one thing I miss from Android is Work Profiles that can be turned on and off and act as pretty much a separated user. It sounds like this is slightly more limited than that, but it’s a good start. At least being able to easily turn work stuff off on the weekend is a huge deal for work life balance (and I feel a bit uncomfortable when my work stuff is effectively not isolated from my personal stuff.) Did Android do away with work profiles recently? I used to have one and then following an update from the Enterprise, the apps were commingled and there was no way to explicitly "turn off work".
- yati 7y agoI'm using Android (Pixel 3), and the work profile works for me. IMO it is much better than having to carry two phones.
- john-radio 7y agoIs it something different than just a separate local account?
- plushpuffin 7y agoThey allow your workplace to remotely administer your work account without giving them full control over your whole device.
- 6nf 7y agoApple is the only major player moving in the right direction when it comes to privacy. I'm so glad we have them!
- novas0x2a 7y agoI could be mistaken, but I think this is a somewhat weaker version of Android for Work, which shipped about two years ago, I believe (couldn't find the exact date). Perhaps Apple is doing something that AfW isn't already doing, but it's hard to tell from this article, which doesn't mention AfW at all.
- bestnameever 7y agoI'm not sure of the differences between AfW and this either but I don't think it matters in the big picture. Instead, I see this as just one step in many that Apple has taken in designing their products around user privacy, when possible.
- threeseed 7y ago> Using the per-app VPN feature, traffic from the Mail, Contacts and Calendars built-in apps will only go through the VPN if the domains match that of the business. Shame that Apple doesn't take this one step further and do it system-wide.
- CGamesPlay 7y agoThey will eventually, like they always do. They start with in house apps effectively to prove out the process, then publish the updated APIs required to use the functionality. Other examples: App Store itself, Siri, cross-app sharing... it always starts with just-Apple-apps before expanding.
- synaesthesisx 7y agoGiven their commitment to privacy as a selling point, it would be nice if Apple provided an integrated VPN service (say included with the upper iCloud tiers). For now I’m on the waitlist for Cloudflare’s offering - their DNS works fantastic.
- lostlogin 7y agoI’d use it but it prevents me using a Pihole (via VPN). The Pihole points at Cloudflare though, so they get me either way.
- wtmt 7y agoI doubt if Apple would start a VPN service. Even if it did, it’d have restrictions, like not allowing the user to break out of their geography since that could allow users to violate policies of content sellers on Apple’s store and also any geographical content segregation that Apple may do for its own shows and movies in the future.
- adamlett 7y agoVPN's are not a privacy panacea. Hiding your internet traffic from e.g. your ISP comes at the cost of divulging it to the VPN provider. Apple has been very clear that they don't want to be in a position where they would have to turn over sensitive information about their users to authorities, a position they can avoid by not providing such a service.
- Kalium 7y ago> Apple also noted that one of the big reasons users fear corporate BYOD programs is because they think the IT admin will erase their entire device when the enrollment ends — including their personal apps and data. Yes. This is a true thing that users fear. It tends to happen because they're using phones that don't allow any more constrained option. It's nice to see iOS catching up with Android in this.
- GordonS 7y agoI've had InTune and also some VMWare device management installed on my device in the past, and during installation you do get a warning that your admins will be able to delete everything on your device. It kind of makes sense for them to do that if your device is stolen, but I still just don't like handing over control of my device like that. They typically also enforce other annoying policies, such as not allowing rooted devices, not allowing swipe patterns and requiring a PIN/password. The VMWare one even required that all browsing went through their shitty browser app (and presumably they got all my history). Again, some of this makes sense from an enterprise point of view, but as a user it's annoying and feels invasive.
