17 ms·
Seriously, let’s spend billions in renewable investment and government lobbying to fix the climate crisis. Wow, this is getting silly. Broadband internet is jus
by bamboozled 7y ago
Seriously, let’s spend billions in renewable investment and government lobbying to fix the climate crisis. Wow, this is getting silly. Broadband internet is just not a fundamental human need, a habitable planet is.
- dragosmocrii 7y agoSadly, I think there's no incentive for doing well for the planet to get business value. Maybe when we'll run out of clean drinking water, or land, or clean air, then traditional businesses will invest in R&D and come up with ideas and products to sell you to alleviate the pain.. that's the the goal of a business. what we need is more philantropists. Jeff Bezos is not a philanthropist. Bill Gates on the other hand - more likely..
- staunch 7y agoThe goal of a business is approximately whatever the founders decide to make it. The view that there is something inherently exploitative about all corporations is just naive. Tesla is selling billions worth of cars while doing good for the planet. They have also triggered a technological revolution that will do more than any government or the UN could ever do with regulations. If Bezos successfully ushers in an era where toxic industrial work is moved to space that could do more for the planet than almost anything imaginable. And that is his goal with Blue Origin. These are the good actors. The bad actors are the Koch Brothers, coal plants, Walmart, the old car companies, etc.
- walrus01 7y agoBringing several Mbps internet to the farthest most unreachable corners of the earth, economically enough for low income people to use, is a net social good. you would understand if you had ever worked in geostationary satellite based internet access and seen how costly it is.
- bamboozled 7y agoI'm not disagreeing with that, but let's talk about priorities. If you're living in some of the farthest most unreachable corners of the earth, you;re life is probably more and more in-danger from the threats of climate change through drought, fires etc. Yet another plan to launch thousands of satellites into orbit so it's easier to order more junk from Amazon is a low priority for those people I'm afraid.
- walrus01 7y agoHaving worked in developing nation telecom - you might be surprised. Look at the % of people with HSPA+ or LTE data on their $60-80 (in local currency equivalent) Android phones in the eight largest cities in Afghanistan. Look at the growth of developing-nation specialist mobile phone carriers such as south africa's MTN expanding into rural areas of underdeveloped African countries. It's not like the satellites are going to serve a walled garden Amazon internet, or that their main purpose will be to go to amazon.com and buy products. I'd be very surprised if the service didn't resemble a normal ISP in terms of default route out to the Internet for a full routing table.
- jcims 7y agoCommodity residential broadband makes telecommuting possible. Reducing the influence of population density on capacity benefits folks like me that try to telecommute from rural areas.
- bamboozled 7y agoI'd be really surprised if the most polluting countries in the world don't have access to broadband?
- vatueil 7y agoIt doesn't do any good to pick an unrelated endeavor and say the resources would be better spent on a worthier cause instead. Private spending on space, or public funding of arts and culture, or humanitarian aid, etc. is not blocking us from tackling global warming. If anything, such tangential criticisms are a distraction. Advocate for measures that would help, such as a carbon price and dividend, instead of attacking other causes and making unnecessary enemies.
- mrpopo 7y ago> If anything, such tangential criticisms are a distraction. Advocate for measures that would help, such as putting a carbon price and dividend, instead of attacking other causes and making unnecessary enemies. Amazon is allegedly the biggest company in the world, and is still not publishing open carbon emissions data[1]. Is Amazon here an "unnecessary" enemy? [1] https://www.seattletimes.com/business/amazon/amazon-reluctant-to-share-carbon-emissions-data/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/amazon/amazon-reluctan...
- vatueil 7y agoThat has nothing to do with plans for satellites. Especially not space or broadband in general, as the original comment decried. Feel free to criticize other matters, but don't lump in separate projects.
- bamboozled 7y agoIt doesn't do any good to pick an unrelated endeavor and say the resources would be better spent on a worthier cause instead. In theory that all sounds fine, however; Wouldn't you say it's time to set some priorities? “It’s multiple billions of dollars of capex. Amazon is a large enough company now that we need to be doing things that, if they work, can actually move the needle." Sure, advocating and not criticizing sounds good; Although, what madness and what a waste of time and money. It sounds like all we can hope for is Amazon introduces a self-imposed carbon tax.