3 ms·
The Google I use, for search at least says: "the Services are provided by Google Ireland Limited (“Google”), a company incorporated and operating under the law
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
The Google I use, for search at least says:
"the Services are provided by Google Ireland Limited (“Google”), a company incorporated and operating under the laws of Ireland"
to quote the terms of service. Providing any of my data to USA secret service would appear to be espionage, probably treason, and against EU law. I'll bet NSA have access to everything Google know (internally) about me.
The Chinese government probably have all details of my interactions with baidu or Ali Express too.
They look the same to me in this respect, only the Chinese aren't telling my government who they're allowed to do business with.
- gowld 7y agoThe NSA doesn't obey EU law. The NSA's core mission is to violate foreign law in order to collect information.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoGoogle Ireland are supposed to though.
- threeseed 7y agoThis false equivalence is so ridiculous. China is a dictatorship, has no independent judiciary/media, routinely kidnaps Chinese people (not even citizens) in foreign countries, is running the world's 're-education' centre where millions of journalists, Muslims etc are all being detained and is a police state unless anything in history. US maybe stealing your data. But at least you can go to a court or deal with the media to advance your cause without fear of retribution.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThat's why I didn't say what you're claiming, I said the effect on me - neither in the USA nor in China - is equivalent AFAICT. China and USA are both doubtless spying on my country's population and accessing my PII/data as part of that. I'm pretty sure my legal recourse against NSA is identical to that against the Chinese secret services, zilch. Let's be realistic. Trump wants us to stop using Huawei _and_ use USA company produced comms equipment. A consideration of that is then USA can do what they're claiming China is doing. AFAICT you have a legal framework in place to enable just that. What's most incredible to me is that GCHQ haven't endorsed the apparent false claims, which actually gives me some hope about UK (but equally could be meta-games on post-Brexit trade deals; or false flags; or whatever).
- kalleboo 7y ago> Trump wants us to stop using Huawei _and_ use USA company produced comms equipment No US company is producing wireless comms equipment though - it's all European and Chinese
- nostrademons 7y agoLast I checked, Android was largely written by the engineers in buildings 40-43, 1600 Amphitheater Parkway, Mountain View, CA, USA. They're employees of Google, Inc, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Alphabet, Inc, which is a U.S. corporation registered in the State of Delaware. When you access services provided by Google Ireland Limited, you are dealing with a different entity, which last I checked controls a whole lot of money and employs some finance people, customer support, and SREs. Google Ireland is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Google Inc, and contracts with the latter to provide services to Europeans using software owned by Google Inc. Google Ireland follows EU and Irish law. All of this is irrelevant to Huawei, whose contract is with Google Inc to license technology within Android. It is also irrelevant to the U.S. government, who likely gets all the intelligence on Europeans that they need through their Five Eyes partnership with GCHQ, and is far more concerned about potential Chinese, Russian, or Middle Eastern adversaries than they are about Europeans anyway.