5 ms·
When Clinton granted China MFN status and then was allowed into WTO there were some (perhaps naive) assumptions of working in good faith and that while it was e
by mc32 7y ago
When Clinton granted China MFN status and then was allowed into WTO there were some (perhaps naive) assumptions of working in good faith and that while it was expected China would be granted some breaks as it caught up, eventually it would play nice abide by the rules everyone else respects. Well, it’s been 30 years and China is still not playing fair in trade (ownership requirements, IP transfer, IP theft, market access, etc.)
The admin is doing something the Busch admin should have done, or at least the first Obama, but neither did because it would be too upsetting to multinationals and would also “upset” China.
Now we have someone who says times up, do what you signed up for or deal with the consequences of ignoring the rule set out.
And, to a great degree, I agree with this. Blue collar labor was thrown under the bus. That little Texan was right. A giant sucking sound did take the jobs, but not Mexico but rather China chiefly, among other labor outsourcing, to our detriment (their own too) and environmental degradation.
Now, I’m glad and it’s great China took this opportunity to lift its people from abject poverty but we took too much of a hit. It should have been more measured and more fair.
- nikofeyn 7y agobut my guess is that the period of china stealing ip (which is an obvious fact that has happened over decades) is only temporary in the grand scheme of things in that it won't last forever. this is because china has stolen ideas, concepts, and direct designs to catch up but is now in many areas surpassing product design in the u.s. so this idea that u.s. design and development > chinese design and development won't last and is already breaking down. thus, the u.s. is in real danger since china has all the manufacturing ability. so yea, china has stolen and ignored ip laws, but that soon won't even matter. that's at least my prediction. i have a friend in a u.s. technology company, and they simply cannot beat the chinese version of their product in both price and features despite being the creator of the product category decades ahead of others. the chinese companies copied the design but have now exceeded it, so the u.s. product does very poorly in china. so what it sounds like to me is that the u.s. sees the writing on the wall, which is all due to their own actions and corporate greed over the past few decades, and so now is making a hail mary in a trade war. it doesn't seem like a good idea when it likely won't be long until china has the upper hand. so it seems it basically comes down to trump taking his poor understanding of dynamics and abusing the u.s. government's and people's need for a "war".
- mc32 7y ago(Almost) Any country can be a leader in some area even if they are not a superpower. Germany, Japan, UK, France, Taiwan: they all have leadership in some technologies even though they are small compared to the US and China. Should they throw their hand up and say, guys and gals of the world, we can’t keep up with you in all areas, please, come take our IP! I think the answer is obvious.
- nikofeyn 7y agoi am not for sure i understand. i was saying that it seems to me that the u.s. can't always rely on the argument and stance that "oh, it's just china making cheap copies". it seems that china has directly stolen and continues to do so, which is a major problem of course, but they will eventually have no need to. so the problem is worse than just needing to stop china from stealing. the problem is that it's possible the u.s. will be left behind because of our unconcentrated effort versus the chinese's highly concentrated economic approach. my simple understanding is that u.s. corporation's greed and other u.s. economic factors caused a move of nearly all manufacturing to china and now everyone's saying "hey, wait a minute".
- mc32 7y agoI see. But still, even if they are a leader in most areas, they will not be leaders in every area. If they play fair, then we can learn and cooperate. The answer to our losing leadership to them isn’t to capitulate and continue allowing undeterred advantage, it’s, as you imply, to on-shore some of those lost skills. It’s not impossible, but it takes concerted effort by government, industry and citizens (who care about environmental impact, working conditions, fellow citizens).
- filesystem 7y agoI may misunderstand what you mean. Are you saying that you believe China will stop producing inferior (made as cheap as possible) copies of desirable goods and marking the price up? Why would they stop? They have already proven that they have no interest in acting in good faith, and in the absence of morals, this practice is obviously much more profitable than innovation. China now has all the capital & knowledge required to become the worldwide leader in innovation. However, their entire industrial culture was built to the specifications of "making cheap copies". It will be interesting to see what the side effects of those origins will be for China in the long run.
- chrischen 7y agoThere’s a big misconception about manufacturing jobs. Yes, China did take them, but only by outbidding our efforts at automation and robotics. There is no way America has the headcount nor efficiency (no American would work to live at the level of a Chinese factory worker) to match the human labor costs of China. Therefore if labor does move back to the US we’d just invest heavily in automation to compensate. Those jobs were long gone, and they’re either going to be done by a cheap robot or cheap person in a developing country.