- Kalium 7y agoOh, it definitely feels annoying and invasive. Without sandboxing, the options are invasive MDM (because that's the only kind possible) and no MDM at all. I once watched an employer go from unwilling to adopt MDM to requiring it for accessing substantive systems on personal devices. The CEO lost his phone, and suddenly appreciated what MDM was good for. Users were given a choice: MDM, sandboxed if they had a device with modern technology, or no significant access on personal devices. A lot of users had phones that didn't offer sandboxing, so myself and several others found ourselves explaining quite often that there literally was no option available where remote wipe wasn't possible. If they didn't like that, well, they didn't actually need access from their phones, so... Anyway. I'm quite glad Apple is starting to actually catch up a bit.
- jiveturkey 7y agoI didn't read TFA fully but I suppose from your quote, what they didn't say was what corporate IT fears. I don't know how many corps care about this, but when I did that kind of job, I refuse to have my corp have access to a user's personal data, and be able to brick their personal device, etc. It's not acceptable from a privacy POV and not acceptable from an employee backlash POV. Anyway it was an easy choice because we never had sensitive data that could make it to a phone/tablet. In an environment more like that, I would probably have instituted some kind of privacy waiver that an employee would have to sign in order to BYOD (apple brand). That probably wouldn't fly today, in europe. GDPR and all that.
- mysterypie 7y agoAn obvious solution is to carry two devices: one for work, on which the company can install whatever corporate spyware they want, and one for personal use. There's no way I'm letting my employer administer or install unknown programs on my personal laptop and cell even with this enrollment option. This has nothing to do with trusting or distrusting Apple. It's due to avoiding complexity: having to think about a zillion cases of what the employer can and can't do. I don't want to study a 30-page security whitepaper and 300 pages of documentation that probably come with this new enrollment thingie. But if I have two devices--with physical separation--I don't have to think about all sorts of security and privacy gotchas. Buying a cheap extra work phone and carrying two phones is not that big a burden. Plus you can turn off the work phone during personal time, and turn off the personal phone during work.
- pjmlp 7y agoNaturally. I never got the BYOD thing. My employer should provide the required tools, if not, then the work is done within the constraints of what is available.
- aflag 7y agoIt's kind of weird that the employer wants the employee to bring their device, but don't want to trust the employee's device anyway.
- sdoering 7y agoSometimes it is not about trust. It is about regulations within the industry one works/contracts in. But if this is the case I believe strongly, that the employer must provide the necessary tooling.
- closeparen 7y agoWhich regulation requires spyware on endpoints, and where in the text does it say that?
- jimmcslim 7y agoI wonder if this lays the groundwork for multiuser support in iPadOS at least?
- MartyMartyn 7y agoGroundwork has been there for years, called 'Shared iPad' - but its for Education use only... Via an enterprise or education MDM solution you can restrict and configure the iPad in many, many different ways; again, its not for the consumer.
- jakobegger 7y agoThis is nice and all, but I really wish that Apple would allow some real multi-account functionality. Especially for iPads, but also for iPhones. When I hand my phone to my kids to play a game, I don't want them to have access to my email / text messages / contacts etc. It's ridiculous that a 1000€ device is restricted to single user mode. It's even worse for iPads -- they are perfect devices for sharing in the family, but only a single person can use them for Email / iMessage / Whatsapp / Facetime / ... But I don't have any hopes that Apple will fix this. They want everyone in the family to own their own set of iDevices.
- dragonwriter 7y agoYou don't need multiaccount functionality for the use case you describe, just app pinning. Of course, Android has both.
- jakobegger 7y ago"App Pinning" sounds like it's similar to "Guided Access" which has been available on the iPhone forever. That is not what I want. My kids are old enough to navigate the phone on their own, and they use multiple apps. I just want Face ID to recognize that it's my kid, and not show them notifications for my work related stuff, and just let them play Minecraft and Monument Valley or whatever they want.
- epanchin 7y agoBut Apple wants you to buy your kids their own devices.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoTrue, but it's also a pretty obnoxious form of nickle and diming for a company selling $1,000+ iPhones, and well worth complaining about. It’s also yet another way that locked-down devices allow manufacturers to advance their interests at the expense of consumers. There’s a Jailbreak tweak that enables multiple profiles...
