7 ms·
And one more database removes itself from the Open Source community, and disqualifies itself as a dependency of other open projects.
by JoshTriplett 7y ago
And one more database removes itself from the Open Source community, and disqualifies itself as a dependency of other open projects.
- api 7y agoSo the open source community is about giving free labor to Amazon? I've been an OSS user and contributor since the middle 1990s and I very much welcome these moves. SaaS has been getting a free (in the unfair sense) ride without contributing in any way.
- jasonlotito 7y agoNo, the open source community is not about giving free labor to Amazon. But that's not what we are talking about. We are talking about members of the open source community taking free labor from the community and then pulling back on the open source promise. As someone in the same boat, I'd hate to see a project I contributed to change it's license to something that limits how the applications can be used. If something is licensed as MIT, I expect it to stay MIT. Furthermore, the presumption that users of the software are now required to contribute back flies in the face of the agreement. I'm not against people using a license like this. It does however seems a slap in the face to change the license after benefiting from the fact that you are releasing an open source product. tl;dr: It's a bait and switch, and dislike it.
- JoshTriplett 7y agoIt also pulls the rug out from under other projects depending on them.
- amenod 7y agoNot really. The limit is clearly defined (if you are using it as DB, there is no change). If you allow users to create schemas, then it's a different thing, but I'm guessing there is no such project.
- amenod 7y agoThat is a valid point. Of course the question is, how big the contributions from the random people were. Judging by the list of contributors [0] a relatively small core contributed most, but I wasn't involved at any point so this is not a reliable assessment. [0] https://github.com/cockroachdb/cockroach/graphs/contributors https://github.com/cockroachdb/cockroach/graphs/contributors
- gtirloni 7y agoCode is not the only type of contribution in an open source project.
- toyg 7y ago> But that's not what we are talking about. No, that's exactly what we are talking about. The threat of big cloud players swallowing up the SaaS model that powered opensource to the current highs, is very real. Until Amazon and friends were mostly interested in powering the low-level bits, it wasn't a big deal; but now they are moving up the stack and pulverizing the small businesses that drive the OSS ecosystem. That is a problem. The AGPL was supposed to protect against this sort of play and it really isn't, for various reasons. Personally, I welcome the attempts at innovating in this area particularly when they are clearly well-intentioned like this one. > I'd hate to see a project I contributed to change it's license to something that limits how the applications can be used Unless you've waived your rights, you can exert your copyright and block any such move.
- dymk 7y agoIt's about giving free labor to whoever wants to use it.
- pjmlp 7y agoIt is when they decide to pick up non-copyleft licenses. Should have thought about it beforehand.
- nlh 7y agoHow does this move disqualify CRDB as a dependency of other open source projects?
- JoshTriplett 7y agoThe majority of open source projects need to be usable without installing proprietary dependencies. Whatever you might think of CockroachDB's choice, this means that any other project depending on them makes their users deal with that license too, and while CockroachDB might be willing to push that on their users, that doesn't mean other projects want to follow them down that path and lose their users in the process. Leaving aside any license compatibility issues, an open source project with a proprietary dependency will lose users compared to an open source project with entirely open dependencies. This also causes problems for some Linux distributions.
- bpicolo 7y agoPresumably the open source package in question would just support the Postgres protocol, with cockroach being one option? What else are you envisioning there?
- gavindean90 7y agoAs far as I can tell as part of POC downloads for open projects they always use either MySQL or Postgres if they are going to use a relational database. Cockroach seems to be in a good place here as you can just substitute Postgres for Cockroach.
- geofft 7y agoAmong other reasons, most open source projects expect their dependencies to be things they can interact with like they're open source. It's one of the reasons OSS support for Windows is poorer than support for OSS platforms, despite Windows as a whole being far more popular. This might be close enough, in that developers can install it on their own, you can put it in CI, etc. But it's a barrier.