15 ms·
The problem with recaptcha alternatives is that they either are insecure or require time and money to continue to be ahead of bots. All of the "interactive sta
by judge2020 7y ago
The problem with recaptcha alternatives is that they either are insecure or require time and money to continue to be ahead of bots.
All of the "interactive stand-alone approaches" from that page can be beaten with run-of-the-mill OCR (other than perhaps the 3d challenge) and with almost any mobile phone speech recognition engine (and, if the attacker has the money, can send it off to Google's cloud speech-to-text).
All of the non-interactive approaches from the page require this constant tuning and upkeep to make sure bots aren't able to sign up/abuse systems. There's also not \that\ secure if your website is targeted and scripts are made specifically to avoid your anti-abuse methods.
- briandear 7y agoSending my data to Google as a condition of using someone else’s site also isn’t secure. Training Google AI also isn’t something I signed up for.
- cameronbrown 7y agoNot saying I like the precedent of Google being inescapable, you're not "signing up" for anything. A web server is 100% in its rights to refuse to send you a page, on their terms.
- briandear 7y agoThat is true. However, if I sign up for a service, for example TransferWise, then later, signing into the account, I get a Google Captcha, now I am engaged in a relationship/data share with Google and if I don’t agree, I lose access to my account. When I signed up, I didn’t have “you must help train Google AI” as a condition of use.
- ghusbands 7y agoNot entirely accurate. The GDPR restricts the terms they can use, for example. And anti-discrimination law probably also applies. These don't really apply to captcha, of course, under current interpretations.
- cameronbrown 7y agoIt's very easy to argue that CAPTCHA is an essential service and therefore not under GDPR. > anti-discrimination law Google-avoiders are not a protected class.
- Dylan16807 7y agoThe blind are. And the audio captcha is roughly useless.
- mdekkers 7y ago> It's very easy to argue that CAPTCHA is an essential service and therefore not under GDPR No it isn't. In fact, out-of-the-box reCaptcha is not GDPR compliant, and using it on your site will open you up to possible liability. See https://complianz.io/google-recaptcha-and-the-gdpr-a-possible-conflict/ https://complianz.io/google-recaptcha-and-the-gdpr-a-possibl... My reCaptcha strategy is to fire off an email to the site owners every time I am subjected to a reCaptcha, asking for all my data under GDPR. Most websites only need a few such requests to quickly start looking for an alternative. Fuck Google and their constant attacks on my rights.
- ysavir 7y agoI believe we agree with you there. OP was just referencing the methodologies people user, often choosing tools like Google Analytics and ReCaptcha that are "free" by virtue of offloading compromises onto the site's users rather than the site itself. I endorse a site's right to forbid me its content if I can't prove I'm human. I won't endorse a site that accomplishes it by asking me to pay the cost.
- savethefuture 7y agoUnless you dont want to access to whatever is behind a sites captcha, you are signing up to solving their ai cv problems.
- AYBABTME 7y agoNot sure why you're downvoted, it's a valid point. It feels icky to use a service that you pay for, and incidentally provide free labor to Google's AI which they resell in Google Cloud as a walled garden. The result of reCaptcha isn't public as far as I can tell, and humanity probably doesn't get a net benefit from Google's monopoly on AI anymore.
- skybrian 7y agoPeople talk about "free labor" and forget all the times they were able to do Google searches or use Google Maps for free. It seems rather ungrateful? This isn't a one-sided relationship, both sides benefit.
- AYBABTME 7y agoThe difference lies in whether you willingly subjected yourself to this transaction (give eyeballs, get Maps service) or whether it was imposed on you without anyone bothering to mention or question it beforehand. Also the gratefulness part is strange. The corporation has no gratefulness for me, why should we show it any kind of loyalty. It's not a living entity with a consistent mind or consciousness. It will change its will based on Wall Street's demands. It will ban you silently with no recourse.
- skybrian 7y agoPerhaps "ungrateful" is the wrong word. But in a purely transactional society where we charge each other for every little thing we do on the Internet to avoid any "free labor", I suspect that we would be considerably worse off.
- MikeGale 7y agoLogical error here. Some people avoid Google Search, Chrome etc. They are still subject to this.
- ionised 7y agoThis is simple corporate sycophancy.
- anticensor 7y agoYou seem to be a bot. Write a poem describing the outage and email it at larry@google.com . We will look at it and unblock you if we believe you are a human.
- behringer 7y agoThat's why I always answer the captcha's wrong. the machine!
- 0-_-0 7y agoIt's the only way to stop Skynet!
- dessant 7y agoHobby sites may be in a more difficult position, but businesses may decide between developer convenience and low cost, or excluding some of their users and tormenting them. There are also ways to reduce the damage reCAPTCHA causes, such as keeping it out of the default UX path. Discord for example will show a reCAPTCHA challenge on the login page only if you are signing in from a new location. reCAPTCHA cannot effectively defend sites against targeted attacks either.
- lordgrenville 7y agoOK, Discord specifically is terrible. I login in incognito mode from the same location/browser every time, and have to deal with Captcha most of the time.
