7 ms·
> It doesn't matter how much money Google is going to have to pay in the future as a fine for this practice. The amount of money that they will get for kicking
by izacus 7y ago
> It doesn't matter how much money Google is going to have to pay in the future as a fine for this practice. The amount of money that they will get for kicking out the competition is going to be way higher. That is a learned lesson from Microsoft (and probably others before them).
The competition in this case is Apples iOS, for which even HackerNews users love to harp over and over and over again how amazing it is and how little battery it uses because it doesn't allow apps to use anything but APNS, run anything in background or even include GPL source code.
This is what's Android competing against - an completely locked down operating system which cannot deliver any kind of GPL code. And every time it allows more freedom to developers it's punished in the market by losing against iOS and mocked on this very website about how it allowes their app developers to drain battery and access data.
What exactly do you expect Google to do here?
- gubbrora 7y agoAn ideal platform would use a foss compatible framework. It would allow the user to configure which server to use to push notifications(one server for all apps, since that is needed for battery reasons). Notifications would be encrypted with the apps key.
- jayd16 7y ago>allow the user to configure This may be an ideal solution for you but its really not for most people.
- jimktrains2 7y agoThat something is configurable doesn't negate the ability to have sane defaults that most people won't touch.
- joshuamorton 7y agoOften times even having configuration options creates surface for security issues. A good example of this is that there were scams that involved having people paste some script into their chrome devtools and steal data. This worked fairly effectively. Facebook ended up doing some magic to show a warning message in the devtools console to tell people that no, you really shouldn't paste random stuff here, it will do bad things. Configurability does come with a cost. And "the ability to reroute all push notifications through an arbitrary MITM" is a security cost that I expect wouldn't be worth it.
- throwaway2048 7y agoI very much doubt that Google is making the GCM push code proprietary for these reasons.
- izacus 7y agoNo the truth tends to be more banal - making everything replacable in configurable means more (paid) engineering work for Google engineers for what's, essentially, building infrastructure for competition. What would be the compelling business case for Google to do more work to enable removal of their own product?
- gubbrora 7y agoHence why I said encrypted. The impulse to protect people from themselves is a dangerous one. In the article itself we see that in practice it is used to push inescapable spyware. "But our spyware is better than their spyware!" Google says they will protect you. But the truth is they are just concern trolling to shut down marginally worse competitors. For kids and elderly that can't make decisions on their own it could be default -locked to some entity contractually bound to good ior. Locked with an administrator password. That would be a reasonable compromise.
- izacus 7y agoGoogle actually released Capillary, which makes E2E encrypted FCM messages easier to implement: https://security.googleblog.com/2018/06/end-to-end-encryption-for-push.html https://security.googleblog.com/2018/06/end-to-end-encryptio... But yeah, if you want to avoid Google's servers, then it's not enough. But in that case, you're probably on Google-free LineageOS anyway right?
- SkyBelow 7y agoIs the solution to begin, to a degree, treating adults as children?
- gretch 7y ago
- lern_too_spel 7y agoThis is possible to build on Android right now and something I've thought about myself. There is nothing stopping you or me from implementing it, and I've always thought that Amazon should have done it to make it easier to port applications into their ecosystem.
- soulofmischief 7y agoI don't think you're focusing on the entire picture. Some people here like iOS for the reasons you described. However I'm willing to bet, unless you can show me otherwise, that it's a vocal minority. I don't know of anyone personally who is happy that Apple disallows GPL code. Comparing Apple's digital Fort Knox with Google's unsupervised free-for-all is a false dichotomy. There exists a happy medium, where power users get all the freedom they want but apps are still by default beholden to certain restrictions. And this is orthogonal to a proprietary API.
- maxaf 7y agoPlease forgive me for being unnecessarily obtuse this early on a Monday morning. Where does Apple say that GPL code isn’t allowed on the App Store? I ask entirely out of my selfish need to avoid unpleasant surprises later on.
- izacus 7y agoApple doesn't say it directly, but the way how they deliver apps to devices incompatible with GPL licensing terms. See for example https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/6109/is-it-possible-to-have-gpl-software-in-the-mac-app-store https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/6109/is-it-possibl... .
