3 ms·
Renting anything really isn't a bad move. There's not much upside to owning something that depreciates in value. Instead of buying a sofa for 2000$ renting one
by Barrin92 7y ago
Renting anything really isn't a bad move. There's not much upside to owning something that depreciates in value. Instead of buying a sofa for 2000$ renting one for 50 and putting the rest of your money into some productive financial asset is actually perfectly reasonable.
- tehlike 7y agoThe calculation gets more complicated with appreciating land, and leverage.
- quickthrower2 7y agoAlso if you pay off the mortgage let's say $2k/m then you are $2k/m better off after tax. Otoh if you rent and invest you need to make $2k/m after tax (so maybe $4k/m before tax, depending on where you live etc.) from the investment to be in the same position.
- tehlike 7y agoYes! You can also do 1031 and things like that to defer taxes. And value adds by doing renos.
- onion2k 7y agoTechnically you're right but the reality is that most people who choose to rent things other than a place to live are doing so because they want to use something that's better than what they can afford to buy on credit or outright. It's much more often about living a luxury lifestyle rathe than pragmatic financial sense.
- durnygbur 7y agoAfter 4 years you paid for the sofa 2400$, "rest of your money" is -400$, sofa doesn't belong to you, and in case of scummy renter you own money for damage repairs and cleaning. Ready for legal litigation?
- Barrin92 7y agoThe point of the exercise is to invest the money you didn't pay into something that earns you money. If you put the 1950 bucks you didn't spend into stock, you're making money. And in case of damages and repairs, if you own the sofa, you're always sitting on the damages. Homeowners for example routinely spend thousands of dollars per year on their houses, whereas renters (generally), have repairs covered by the landlord. this is a basic situation of opportunity cost. You can't just tally up the renting costs while ignoring the freed up capital, this is the exact mistake people make when they prematurely buy.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAs a regular middle-class person, how do you put $1950 in stock to make more than $400 in 5 years risk-free and time/effort-free?
- Barrin92 7y agoindex funds, they've averaged about 7-8% over the last 20 years and cost you basically nothing. mind you renting your toothbrush probably isn't worth it, but if you're thinking about spending thousands of dollars and compare that to the compound interest you earn in a passive fund over a few years, you'd be surprised how much you lose out on. In fact that's one of the drivers between middle class and upper class inequality. The upper class invests primarily in capital.
- dagw 7y agocompare that to the compound interest you earn in a passive fund over a few years So I did. Remember you've still got pay the $50/month out of that savings. Even with 7% guaranteed annual interest on your initial investment you're still losing money after month 46 with renting at $50/month compared to paying $2000 up front.
- jbarberu 7y agoIf the company renting out the couch didn't come out on top, they'd just put their money in index funds instead of buying inventory...
- pjc50 7y ago> There's not much upside to owning something that depreciates in value. Sure, so why is the sofa rental company in the business of owning sofas? You've got to ask the question from the other side. You're paying someone else's cost of ownership and interest and overhead and profit margin. In practice what consumer goods rental competes with is consumer credit. People don't sit on the floor for months while they save up the $2000 for the sofa, they buy it on credit. Lots of places offer interest free credit too! e.g. https://www.dfs.co.uk/content/finance https://www.dfs.co.uk/content/finance For most people there is no "rest of the money".
- 0x445442 7y agoUsing your example, renting the sofa only makes sense if you expect to only need a sofa for about 40 months. I say about because if you're super diligent, and most aren't, and put the extra 1500 in some investment you're still only going to stretch out the break even point to something like four years. Most people have sofa's more than four years.