- Spivak 7y agoI mean do you want Discord to fingerprint your browser so you don't have to deal with captchas? Kind of defeats the purpose of incognito doesn't it?
- Dylan16807 7y ago> Kind of defeats the purpose of incognito doesn't it? They're going to track my IP whether I want them to or not. So they should go ahead and use it to reduce hassle.
- Arbalest 7y agoI use Discord from an incognito Chrome window. I avoid it most of the time, by doing: 1. Email is manually typed, password is copy pasted 2. I move the mouse around in the window in a fairly non-mechanical manner. I don't know if you use Chrome proper for it, so that could still be a point of difference.
- __david__ 7y ago> …only if you are signing in from a new location. Or you clean your cookies out, thank you "Cookie Autodelete".
- pmontra 7y agoI implemented simple question / answer antibot filters on registration forms for a few sites. Nobosy ever made the effort to customize their bot to answer to those very few questions. I guess it doesn't make sense economically. However if a big site would go that way, it would be filled with bots in a day.
- dmix 7y agoThis is probably good enough for 90% of websites that accept user content. Then in the small chance it isn't because of growth or some random spammer decided to spend some time on your site, then you can switch to something like recaptcha.
- progval 7y agoI did that for on an old forum that has been dead for year, I thought spammers would not care enough. But one of them did! Whenever I changed the questions, bots would stop for a few days, and then start again. Someone cared enough to manually enter the correct responses (no, blind dictionary attacks were not possible)!
- rodw 7y agoFor small scale sites you don't even need to do much that requires human intervention. Most bots (or at least most bot-actions) seem to invest very little in sophisticated techniques and rely instead on finding vulnerable servers by casting a very wide net. As long as that is true, you can filter out 99+% of the noise by applying very simple but slightly bespoke techniques. As long as there continue to be enough cookie-cutter blog/forum/ecommerce sites out there for the bots to exploit, very simple techniques (JS-populated form fields or request parameters, very basic validation of the HTTP headers, taking into account the rate or frequency at which requests are made, etc.) will quickly and cheaply identify almost all of the bot activity. Of course sophisticated or dedicated bots will still pose a problem, but assuming you're not just standing up a popular off-the-shelf platform without any hardening or customization, you'll need get pretty big (or otherwise valuable) before attracting that kind of attention. A reasonable analogy here is the observation that simply running sensitive services on non-standard ports (e.g., not running SSH on port 22) will eliminate a ridiculous volume of malware probes against your system. To be clear, that's no substitute for actual robust security practices -- you almost certainly shouldn't have something like SSH world-visible to begin with -- but given how trivially easy it is do something like to change the default port for services you're not expecting the public at large to reach it's absurd that servers are compromised by dumb scripts blinding probing the Internet to exploit well-known and long-ago-patched exploits every day.
- benologist 7y agoThe problem with CAPTCHA and the like are they seek to stop programmatic-browsing of websites, that both Firefox and Chrome support out of the box. If companies are concerned about non-human access they should make an official API instead of their website being a de-facto unofficial API. If they are concerned about fraud they will be woefully defended by CAPTCHA, it makes no judgement on the validity of transactions at all and doesn't prevent frauds signing in manually. Ironically, Google has committed at least $75 million and likely hundreds more of fraud, via stolen refunds and stolen banned-account balances! https://www.businessinsider.com/google-emails-adtrader-lawsuit-refund-ad-click-fraud-2019-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/google-emails-adtrader-lawsu... https://www.searchenginejournal.com/adsense-lawsuit/248135/ https://www.searchenginejournal.com/adsense-lawsuit/248135/
- themacguffinman 7y ago> If companies are concerned about non-human access they should make an official API instead of their website being a de-facto unofficial API This is often impractical for several important use cases, like image rendering and PDF generation. Just hand waving away the cost of developing dedicated, pure APIs won't make companies more likely to do so. > If they are concerned about fraud they will be woefully defended by CAPTCHA, it makes no judgement on the validity of transactions at all and doesn't prevent frauds signing in manually. There are many different vectors of attack and fraud and CAPTCHA tackles one of them. It's silly to say it's unnecessary just because it doesn't cover all fraudulent activity
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- capsha 7y agoYeah, but then again, so many times that I run into Captcha issues, it's on a site that really doesn't need Captcha to begin with. Why make me solve a Captcha to see static content? Why make me solve a Captcha to log in when I've already completed one to register? Why make me solve a Captcha to pay utility bills? Is there some underground group of deviants going around surreptitiously paying other people's utility bills? The monsters.
- DownGoat 7y ago> Why make me solve a Captcha to see static content? Fair point, I usually run into this when using Tor, or VPN when accessing content behind Cloudflare, and or similar services. This is some anti abuse stuff, but is often overly agressive with giving you captchas. > Why make me solve a Captcha to log in when I've already completed one to register? So attackers cannot password spray. This is typically after attackers has gotten access to the latest database breach, and are just blindly trying username/password combinations. > Why make me solve a Captcha to pay utility bills? Is there some underground group of deviants going around surreptitiously paying other people's utility bills? Sound like a strange place to have a captcha indeed. What information is needed in the form to submit it? Does it validate stuff that an attacker might want to scrape? I guess they added it for a reason.