- ljackman 7y agoApple has been slowly phasing out GPLed software from their own software, such as Catalina's migration from Bash to Z Shell, but even writing third party apps with the GPL has apparently been problematic in the past: https://thenextweb.com/apps/2013/07/18/vlc-for-ios-will-return-to-the-app-store-on-july-19-full-re-write-open-source-licensed-under-mplv2-and-gplv2/ https://thenextweb.com/apps/2013/07/18/vlc-for-ios-will-retu...
- soulofmischief 7y agoIt's what I've heard rehashed around HN, but afaik the actual policy is more or less as described here: https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/18922 https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/18922 Essentially it works like it should anywhere else: If you don't publish source code and someone complains, you're out. In an ideal world Google Play would hold itself to the same standards. However, the App Store does impart restrictions which are incompatible with GPL, so it's not so much that Apple doesn't allow it as it is that GPL doesn't allow it. Apple has no official statement on this of course, but we know how they feel about GPL code given that they've removed every bit of it from their OS over the last few years.
- kortilla 7y agoHave you considered those two groups aren’t the same?
- ViViDboarder 7y agoI would like a choice between consistent and curated vs open and free with both respecting privacy. Unfortunately, the choices today are limited.
- roboys 7y agoGood thing Huawei is cut off, we might get some much needed options that are not tied to Google Play Services.
- Despegar 7y agoThe difference is Apple has been the same from the beginning. There was no bait and switch. People who bought Apple products knew what Apple was and will be and what the terms were. With Google there is a bait and switch (and it doesn't really just apply to this particular story). They came to market defining themselves as the open alternative to Apple to get market share and developer interest (and evangelism), and now that they've achieved dominance the terms are changing. There's no surprise that there's going to be massive pushback (and probably antitrust implications).
- pkaye 7y agoApple has the majority market share in the US. I think they need to be forced to open up for alternative app stores.
- bjelkeman-again 7y agoThis data says that Android is bigger. https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held-by-smartphone-platforms-in-the-united-states/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held...
- behnamoh 7y agoExactly. We see the same pattern with Chrome and the new course it's taking. The reverse is also true: whatever sufficiently good product that doesn't generate money is basically doomed by them no matter how many users depend on it. (Reader, Inbox, Talk, ...)
- jasonvorhe 7y agoWho exactly is buying Android phones based on the premise of openness vs "they're cheaper", "it was a subsidized new phone from my carrier"?
- officeplant 7y agoPersonally I've always bought Android (and while it lasted Firefox OS) phones because of the option to easily tinker with the phones. If/When pure linux phones make a come back I'll be moving on to them. Of course nerds being nerds is an outlier.
- HillaryBriss 7y ago> What exactly do you expect Google to do here? Let app developers and users have a choice.
- izacus 7y agoThat was exactly the state of the Android until 6.x or so and I've had multiple frustrating hours of mentoring Android developers on how to do notifications respectfully just to be ignored with "eh, I'll poll every 10 minutes, it's easy and it works!". And this has been my experience constantly: - "Eh, I'll just demand full storage access for my game, it's easier to unpack files in root of sd card" - "Eh, I'll just constantly reconnect HTTP no matter what the current device state is" - "Eh, I'll just download 600mb on mobile, it's easier than checking" There are some developers that did right by users, but enough Android devs are constantly ignoring the best practices of development and users privacy because it's "easier" and requires less code. Because of that I fully understand Google's new stance: developers haven't proven themselves trustworthy and it seems Apple's way is the only way to defend users against abuse.
- AstralStorm 7y agoDefending users by actively lying about battery usage is not acceptable. Battery meter in 8 was accurate and flagged battery eating apps accordingly. This new thing is actively lying when you don't use Firebase, as if nobody can ever correctly implement push notifications.
- izacus 7y agoI'm not sure what you're talking about exactly? What's the "new thing" in your post? (Btw, the on-device battery meter is horribly inaccurate and always has been. Multiple values, like screen power use, are hardcoded by OEM and tracking app power use is not reliable in any case because those graphs are incapable of measuring cascading power efficienty effects coming from using the radio or Play Services. Use Battery Historian if you want more useful battery use debugging.)
- bad_user 7y agoI use an iPhone currently but I'm wishing for an Android instead, precisely because Android allows some Free Software apps that have no equivalent for iPhone. But yes, I agree, Android's competition is iOS and that's freaking sad.
- xwvvvvwx 7y agoTwo things: 1. According to the reddit post the firebase library makes no difference to battery life 2. It is perfectly possible to provide strong guarantees around battery usage and resource consumption with open source code