4 ms·
> "How we got here: The Fed's quantitative easing program pushed the cost of borrowing money to next to nothing for nearly a decade, allowing companies to
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
> "How we got here:
The Fed's quantitative easing program pushed the cost of borrowing money to next to nothing for nearly a decade, allowing companies to splurge on debt for mergers and acquisitions and to boost revenue."
Put another way, the Fed made the rich richer, and the lack of significant "trickle down" has created a socio-political Charlie Foxtrot; of which the Fed is not accountable for.
- cstrat 7y agoI can't see how the continued erosion of the middle-class is not going to have huge impacts on the livelihood of everyone else.
- dev_dull 7y agoPrecisely why I’m a big fan of tariffs and America-first foreign policy. We need a way to restore manufacturing industry to the US, the loss of which played a large role in the erosion of the middle class. Protecting manufacturing and factory jobs used to be a selling point for Democrats but things have been a little turned upside down lately.
- komali2 7y agoIf only tariffs caused manufacturing facilities to return to the USA. They don't, though. Here's a great map of the net negative effects tariffs have on the state of your choosing: https://www.uschamber.com/tariffs https://www.uschamber.com/tariffs
- dev_dull 7y agoI realize that tariffs are controversial given the current political climate, but they really are one of the best ways to claw back money from large corporations and reward unskilled labor in the US. We need to bring manufacturing jobs back to the US. The loss of those jobs disproportionately affected minorities. Increases in corporate tax is easily avoided by domicile changes. Tariffs are a simple way to restore balance. Build it here. Hire here. No tariffs.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoPerhaps. But also keep in mind that in bringing back that manufacturing we'll be bringing back the ecological issues (read: pollution) as well. There's always an unintended consequence or two.
- komali2 7y agoDo you have evidence to support your claim? I ask because in my experience this is one of those "sure, makes sense" situations (like "just build a wall!") that, when actually taken in the context of real world economics, doesn't work.
- howard941 7y agoThere's something wrong with the data at that URL - the data, not the web site which is really attractive and responsive. The first two states checked out were funky. That there are $659M of wireless phone exports from Calif to China doesn't pass the smell test. It's an incredible claim requiring incredible proof but there's nothing there despite the state being colored in as suffering Extremely Significant Damage. Another state, Florida, gets off more easily and only suffers Very Significant Damage. Drilling down it turns out the goods being tariffed aren't good at all: The tariffed items are literally scrap gold jewelry and scrap metals. California's stealthy cellphone export I'm pretty sure don't exist. I'd argue that Florida's scrap exports are resources better kept in country as feedstock to help spur on-shore manufacturing. I'm going out on a limb and expect the remaining 48 states are showing tariffs on bulk minerals, ag products, trash, and make-believe products. Tariffs on these items are positives insofar as they keep input costs low for domestic producers.
- joshgel 7y agoThis is just incorrect. A 25% tariff doesn't correct for the difference in labor costs between China and the USA, because the difference in labor costs is > 25%. It just makes stuff more expensive for Americans.
- dev_dull 7y agoI don’t think that’s true, besides, couldn’t the same argument be said about raising the corporate income tax? Yet many people are in favor of that. Tarrifs directly benefit American workers and factories, who find their prices 20% more competitive.
- internet_user 7y agoIt is more difficult to evade tariffs or VAT on imports, sure. For that to even out the playing field, it would have to be refunded to average Americans, and I am not sure it can even happen given the fiscal structure in the US? Maybe a patchwork of all sorts of federal programs, better Medicare here, some more govt jobs there, etc? A direct refund would probably work much better.
- brewdad 7y agoFix the Health Care mess and we'll call it even.
- internet_user 7y agoIt already has? We are living it right now.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoAgreed. The future __is__ already here. It's just unevenly distributed, literally.
- Spooky23 7y agoThere was a thread earlier today where people on a site catering to tech people were commenting on how they cannot afford to have children. When people are rejecting reproduction and family to play video games and go on vacation, that’s an impact.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI don't want to get off-topic but the birth rate is an unspoken reason why we have 12+ million "undocumented workers". Immigration is proxy for population growth, which in turn is an easy way to "grow" the economy. Obviously, propping up the economy in that way has helped to spark socio-political issues. Long to short, the Fed is "against" the middle class and immigrants are taking the brunt of the blame for it. FYI - It was my comment this sub-tread is from.
- Spooky23 7y agoThat's a great point, thanks for making it. Personally, I grew up in a rural area in NY that is basically being systematically wiped away, because of these policy decisions made in a vacuum that few people understand. People blame "the other" and get caught up in racist nonsense. Meanwhile, we're reverting into ancient latifundia and turning into a society where basic human needs aren't being met.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoAnother FYI - In Europe (e.g., Germany and France) a similar thing has happened. The difference there is a noticeable percentage of the immigrants are Muslim (and are generally less inclinced to assimilate). I remember reading a couple of years ago that soon enough (read: 25 to 50 years?) - if current trends continue - Muslims will be the majority in Germany. So while Germ's economy has fared well as of late, it might be sitting on a cultural powder-keg if the economy stagnates. As for Japan's economic stagnation of the last couple decades? Relatively low immigration.