- mc32 7y agoChina is automating as well. I bet they’re not thinking “well, why bother trying to be the destination for offshoring, we’re gonna automate it anyway”. No, they understand strategic technologies, economic positioning, trade deficits, keeping people employed, etc. Also, on-shoring and automation would make our workers more productive and thus be compensated better and reverse the decline in real earnings since the 80s.
- chrischen 7y agoWorkers will be more productive, which is why there will be fewer of them.
- bobthepanda 7y agoMore productive blue-collar work is good though, because it results in two things: - a path to higher earnings for those without college-level education, slowing if not eliminating the hollowing out of a lot of traditional "middle class" jobs - said workers will also result in additional money flowing through the economy. Lower earning workers spend more of their income on goods and services as opposed to savings, boosting the economy. It's why Ford paid his workers enough to be able to afford his cars, a crazy idea at the time; a healthy middle class is one that can spend money on further things. The increasing economic inequality in America has mostly resulted in lower-earning workers using credit to try and replace middle-class earning power, and we saw how well that turned out the last recession.
- 1PlayerOne 7y agoSo unilaterally imposing tariffs on China, Mexico, Canada, and possibly EU, instead of using the WTO or working with America's allies (TPP), is a best way of making China play fair?
- mc32 7y agoIs it the best? I don’t know. I don’t agree with how some of it has been done, but I agree something hadn’t been addressed which needed addressing years ago. W/re WTO they are already as is violating it, so how do you suppose “more WTO” will make it work?
- briandear 7y agoDidn’t Canada, the EU and Mexico have tariffs on US products before Trump? Importing clothing, computers and similar goods into Mexico has always faced stiff taxes. Milk into Canada, heavily taxed. American cars and motorcycles in Europe, also taxed. The idea that Trump invented protectionist tariffs is ridiculous. Korea also has had significant tariffs and their cousin, quotas. Try to import rice into Korea, it’s heavily taxed, American beef as well. It’s almost impossible to buy an American car in Korea as well. The pots are meeting the kettle and the kettle is willing to be a lot more black than it used to be.
- kombucha11 7y agoSo the best way to win is with similar protectionist policies? That seems silly.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoFrom a different point of view, almost everyone has made a lot of money on the current relationship, Chinese and Americans, so why mess up a good thing? Even with the ownership requirements, IP transfer, market access, and IP theft that occurs, this has still been incredibly profitable for American companies and multi-nationals, so there wasn't much pressure to bring an axe down on China. The same goes with Mexico and pretty much every other trade partner. However, some people didn't win out, and in fact lost out significantly because of all this globalization: American blue collar workers. These people became disgruntled, elected a rightist populist nationalist to the presidency, and now they want change. In reality, it wasn't just China doing them in, but China (and Mexico and immigrants) make great scapegoats for those rightists, ATM.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> why mess up a good thing? It's unsustainable. Trump's broader trade policy is protectionist. But the reason his China policy finds firmer footing than e.g. his Mexico tariffs come from China's abuse of several good-faith measures over the past 30 years (e.g. early accession to the WTO). It was plausible to assume the next leader would be another Deng. But when Xi ensconced himself as a "leader for life" [1], the timing calculus changed. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-43361276 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-43361276
- seanmcdirmid 7y ago> It's unsustainable. How so? It wasn't fake money being passed around, there was real production and real demand for trade with China. > But when Xi ensconced himself as a "leader for life" [1], the timing calculus changed. Xi is messed up for a lot of reasons, but this isn't really one of them.
- siffland 7y agoPut it back in context: It's unsustainable. Trump's broader trade policy is protectionist. The US has become overly reliant on China, add on their Belt and Road Initiative, and we should be taking a more aggressive stance. Trade wont last forever with us and we will not have any industrial infrastructure left. this is trying to protect ourselves. I find it funny half the US wants higher minimum wages and better standards of living here, but complain when prices go up for cheap stuff from China being made by near slave labor in oppressed conditions. I guess out of sight, out of mind.
- agent00f 7y agoThe occasion political content here that's often just fox news level "we're the good guys" talking points makes me question the objectivity of the rest of the tech content.
- jdietrich 7y agoThat explanation simply doesn't tally with the facts. Trump isn't singling out China - he's also imposing substantial tariffs on Canada, Mexico and the EU. Have they been flouting the laws of international trade? A far more straightforward explanation is that Trump's trade policy is a) protectionist and b) a means of imposing regressive tax increases by stealth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_tariffs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_tariffs