14 ms·
If you want a loud computer that consumes ten times as much electricity as it should, then an old Xean Workstation might be for you. Personally I prefer buying
by adrianN 7y ago
If you want a loud computer that consumes ten times as much electricity as it should, then an old Xean Workstation might be for you. Personally I prefer buying old Thinkpads. They're cheap, fast enough, and their electricity consumption is decent.
- ldargin 7y agoSome of those computers can heat a room though...
- cm2187 7y agoYou feel it in big, packed open spaces when they cut the a/c the week end. It may be freezing outside but the floors become really hot.
- dagw 7y agoI can't talk about power consumption, but I have a couple of old HP z420 and the loudest component in them was the old Quadro cards. Swap that out and the system is very quite.
- tecleandor 7y agoQuite quiet ;) :P
- lrem 7y agoIn my experience Xeon workstations are no more noisy than personal computers. That's including my current Lenovo with can't-even-remember-how-many cores and just shy of 200GB RAM. I never felt a need to measure how much my employer pays for electricity.
- thrower123 7y agoI have a Xeon ThinkServer sitting here on my desk as I type this. It is considerably quieter than the laptop I sometimes use, under typical usage (Slack, VS Code, a couple other Electron apps, Outlook).
- mongol 7y agoI have an old Dell Xeon workstation, it is not loud at all.
- bluedino 7y agoThe older ones definitely make noise from the fans when running at full tilt. The Precision 3630 on my desk will even make a bit of noise, it only has an i7-8700
- phaedrus 7y agoI built a dual-CPU E5- based workstation with 64 GB of DDR4, and kill-a-watt says it draws only 75W at idle.
- adrianN 7y agoA Macbook Pro lasts ten hours on a 80 Watthour Battery
- DuskStar 7y agoNot if you're running Docker it doesn't.
- adrianN 7y agoIf you actually run stuff the Dual Xeon system won't be sitting at 75W either.
- ggg2 7y ago> 10h disable lid sleep (well, disable sleep entirely on osx 10+ because apple don't want to give you the option to disable lid sleep only) and it will never pass 4h. the 6/8/10h some people claim is because they don't realize the computer is sleeping most of the time. I guess it is fine if it's just your facebook terminal...
- behringer 7y agoMy dual cpu z600 running 12 cores (24 with HT) is virtually silent. The GPU is the loudest part and hardly audible. I keep it in my living room.
- yegle 7y agoI'm actually using the HP Z420 (the one mentioned in the article) at work. Pretty quiet IMO. Note the Z420 is a workstation not a server. Buying an old server is completely different.
- noisy_boy 7y agoCoincidentally I'm considering buying a used Thinkpad X220 for fun projects for me/kids because of the reliability, build quality and the awesome keyboard. The best quote I have received so far is about $145 for i5/8gb ram/no-drive (I already have a spare ssd). Hoping the machine is in a good condition :)
- vuln 7y agoGo for it. You will not regret it... I still have mine powered on and sits on my desk with an external plugged in. I suggest doing the FullHD mode if you're decent with a soldering iron. Here is a great resource for x220s. Enjoy! http://x220.mcdonnelltech.com/resources/ http://x220.mcdonnelltech.com/resources/
- noisy_boy 7y agoI have never touched a soldering iron and quite wary of h/w tinkering - thanks for the link though. Even if I don't know how to work with h/w, I like to read about other people doing it.
- panpanna 7y agoGo for it, but you may need to change battery and the thermal paste
- noisy_boy 7y agoThats my fear too - not only the battery but even the thermal paste part. I have never tinkered with h/w and have a bit of phobia of breaking things. I'll probably end up paying someone to do it :(
- hotcrossbunny 7y agoIf you do go for it look out for one with an original battery that may well fall into the battery recall that Lenovo has been running for years. A "dead" battery to the seller may represent a free replacement from Lenovo without any cycles it's clock.
- iscrewyou 7y agoWhat’s a good place to look for an old reliable thinkpad? Do you find them on Craigslist or eBay? I’d love to get an old one and stick an ssd in there for basic usage.
- bdcravens 7y agoI bought an i5 t460 (2-3 years old) for 300 on eBay. The keyboard was kinda nasty so I bought a replacement for 30 on Amazon.
- owenmarshall 7y agoI googled “used laptops” and found a company that resells off-lease computers. If you’re in a large(ish) city I’d expect you’d be able to find a similar company. I was able to pick up a x240 in great shape for $125, and test drive it in person before I paid.
- bluedino 7y agoDon't forget on most of the W-series you can stick 4 DIMMs in to get 32GB of memory.
- jotm 7y agoYeah, no shit, a laptop uses less power. Look at ZBook, Precision workstations for the best performance for your dollar.
- fmajid 7y agoHP Z workstations are actually fairly quiet. It's one of the few computer lines that actually has published acoustic decibel ratings (19 dB for the low-end version, 34 dB for the high-end, see https://www.bluechipit.com.au/media/product_spec/Z420_WORKSTATION_1.pdf https://www.bluechipit.com.au/media/product_spec/Z420_WORKST...). My main objection to the Z4xx series is that the cases are so bulky. I prefer the Z2xx small form factor models, or even better the Z2 (fastest computer I own, but also one of the smallest). One of the big advantages of a Xeon is that it will use ECC memory, and thus be more reliable.
- ratling 7y agoOld Xeons have a niche use as perfect freenas hosts (it's cheap to get 8g+ ECC memory) as long as you're smart enough to shut them off when you aren't using them. I really want to get on the Thinkpad meme. I really do, I like my t500 I use for docker stuff. The problem is there are a lot of newer models that either have dogshit touchpads, dogshit screens, dogshit wifi cards, or (in the case of edges) all 3. Yeah you can replace a bunch of parts (except for the wifi which is bios locked) but at that point I'd be better off buying an Acer Aspire E15 or something else remotely modern. (Yes I know you can flash the bios to get around the bios lock. I also don't care. I shouldn't have to do this.)