- dev_dull 7y agoIt’s trickled down but in narrow bands. For example, starting salaries in the Bay Area are up big in the last decade, partly because of an influx of easy money into tech growth tech companies. However, much of that goes directly into the pockets of land owners. Ultimately the winners in QE are those that own the finite resources.
- siculars 7y agoYa, and? Isn't that always the case - the owners of finite resources profit. Is there some other way it would be?
- piva00 7y agoHaving more owners of finite resources instead of helping them to concentrate it through mergers and acquisitions could be a way.
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> " the owners of finite resources profit" That's not the issue. The issue is the Fed tilted the game in the favor those already winning the game. And as a friendly reminder, no one elected the Fed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 7y agoI thought ZIRP was the culprit, with QE being a response to the 2008 crashes that stacked up on it.
- internet_user 7y agoand QE is just kicking the can down the road a little further. We are the new Japan.
- hkmurakami 7y agoFrankly every (developed) country is the new Japan when you look at debt loads and demographic ratio trends. They’re the canary in the coal mine for all of us.
- HillaryBriss 7y agoin some ways, yes, but one difference is that our population is not shrinking. another is that our debt to GDP ratio is something like 90-100%, but Japan's is more like 200%. yet another is that we don't have the sort of nationalized healthcare system Japan has. also, Japan's been playing the "managed trade" game for decades now and they know how to do it well, whereas the US has been practicing a consumer driven economy better characterized by "free trade." in order to really become like Japan, we'd have to enlarge our federal level trade negotiation bureaucracy and become more mercantilistic, improve literacy rates and secondary school quality, and become more racially and culturally and linguistically homogeneous, as well as implement extremely strong gun control laws and lower the murder rate. we'd also need to increase government job-creation spending on infrastructure to the point where we're building bridges to nowhere all over the place, plenty of underutilized airports, etc and create even tighter restrictions on immigration than we have now (yeah, I know Japan is liberalizing immigration, but not very much).
- internet_user 7y agoDebt/GDP ratio doubled in 20 years, and the bulk of that change in the in 10 years or so. It won't take much longer to get to 200%, we are going to see it. I'm not sure what you are trying to say in the last two paragraphs? That we are somehow so fundamentally different, that the fiscal picture is not comparable?
- theturtletalks 7y agoThe Fed is against raising the minimum wage because it will make inflation increase above the allowed 2% per year. Which kind of makes sense because paying workers more will make things more expensive especially service businesses. But, they should still raise the minimum since most service businesses are heading for automation and the bump will help workers have a better job transition.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWouldn't it just make the automation viable more quickly?
- theturtletalks 7y agoI feel like companies are already racing for it. Just look at how fast outsourcing has taken place across SMBs and public companies.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThey do it when the cost of automation is less than the cost of labor. In some areas that has already happened, sure. But what's the result when you cause it to happen more?
- CryptoPunk 7y agoIt could boost per worker automation, but there will be fewer workers, and less economic output to reinvest into capital (which is essentially automation), so there will be less automation in general. So higher automation per worker but lower automation per capita.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoCapital isn't "essentially automation" in general. It includes a lot of other things like land and art and government bonds. If you have a job which can be automated at a cost equivalent to a $10/hour wage, it doesn't get automated when the wage is $9 and does when it's $11. The money doesn't inherently come at the cost of some other automation, it may (and if the other automation is profitable, more likely does) come from selling some bonds or other assets you own, or by borrowing it from a bank which just creates the new money from nothing as banks do. You're also ignoring a number of other effects like the higher demand for automation allowing fixed costs to be spread over more units and lowering the purchase price of the automation equipment. A lot of these things are actually good -- if people sell real estate to buy automation equipment then housing prices come down. If four people get replaced by four machines and one person to look after them, the person who knows how to look after the machines may get paid more than any of them would have before the automation. But the other three are still out of a job, and are then in a wasteful competitive signaling game with all the other newly unemployed to overpay for degrees and credentials because none of them are allowed to compete by accepting lower compensation anymore.
- guelo 7y agoThe article also mentions globalization and Trump's tax cuts.
- Maarten88 7y agoThe "trickle down" story keeps coming up, but it's untrue. It simply doesn't work that way. If someone who is already rich gets even more, it won't be spent in a way that is good for someone poor. More likely, the excess money will be invested in a way that provides yield, like buying real estate, driving up prices and rent. Or merging businesses to lower competition and costs. Leading to money streming 'up' instead of trickling down. The trickle down story is a hoax that needs to die.
- jlawson 7y agoIt 'keeps coming up' because it's a strawman people love to punch. People literally only bring up this concept in order to tear it down - because it was only created in order to be torn down. Nobody actually argues for 'trickle-down' policies. It's a sneer term signifying a deliberately oversimplified version of right-wing economic policies. It's not a real position people hold and push for. I guess it's a lot easier and more fun to feel righteous attacking strawmen than it is to do the work of interacting with real ideas with serious intellectual backing and real influence.
- imtringued 7y agoCorporations and rich people fight for lower taxes all the time. Usually the argument is that if the taxes are too high they will just move to a different country.