4 ms·
Articles like his do a great job of communicating change, but a very poor job of communicating threat. I'm going to be unpopular and say I still can't see why t
by roenxi 7y ago
Articles like his do a great job of communicating change, but a very poor job of communicating threat. I'm going to be unpopular and say I still can't see why the metrics being listed here rate higher consideration than all the threats that could reasonably be imagined over the next 40 years. The risk of running out of fossil fuels without being prepared is much more threatening than the statistics listed.
I'm going to single out "Sea levels are rising." for special mention - entire cities can be constructed in 40 years (I'm thinking Shenzhen); 9 inches over a century isn't that scary in context of all the other radical change that has happened over the same period. There was a period in there where nuclear annihilation was an imminent threat. Nuclear annihilation is still a concern.
It is obvious the situation is changing, it is not obvious in this article that any of the changes are important over the timeframe given. There is always going to be radical change over a 20 year period that we have to roll with.
- whytaka 7y ago> I'm going to single out "Sea levels are rising." for special mention - entire cities can be constructed in 40 years (I'm thinking Shenzhen); 9 inches over a century isn't that scary in context of all the other radical change that has happened over the same period. The problem isn't the sea-level rising, it's the people that would be displaced, migrate over, and cause havoc to the systems of regions unprepared for such a massive ingress. Consider that there are housing crises around the world today and these cities aren't built for them today.
- api 7y agoLook at the social and political havoc caused by the European refugee crisis in recent years for a concrete example.
- enraged_camel 7y agoYep. Europe can barely deal with a few million refugees from Middle East. Just wait until they start getting tens of million, if not more, from the Indian subcontinent and surrounding coastal countries.
- abathur 7y agoThis. And the possibility space is daunting. And many of the changes can unfold drastically faster than sea level rise. Consider things like: The difference in the number destabilizing European politics, compared to the numbers at risk of displacement via sea level rise. The potential for people to be displaced by shifting weather patterns. How many years of draught, wildfire, dust-storms, crop failure, 500-year floods, weeks-long power outages, etc. will it take to permanently displace people? Will the die-roll throw these effects at low-productivity, low-population areas, or will some hit breadbaskets, transportation nexuses, industrial centers, or cities? Or will the people bearing the brunt of these effects stubbornly stay put, and disrupt internal politics by repeatedly rebuilding with taxpayer assistance?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoEasy to focus on "how can people escape the change". Not so easy, for coral reefs that take 100 years to regrow, and the fisheries that utterly depend on them in a food chain. And the billions worldwide that eat those fish. We're all safe here in the West, but billions may die worldwide. Unless the refugees overrun us all. Like they did in the 'ring of fire' years, back when Ur and Hammurabi were writing. A chain reaction of failed crops, refugee migrations and overloaded ecosystems culminated in Egypt being nearly destroyed by the 'sea people', a flotilla of desperate refugees. It only ended when Egypt armed everybody and defeated them (killed them all).
- roenxi 7y ago1/7 of the world population wiped out by a 9 inch change in water levels over 100 years? Seems a little unlikely. My point today is there isn't anything in the article that supports your comment. Nothing in that article is a risk to billions of people. Look at what is happening with Swine Flu in Asia right now - there is always a risk of a given food source collapsing; climate change or no climate change. I get that this is interesting, I don't get how we can link a 0.04 change in pH to requiring action to avert the apocalypse. The 'drastic toll' they are presenting isn't very expensive. This article is a call to inaction rather than action.
- madaxe_again 7y agoInteresting choice of example, given that the African swine fever epidemic, which is also occurring in Europe, is in part being driven by climate change, as it has changed the ranges of the vectors - wild boar and warthogs.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoTo inform: Reefs are on sloping continental shelves. Reefs grow at exactly a depth, temperature and clarity of water. Change the water depth an inch, the optimal location moves by feet or yards. Reefs are not ambulatory. Reefs take decades to regrow.
- theothermkn 7y ago> I'm going to be unpopular and say I still can't see why the metrics being listed here rate higher consideration than all the threats that could reasonably be imagined over the next 40 years. The risk of running out of fossil fuels without being prepared is much more threatening than the statistics listed. While it's unfortunate that you can't see the danger, it's comforting that that view is increasingly "unpopular." Let's take the "risk of running out of fossil fuels without being prepared" as an example. Absolute tripe. A fiction bordering on incoherence. First of all, there is no "risk" of the scenario you have described, in the sense that the probability of "running out without being prepared" are indistinguishable from 0. Fossil fuel prices will climb. Transportation and energy prices will climb to the point that some forms of transport and some uses of energy will either become unaffordable or change to the second-best option (relative to now). This is already happening with hybrid and electric vehicles and wind and solar energy. It will just continue. We won't "run out" in the sense that we've mined the last lump of coal or pumped the last drop of oil. Rather, the costs of extraction will climb until it's no longer feasible to extract. This takes time, and one of the mechanisms that drives that time scale is cost. On this matter, we can breathe a sigh of relief. On the other hand, the collapse of the ecosystem, or it's (or large parts of it's) sudden transition into a new dynamic regime, is not at all unlikely on the face of it. Mussel shells are an example of a large change due to ocean acidification over the last 50 years: https://news.uchicago.edu/story/mussel-shells-much-thinner-50-years-ago https://news.uchicago.edu/story/mussel-shells-much-thinner-5... . Whole sardine fisheries have collapsed. (It'll be interesting to see if the increase in microplastics will build to a threshold that leads to a sudden die-off of plankton-feeding whales. It's not difficult to imagine a system with that much lag building to an irrevocable state.) The bread basket of the United States is a happy coincidence of wind-blown silt from the Rockies and weather. That good weather is moving north into Canada. These all represent signals from gigantic systems that are careening out of whack. Here, we can only cross our fingers. And hold our breath. "Running out of fossil fuels" is not the problem. The problem is quitting them before we destroy the systems that keep us alive.