3 ms·
Yes, I think mirror+specific alternatives... In fact, the simplest would be "mirror + backtrack". If a given site had an earlier dns entry, the alternative dn
by joe_the_user 16y ago
Yes, I think mirror+specific alternatives...
In fact, the simplest would be "mirror + backtrack".
If a given site had an earlier dns entry, the alternative dns would point to that earlier entry as the second alternative. If you think the second alternative is "really it", you can make that permanent for you.
It wouldn't solve everything but it would make a variety seizure approach not work well in the short term.
You'd still have trouble if you lost your ip address(es) but this would mean seizure would need multiple points of failure.
Moreover, this would need only a minimum of centralization.
A browser plugin to "find hidden/seized sites" might actually be trivial to produce. Name it something catchy. Anyone would to work on this?
- Groxx 16y agoBut what that means is that the internet goes from being a www.com => globally-identifiable site to everyone having their own version. Links, URIs, Universal Resource Identifiers are no longer universal, and can't be used to reliably direct people around. It could be mitigated by changing the scheme (say: http://version/www.com/ http://version/www.com/), but then every address-reading system on the planet has to be changed to handle it without throwing validation fits. The average person will not understand this and will simply use whatever comes through automatically. If it doesn't lead them where they expected, they simply turn back. Leaving us back where we started. Heck, you can already do this: you have a hosts file. Just map www.seized.com to the original IP. As long as the servers are running, it'll still work. The problem comes when traffic drops to zero, ad revenue drops to zero, and the reason for the site's existence is lost. Which is precisely the same problem with running alternatives; the average person, who accounts for most of most site's traffic, will take whatever is served to them and not manage it on their own. Any system like this would eventually bloat to unmanageable levels, as again, ownership transfers look the same as seizures (or the reverse can be made to be true, with the intent to trick people). Eventually, loads of sites would have tons of alternatives. People could nab the servers / IP addresses of the old ones, and run phishing sites that look like the originals, further degrading the use of any alternative addresses... ... so people will use what's already decided for them. Which is what we have now. The fraction of a fraction of 1% of people who will visit the alternatives will not prevent their eventual death. Only the most popular seized pages will have any chance of continuing to exist... at which point their servers are simply seized along with their domains (where possible. governments cooperating in this is only increasing, and if the ACTA goes through it'll likely become the standard, done automatically, instead of the exception). --- All of this also relies completely on the internet backbone routers not being manipulated. All it would take is a re-write rule, and any attempts to reach the address are taken out entirely. If a distributed DNS gains traction, do you honestly think this won't become a government's weapon of choice? Those routers exist somewhere.
- joe_the_user 16y agoHmm, "But what that means is that the Internet goes from being a www.com => globally-identifiable site to everyone having their own version. Links, URIs, Universal Resource Identifiers are no longer universal, and can't be used to reliably direct people around." Yeah, it suck the state is breaking the Internet. I don't like it. We should be clear. We shouldn't claim consider this to be an improvement. We should consider this a counter-measure to something like an act of war on the Internet, which it is. "The average person will not understand this and will simply use whatever comes through automatically. If it doesn't lead them where they expected, they simply turn back. Leaving us back where we started." The average user is smarter and smarter. This is something like a war. Normally fat, dumb and happy humans can often sudden exhibit more intelligence in this kind of situation. Only the most popular seized pages will have any chance of continuing to exist... The state cares most about these sites too. The state doesn't like actions which dilute it's power. Even when they don't really work, they also make it look bad, which should not be underestimated. Basically, this an electronic form of civil disobedience. And I believe things have come to the point that this might matter.
- Groxx 16y ago>The average user is smarter and smarter. And relying on more and more complicated tools that run more and more automatically. For example: it seems to me that one of the major reasons password managers (and thus better passwords) are gaining ground is because they're better in every way - you don't need to remember anything. It makes things easier and more automatic, so people use it. My basic theory on humanity is that people aren't stupid, we're just lazy. And I mean that in a good way; laziness often leads to efficiency. Especially when taken to a global scale, things change when they become easier, not necessarily better. I don't think we'll agree here though, so I won't debate that point further. >We should consider this a counter-measure to something like an act of war on the Internet, which it is. Sadly, yeah, it does seem to legitimately be under attack. From all sides. Something along these lines might work to make a parallel internet, which could be useful, but I don't see it as a solution, so something still needs to be done, and the sooner the better. Why not now?