4 ms·
It'd be just perfect for Toyota, then, once they give up on Hydrogen, The Fuel Of The Future.
by taneq 7y ago
It'd be just perfect for Toyota, then, once they give up on Hydrogen, The Fuel Of The Future.
- jarym 7y agoI was going to say this - Toyota gave up on batteries after building the Prius. Their hydrogen fuel cell is clearly not the way the industry is going. So are they going back to batteries, the tech they said would never be commercially viable?
- solarkraft 7y agoIf they don't want to die completely, they should probably build BEVs. This seems to be a sign of them slowly realising that.
- melkiaur 7y agoWait. I thought their hydrogen cars were hybrid cars, just like the prius. Why do you say they gave up on batteries ?
- glogla 7y agoKinda. H2EV don't "burn" the hydrogen, because fuel cells are much better than engines that burn stuff in cylinders. So you end up with electormotor and fuel cell. And since you can recuperate into fuel cell and fuel cells aren't very good at providing big short peaks of power, it makes sense to add a battery to smooth things out and to store energy when braking. But the battery doesn't need high-capacity, because it's just a temporary store of energy. It's a very different battery technology than what you find in a Tesla or Kia e-Niro or whatever. In the end, Toyota H2EV (Mirai) is basically 1) electromotor from Lexus hybrid 2) battery from Prius 3) Fuel cell.
- clouddrover 7y agoToyota will do both battery and fuel cell electric vehicles. Hyundai is also doing that: https://www.electrive.com/2019/06/05/hyundai-to-sell-their-fc-drives-to-competitors/ https://www.electrive.com/2019/06/05/hyundai-to-sell-their-f... And Volkswagen is keeping fuel cell cars open as an option: https://www.audi.com/en/experience-audi/models-and-technology/concept-cars/audi-h-tron-quattro.html https://www.audi.com/en/experience-audi/models-and-technolog...
- glogla 7y agoThere's a lot of synergy in doing both. Battery EV is high-capacity battery + engine + thermal management system for the battery. Hydrogen EV is fuel cell + low-capacity battery (for smoothing out peaks and recuperation) + engine + thermal management system for the fuel cells. BEV have low price per km (here it's about 1/4 compared to gas cars), but lower range, while H2EV have higher price per km (in Germany where there's actually infrastructure available, its about the same price per km as gas car) but higher range, so it can make sense for some use-cases, like long-range buses or whatever. You could even build Plug-in Hydrogen EV with medium capacity battery and have BEV-like usage where you charge at home but still get 1000 km range if necessary - it seems needlessly complex, but it just means adding bigger battery and charging port to H2EV, so it can make sense.
- clouddrover 7y agoAnother potential advantage of fuel cell cars is a lower purchase price. Toyota thinks FCEVs might become cheaper to buy than even ICE cars: https://www.thedrive.com/tech/26050/exclusive-toyota-hydrogen-boss-explains-how-fuel-cells-can-achieve-corolla-costs https://www.thedrive.com/tech/26050/exclusive-toyota-hydroge...
- glogla 7y agoIt might be in the future. Here (EU) and now (2019), they cost as much as BEV, while fuel costs as much as fuel for ICE, giving you the worst of both worlds.
- adev_ 7y ago> It'd be just perfect for Toyota, then, once they give up on Hydrogen, The Fuel Of The Future. Before getting back to Hydrogen when the world realize there is not enough Cobalt and Lithium on Earth for every car.
- taneq 7y agoCobalt is an engineering problem and on its way to being solved: https://cleantechnica.com/2018/06/17/teslas-cobalt-usage-to-drop-from-3-today-to-0-elon-commits/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/06/17/teslas-cobalt-usage-to-... We're not going to run out of lithium any time soon, current supplies are limited only by the fact that it's only been desirable for a few years. There's a LOT of lithium mining capacity coming online now or in the near future. Hydrogen was a dead end in 2000 and it's only getting deader.
- adev_ 7y ago> Hydrogen was a dead end in 2000 and it's only getting deader Easy sentence with no content. Dead on which aspect ? In Elon Musk propaganda speech ? Hydrogen never was a dead end technically. It's only blocker is cost of generation, cost that goes away with scale and cheaper electricity.
- whitezombie 7y agoAnd the massively expensive catalyst materials. And their pathetic power output. And the fact that despite Hindenburg memes, compressed hydrogen is extremely dangerous. Go look up Thunderfoots video about compressed hydrogen and HFC cars. And before you have a musk fanboy seizure, please note that thunder foot hates Elon musk more than anyone else on YouTube. And also take note of the fact that calling someone a fanboy is not an argument and it doesn’t make you right. Hydrogen cars already require a battery. Inevitably, the battery will get bigger and the fuel cell will get smaller and what do you know, it’s a BEV with a hydrogen range extender just like everyone told you.
- adev_ 7y ago