5 ms·
So we should be thinking about this as a crazy overreach by Customs/ICE rather than a crazy overreach of Homeland Security?
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
So we should be thinking about this as a crazy overreach by Customs/ICE rather than a crazy overreach of Homeland Security?
- tptacek 16y agoYou could, but this has been part of ICE's charter for a long time. I'm only making the point that this isn't some crazy RIAA subversion of the Department of Homeland Security. Homeland Security sounds scary, like, "the US Government thinks the RIAA's IP claims are vital to national security!". No, they don't.
- grandalf 16y agoSo you're saying that you think it would be perfectly reasonable if the FDA or agriculture department happened to be tasked with enforcing music piracy prevention ? Joking aside, I guess this is part of the problem with naming departments cutesy Orwellian names like "Homeland Security".
- tptacek 16y agoI think it's not an indication that the government thinks the RIAA's problems are homeland security concerns, and would prefer not to be baited into discussing anything else I think about it.
- grandalf 16y agoFair enough, though I look forward to the day when there is just one governmental department and it's called the "Vanquishers of Evil" for the sake of clarity.
- alexqgb 16y agoEvildoers, if you want to be precise.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWho, ... on this deep thread, ... that you started, ... ever claimed this?
- tptacek 16y ago... Nobody!
- joe_the_user 16y agoSo you started this conversation with yourself because... ???
- Robin_Message 16y agoHe provided a useful piece of background on the thread. I was about to post a comment about "oh look, they overreached with the too-wide anti-terror laws and are using them on music pirate, quelle surprise," so it is useful to know that, except in name and org chart, this has nothing to do with homeland security (and any of the laws associated with the war on terror.)
- amadiver 16y agoWhile no one ever claimed it, tptacek was correct in assuming people were thinking it. Or, at least, a person was thinking it. I'm really glad to see a possible explanation for why Homeland Security would be cracking down on music blogs. While I don't agree with the DoHSs actions, I now have a foothold in understanding the situation. It may or may not be correct, but as a fairly logical interpretation of the scenario, it'll suffice. I'm disappointed to see your fairly dramatic response (though I like the elipses and poetic linebreaks :) ) and 'yummyfajitas's pat response earn collectively more upvotes for delivering far less information (no offense).
- joe_the_user 16y agoTo me, jurisdictional questions around the particular authority claimed by ICE to censor the web are interesting only in relation to the larger political decision to censor the web. Tptacek focuses on only the first question and righteously refuses to look at the latter question. He "prefer not to be baited into discussing" the substantial question here. What I consider an important and disturbing development: the US government effectively taking up the authority to censor websites sans any conviction of web master for anything (sure they "file a lawsuit" but they do NOT have to actually convict or even serve the webmaster in question. It's the effective negation of free speech whatever the ostensible argument). I thus think the various responses are appropriate. I've disagreed with Yummy on plenty of other issues but he decodes the misdirection in the GP well here.
- kragen 16y agoI don't think prior restraint of domestic publication has been part of ICE's charter for a long time.
- mcantelon 16y agoICE's charter was to stop music piracy?
- uxp 16y agoThe C in ICE is Customs, which has been charged with stopping counterfeit goods produced abroad from entering the USA, such as knockoff Rolex watches and Prada Handbags. Counterfeit goods have been charged with "reducing the desire" to own original goods, much like pirated music has been charged with reducing the desire to actually buy the CD. If anything, ICE is probably the only department that administratively is capable of combatting piracy, since they have been doing it for so long under their own banner. They now get to do it under the Homeland Security banner.