4 ms·
I would rather not desire KFC or Powerade, I may be in the minority here, but I am extremely skeptical of suggestions regarding the ability of ads to truly com
by mindcrime 7y ago
I would rather not desire KFC or Powerade,
I may be in the minority here, but I am extremely skeptical of suggestions regarding the ability of ads to truly compel one to desire something they really don't want.
Anecdotally speaking, I've seen hundreds or thousands of commercials for Budweiser, Coors, Miller, and the like. And I watch a lot of football at sports bars, where I have plenty of opportunities to drink that stuff. Heck, they even have hot girls in skimpy outfits come in to the bar and give away random freebies, run silly contests, blah, blah, etc., to advertise those brands. And yet, while I am a (light) drinker, I have never felt any desire whatsoever to drink Coors, Budweiser, Miller, etc. When I do drink, it's almost always either a Sam Adams product, or a microbrew / craft beer.
Yeah, n=1 and all that, but if advertising were as powerful as some people make it out to be, surely I'd be drinking at least a little Coors or Miller by now.
- maxdamantus 7y agoSo .. are you saying those companies are wasting their money by producing advertisements? Maybe you should inform them that they could be saving money by not putting effort into producing those ads.
- mindcrime 7y agoThey may very well be. It's a pretty well known issue in the field that it is very hard for firms to definitively attribute any specific revenue increase to their promotion efforts. It may be that all the ads are doing is reinforcing preexisting biases, and not inducing any new demand.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoThe impact of Edward Bernays' work seems to indicate marketing can change biases.
- mindcrime 7y agoMaybe so, but that's still pretty far from where this line of discussion started, which (as I interpreted it anyway) was the idea that ads can compel you to desire something that you really don't want to desire. I'm not saying ads are totally wholesome and good, and made of puppies and sunshine and rainbows or anything, mind you. I'm just skeptical of the degree of power that some people seem to attribute to advertising. To hear some people talk ads are just short of "Manchurian Candidate" level brain-washing.
- maxdamantus 7y agoEven if it is just a case of "reinforcing preexisting biases" (I don't think it is), I think it should be highly questionable when companies are spending money/time to maintain those biases of the population. It's not like the vast majority of ads encourage some rational thinking about a product. It's just some content that someone is paying you to watch.
- roenxi 7y agoYou have to learn about KFC or powerade for the first time somehow. I, for example, don't think I've ever drunk powerade or gone in to KFC in living memory. I wouldn't even know that the C stands for Chicken except for their extremely effective global advertising. The birth rate in the US is something like 8 persons/minute of which presumably at least one 1 would be very happy to eat KFC and drink powerade. They are a good target for advertising, as well as people who are borderline about where they eat today. There was an xkcd comic that really summed this idea up well. There is population turnover. Just because you know what everyone knows doesn't mean the new entrants to the world do - they have to learn from somewhere. Advertising makes sure it happens. I can vouch that it is working well for me even though I don't eat fried chicken.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- amelius 7y ago> Heck, they even have hot girls in skimpy outfits come in to the bar Can't we ban the use of people in ads? That could be a first step in putting a stop to the mind-hacking, while still allowing informative ads.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoAnd bright colors on bleached paper? So much waste for no benefit to society.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoYou know the names of those brands, and recognize them over $generic_brand, and mention of them immediately brings to mind their marketing pitch (sports, skimpy clad girls, etc). Even if you didn't buy, the advertising worked. You may have built your self-image around beer with the twigs and beaks left in, but others will have a self-image that fits the story and will be vulnerable to being persuaded to buy beer-oid swill.