- Elv13 7y ago> Sound like a strange place to have a captcha indeed. What information is needed in the form to submit it? Does it validate stuff that an attacker might want to scrape? I guess they added it for a reason. In the past, I used curl to get some billing info, add the money to a dedicated virtual prepaid card, then pay the bill, then send an email to a gmail (+paidinvoice) label. These day, at least for my bills, they have pre-approved withdraw directly from the bank. However I guess this is not widely deployed. If other people did this, but ended up doing it from an insecure machine and lost the credentials / got hacked, I can see why at least some orgs might want to prevent people from doing this. This is a classic over reaction, but a plausible scenario.
- 7y ago
- mitchty 7y ago> The problem with recaptcha alternatives is that they either are insecure or require time and money to continue to be ahead of bots. Sure great, but when I see behavior like the above, I just hit back and add the site to my routers firewall black list. If its this much of a PITA to "solve" a captcha, CORRECTLY but I keep getting the middle finger I don't give a crap anymore. Your site isn't worth going to if I have to spend literally minutes "solving" captchas for googles stupid ai which is treating me like prove i'm a bot even when I prove i'm not. Just realize by using recaptcha this is what you're forcing some users to deal with. And I deal with it by making sure I never come back to your site ever again when you've wasted minutes of my time just to try to get to your page. Even if its googles fault for being jerks, I don't care. You choose to implement it. Ok rant mode off and stepping off my personal soap box.
- reaperducer 7y agoYour site isn't worth going to if I have to spend literally minutes "solving" captchas for googles stupid ai which is treating me like prove i'm a bot even when I prove i'm not. I've run into state and local tax agencies, utility companies, and large healthcare companies that require Google's reCAPTCHA. So, unless you don't want healthcare, to have water service at your home, or you're in the mood to just shut down your business, you have to suck it up.
- modzu 7y agoi say the same thing to my friend in a wheelchair -- "suck it up handycapper and pull yourself up the stairs". there was a time not long ago before wheelchair ramps or accessible doors were commonplace. these people were literally shut out of society. its the same with captcha forcing privacy-conscious users off the internet.
- drusepth 7y agoUh, using a wheelchair vs walking is a lot less of a personal choice than using Firefox vs Chrome. Or: people who need a wheelchair are protected by anti-discriminatory laws, while people who prefer not to use Google products aren't.
- zrm 7y agoHow hard would it be to create an alternative using GPT-2 or the like? Create a dozen models based on different things. Street signs, cats, houses, cars, etc. Then show the user a random selection of images generated from different models and say "select all the cats" and they get it right if they choose the images generated from the cat model.
- matt-attack 7y agoTo understand the depth and complexity of Captcha2 I highly recommend this: https://www.quora.com/Why-cant-bots-check-“I-am-not-a-robot”-checkboxes https://www.quora.com/Why-cant-bots-check-“I-am-not-a-robot”... Was posted on HN a while ago.
- zrm 7y agoSo the short version is that they try to fingerprint the user and then distinguish fingerprints that seem like humans from fingerprints that don't. The interesting question then becomes how this is going to interact with future browser anti-fingerprinting measures whose purpose is to prevent just that.
- modzu 7y agowrong. captcha blocks bots and humans alike. so why bother with the fake puzzle at all? just replace whatever triggers your captcha with a straight up block. or else please consider a responsible alternative.
- judge2020 7y agoReCaptcha blocks (or deters) an extraordinarily larger percentage of bots than it does to humans by far.
- modzu 7y agoof course it does. so does an automatic ban. that's precisely not the issue. i think you probably meant to say recaptcha allows an extraordinarily large number of humans compared to false positives? because that would be the relevant metric. you sure about that one?
- Semaphor 7y ago> and with almost any mobile phone speech recognition engine My only problem with recaptcha is when audio doesn't work (google decides I'm spamming their network… sure…). Because their audio validation seems to use only one rule that says "letters where typed". So I'm not sure how being able to beat it with voice recognition makes it worse.
- achingtooth 7y agoI don't doubt that it's far easier to abuse traditional captcha systems, but I wonder how wide spread that is. A while ago I did a test with securimage and tensorflow/python/opencv/keras after I read a Medium post. While it could solve captchas with a little distortion when I added squiggles, dots, and more distortion it was unable to solve the captchas. I'm sure you could spend more time and create a system that can solve these captchas, I wonder how much effort some random spammer will put in to attack your blog. Yandex uses traditional captchas, and they don't seem to have any issues.
- mcv 7y ago> The problem with recaptcha alternatives is that they either are insecure or require time and money to continue to be ahead of bots. You're posting this in response to an automated recaptcha solver. Clearly recaptcha also has trouble staying ahead of bots. It seems to me that any simple automated test at the entrance is inevitably going to be easy to solve by bots, especially when it's a one-size-fits-all test like recaptcha, so bots have only a single target to aim at. A small-scale unique test will be more successful simply for that reason. But it seems to me that the better way than to ban bots together with humans who fail to pass your Turing test, is to check for the behaviour you want. If you don't want spam, have a system to recognise spamming behaviour, rather than traffic lights.