- dewiz 7y agoIt feels like an over engineered solution for a simple problem. If Apple were instead to add multi-users support to iOS then it would be as simple as having a work identity with dedicated apps and segregated data, and a personal identity as such, invisible to IT.
- adamlett 7y agoSuch a "solution" would be a PITA. I for one am using my phone many times during a work day for personal stuff (e.g. messaging with my wife), and I am also often using it for work stuff in my free time (e.g. replying to email from my boss). I would go insane if I had to switch profiles every other time I had to do accomplish simple task in my phone.
- aNoob7000 7y agoThe problem is that most MDM solutions want to take over your device. At my employer, the MDM solution literally takes over your entire device. I've installed the solution on an iPhone, and a Samsung Galaxy S8 (with and without Knox) with the same result. Unfortunately, the result is I carry two phones instead of one. I think Apple's solution to the problem might work. As long as the companies data is separate from mine, what I do on my phone is private, and basic functionality like screenshots are available on my phone, the solution looks good to me.
- wool_gather 7y ago> I think Apple's solution to the problem might work. It might. As long as IT/Security can be convinced that it fulfills their goals. That doesn't seem like a sure thing.
- Quequau 7y agoI am not a wealthy man but there is no way I'd sign up for using any of my employer's comms infrastructure for personal use or use any of my personal equipment for business use. I don't live to work and there's no reason to hand over any more info about my personal life than necessary.
- DEADBEEFC0FFEE 7y agoAs someone who has managed 10k endpoints, BYOD is a very niche solution. The security threats that any company with data worth stealing has is non-trivial. Those folk in this thread moaning about corporate spyware, are living on another planet. Nobody has the resources, or the motivation to spy on anyone. When Oracle, Adobe and Microsoft come a knocking, knowing what is installed and being able to uninstall it save a $1 million, easy.
- masto 7y agoThere is some motivation. Imagine you're Tim Apple and you wake up one day to find The Verge has a front page story detailing all of your secret Apple Car technical details and plans through 2022 courtesy of a "source with firsthand knowledge of the project". I don't doubt for a minute that Apple has a corporate security team with the empowerment and resources to dig through employees' personal iMessages to find the leaker.
- jaimex2 7y agoAh, so this is why they killed all the other MDM based school management apps. Well played Apple.
- jiveturkey 7y agofinally. it's a thrice-removed description, but at a surface level it sounds better than android profiles, at least for work/home device sharing. for sharing with family members (parents/kids, eg) it doesn't sound so awesome. hey, if it means kids have to have their own tablet, well more power to apple then!
- dclusin 7y agoWill Apple employees will be allowed to use this program? They're notoriously paranoid about maintaining secrets. Wonder if their IT department would give up the control.
- larkost 7y agoI worked for Apple about 5 years ago, and there almost everyone I interacted with carried an Apple-owned iPhone that was specially setup for running internal in-development software. This was Apple's way of getting those builds tested by a large number of people before they went out. There were a few (software) restrictions placed on the devices, namely that you had to have password lock turned on, and a password complexity policy. But after that they really did not interfere at all. When I left I reset that phone myself, and then bought a new iPhone and used the backup (not including OS) of that phone off of iCloud (of course minus the Apple email account they just turned off, and a couple of Apple-only apps I was using). Other than some basic access controls on systems (especially around iOS sources), and a lot of prototype-asset-tracking (I ran a lab with a lot of that), Apple really does trust their developers to do the right thing. If they trust you to have the information, then they trust you not to share it without a lot of big-brother monitoring. And there really is very little in the way of an IT department at Apple as you would normally think of it. They provided the network and the printers, but setting up your own computer was usually up to you and whatever help you got from your team (who really were the ones who knew what you needed for resources).
- jdofaz 7y agoI've experienced law enforcement raiding offices and confiscating technology for evidence collection. They will return the devices but not for years. I don't want anything work related on my personal device.
- gumby 7y agoBYOD is also a driver for dual sim phones, which Apple has finally introduced (they have been common in China for some time). When Apple announced them the us press discussion was all about international travel.