5 ms·
This seems dangerous, like people are going to spend 100% of their paycheck every month and get everything taken away from them if they go a week without a job.
by whatshisface 7y ago
This seems dangerous, like people are going to spend 100% of their paycheck every month and get everything taken away from them if they go a week without a job.
- staticautomatic 7y agoIt's the Rent-A-Center model.
- walrus01 7y agoWelcome to modern serfdom, implemented by app. Your boss is an app, your job is classified as an "independent contractor", you own nothing. You can never get off the treadmill of wage slavery.
- Jgrubb 7y ago16 tons and what do you get? Another day older and deeper in debt. St. Peter don't you call me cause I can't go, I owe my soul to the company store.
- pembrook 7y agoOr on the flipside, I've got some contractor/consulting buddies who regularly pull down $200/hr bouncing between Tech companies in the Bay Area and Seattle and big banks in NYC. Not owning anything allows you to go where the work is and keep your net worth in assets that produce actual income (like index funds and bonds), instead of sitting around collecting unemployment during a dry spell because you're encumbered by your depreciating assets. I'm sure some people will use this as a way to temporarily live beyond their means...but it's not like Credit Cards don't enable this behavior already. The US is the land of the free of course, where we allow the weak to be preyed upon.
- walrus01 7y agoThis is a lot different if you're making $140,000/year gross vs the typical "rent to own" market of Aaron's and Rent-a-center for household furnishings, where the consumers make significantly less than that.
- jackcosgrove 7y agoI agree that many people already lived on a financial knife edge before all these rental services. However the example of a contractor who lives an unencumbered life and saves a lot of money is not at all typical. It's similar to using the example of an investment banking associate or corporate attorney who pay high rent in Manhattan for some years and invest the rest, as an argument against buying a home and having a mortgage. In reality, many/most people are better off with a mortgage because it forces them to save money, which they behaviorally wouldn't be able to do otherwise. Likewise, buying something and keeping it around probably prevents a lot of needless repurchases and upgrades of the same item. If you are rational the rental lifestyle can make sense in some cases. But for most it just facilitates impulsive behavior. Hence the rush to capitalize on it.
- Godel_unicode 7y ago> better off with a mortgage because it forces them to save money I'm going to go ahead and guess you don't have a large peer group who were buying houses in the late-2000s. A mortgage in no way forces you to save money, added to which it has a tendency to decrease savings due to the moral licensing of exactly your train of thought. "I'm already saving with my sweet ARM, I can afford to lease that car!" People who are financially illiterate are going to be bad with money, regardless of the system.
- bitcoinmoney 7y ago400k/year doing what?
- outside1234 7y agoA lot of things. Remember, this doesn't include their health insurance or a 401k and they will also have to pay self employment tax.
- yibg 7y agoThere are lots of stories (and also some info) on engineers working at FAANG making ~$400k a year or up. Granted these are not your typical engineering jobs, but they do exist and in not so insignificant numbers; say it's 1% of engineers (made up number). I am curious though as to the distribution of freelance / contract rates. Is $200 / hour also 1% of engineers? More? Less? Financially for the same person what's actually a better route? For someone that can get $400k a year at google, is that better or worse than the contract route on average?
- literallycancer 7y ago$200/hour definitely isn't the top 1%. On the other hand you could work at FAANG and run a company as a side project, you could use some of your connections there to get interesting contracts.
- joncrane 7y agoI think if you're making $200/hr and "bouncing around," you're not necessarily billin 2050 hours per year.
- m463 7y agoOn the other hand, what about people with lots of credit card debt?
- taneq 7y agoBasically the same thing except instead of renting off the "-as-a-service" crowd they're renting off the bank.
- onion2k 7y agoOne small difference - eventually they pay the bank debt off and own the item. The as-a-service users pay forever.
- taneq 7y agoA lot of people just keep their credit cards maxed, pay the minimum every month, and re-sell things they've bought at a loss.
- onion2k 7y agoSure. Even then though, if they ever decide to stop living that way they can pay off their debt without borrowing more, and keep the stuff they bought. re-sell things they've bought at a loss Only a loss compared to the price at the start. If you account for the utility they got from the item and depreciation it's probably just the current market value.
- jfoster 7y agoIt's actually not that different than before. Clothes wear, smartphones get outdated, people are already used to renting their home & car, etc. There's not many things you only ever buy one of.
- mc32 7y agoI guess, but it makes things even more disposable, more consumerist. More detrimental to the environment.
- arcticbull 7y agoI could make a case for the opposite -- consumers tend to buy something new at the store then throw it out a couple of years later. I can imagine these types of companies buying more durable goods so they can rent them out to multiple people back to back instead. I see it as almost automating the craigslist model.
- mc32 7y agoTime will tell, of course. You might be right... but I’m pessimistic here. Renters and leasees take less good care of the items they let or rent. The clothes will have a faster velocity to the waste dump, etc. manufacturers and purveyors will cater to this increased velocity... People are worried about drinking straws. Imagine all the new plastic items to cater to this new usage pattern...
- ianschenck 7y agoAs someone who just recently stopped being a "landlord"...I very much agree that renters put a magnitude more wear and tear on things. The wear and tear people put on things when they don't own them...and without even being consciously aware of it. I know now that anything rented should maximize durability while minimizing cost. Time will tell which one weighs heavier, but I'm pessimistic also, and guess that minimizing cost is overall cheaper than durability.
- 7y ago
- _bxg1 7y agoWho says they have to spend 100% of their paycheck?
- whatshisface 7y agoThat's kind of like asking "who says they have to get student loans," great advice for any individual but not so great as a prediction for what we'll be reading about in the NYT 20 years from now.
- apatters 7y agoRenting things is a financial tool and it can save you money. The calculation is simple. You estimate the difference between how much something costs and how much you can sell it for once you're done using it. That's your real cost to own it. Compare that number to the cost of renting it for the same time period. If the cost to rent is lower, renting is a better deal. For larger and more involved transactions (especially homes) things get more complex, but that's still the basic arithmetic. Making more things rentable isn't a big problem. The big problem is that many people don't understand this arithmetic so they end up shooting themselves in the foot when you start giving them options. And unfortunately the people who need this knowledge the most are often the least likely to have it. There's a simple solution which is to just teach a great personal finance curriculum in high schools nationwide. (Well, as simple as solving a problem for hundreds of millions of people is going to get.) Of course this being HN we can probably dream up fancier solutions like incentivizing people to take some personal finance training online.
- rebuilder 7y agoIt seems like you'd see the same kinds of problems with this as you would with predatory lending: even if the cost of a loan (or renting in this case) were much higher in even the medium term, if you're poor enough, it still makes sense because the alternative is not having enough money to live on, right now. Loans and renting are IMO potentially the same thing in this context. It seems to me there's a fairly straightforward regulatory solution to this issue: require tighter financial checks, or reduce the protections given lenders in case of default.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIn an efficient market, shouldn't the cost to own and cost to rent be roughly the same? Otherwise, everyone would rush to the clearly cheaper option.
- fromthestart 7y agoNo, because of the time value of money. Money now is worth more than money later. Having all of your toys today vs saving for a couple years to buy a home. [1] has a somewhat explanation but the same conclusion. 1. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/timevalueofmoney.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/timevalueofmoney.asp