7 ms·
Astronomy group calls for urgent action on SpaceX Starlink satellites
- carapace 7y agoThe almost-poetic irony of blinding ourselves to the outer world to better navel-gaze our digital nirvana. (To the astronomy-haters on the thread: Y'all realize we can have connectivity and clear skies, right? There's no intrinsic trade-off here.)
- notus 7y agoWhat is more useful, satellites or astronomers being able to view the stars clearly from the planets surface. Genuine question, but it seems to me that in the long run satellites would win out.
- kitd 7y agoWell, in the really long run, a clear view of potential celestial destinations may be paramount :)
- lazyjones 7y agoOrbital telescopes are much better suited for this.
- rtkwe 7y agoThey're also much much more expensive and less flexible. With earth based satellites new experiments with new instrumentation is easy, in space currently we have no way to fix any issues.
- thecount122195 7y agoWe can and have fixed space telescopes before, probably the most famous example is Hubble and its poor sight. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble_Space_Telescope#Flawed_mirror https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble_Space_Telescope#Flawed_...
- rtkwe 7y agoWe did but not any more 1) there's no longer anything like the shuttle available the only thing that could get close would take two launches to stage the parts and another for the crew capsule (not to mention most US capsules would have to evacuate the entire capsule to go outside iirc) and 2) most of the current space based telescopes like James Webb will be much much further out than Hubble was and most that get announced are also planned to orbit much further from Earth.
- kuschku 7y agoSo which space shuttle should we use to fix James Webb if anything would go wrong after the launch? Currently no country has a well-working solution for that, nor does any company (not even SpaceX themselves)
- sp332 7y agoJWST is for researching high-redshift object - the most distant things we can see in the universe. It's not a planet-hunter. And it will be much further away than other satellites, so they would be more easily serviced. (Not that it's easy, I just think you picked a bad example.)
- privong 7y ago> JWST is for researching high-redshift object - the most distant things we can see in the universe. It's not a planet-hunter. JWST is a general purpose observatory. It will make significant advances for high-redshift objects. It will not survey large numbers of star for new planets, but it will be able to observe and characterize planets that have been identified by other missions/observatories.
- mdorazio 7y agoYour comment assumes we still need fleshy meatbags wearing clunky suits in orbit to fix things. This was true 15 years ago, but I'm not convinced it's still true today. A couple of repair drones housed at the ISS combined with repair parts brought up along with normal resupply missions could probably be made to work if it was deemed cost effective.
- Robotbeat 7y ago...with the kind of capabilities that enable megaconstellations (low cost launch, inexpensive space hardware replaced regularly every few years), neither of those things will be true. So either space astronomy becomes much easier/cheaper and we get megaconstellations, or megaconstellations won't happen.
- rtkwe 7y agoOptics put a lot of design constrains on telescopes that mean they'll always be large items, when you're trying to look really far away at really dim objects you just need a lot of surface area to collect as much light as possible and the size of the object you can resolve is directly linked to the size of the aperture of the telescope you're using. Synthetic apertures using interferometry may solve that eventually but we're not there yet it looks like for really high resolution images.
- Robotbeat 7y agoRight, I meant cost in terms of cost per unit dry mass, not just miniaturizing existing satellites. Starlink satellites are really cheap per unit dry mass, not just per satellite. Starship will be super cheap per unit dry mass, enabling ever-larger space telescopes. NASA even tweeted out one concept out for an aperture much larger than JWST using SpaceX's Starship: https://twitter.com/nasagoddard/status/1116310431969239040?lang=en https://twitter.com/nasagoddard/status/1116310431969239040?l...
- rtkwe 7y agoThey might get cheap to launch but they'll be quite expensive to build for the foreseeable future.
- Robotbeat 7y agoI don't see why they need to be. SpaceX has been able to reduce the cost of building space hardware with Starlink by an order of magnitude. When things are cheaper to launch, you can find ways to reduce the cost to build those things.
- Ajedi32 7y agoYeah, but if you're thinking on those timescales you'd probably be better off using orbital telescopes, or telescopes located on other planets or moons with little to no atmosphere. Satellites and the commercialization of space will be important to enabling that level of space-borne infrastructure, so even in the really long run the utility of satellites probably still wins out.
- thekingofh 7y agoBoth
- whatshisface 7y agoWhy not paint the satellites black on the bottom?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jgrahamc 7y agoHeat? They are shining because they are reflecting sunlight. Now paint them black and have them warm up. They then have to dissipate the excess heat in a vacuum...
- Faark 7y agoYou're overly simplifying, but this musk tweet [0] can indeed be read as going somewhat in that direction. [0] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1132908689860415488 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1132908689860415488
- kijin 7y agoI'm not sure which is worse, a shiny satellite that screams where it is (so you can avoid it) or a dark satellite that silently blocks a patch of the sky.
- sigstoat 7y agothe shiny one. because telescopes aren't in the habit of avoiding shiny things; they use the databases of where all of this stuff is and do the math to figure out where it will be. the dark objects at least won't introduce extra photons into the optics to refract around, when they're in your field of view but not obstructing the thing you were actually trying to look at.
- Robotbeat 7y agoBy far the shiny satellite is worse. Besides, the satellites are tracked carefully by multiple parties, so any serious astronomical observation that could even theoretically be sensitive to a sub-millisecond obscuration of a ~microradian portion of the sky (such as certain exoplanet searches) would be well aware of this ahead of time (and atmospheric aberration would be a far greater effect). A dark satellite is effectively irrelevant to optical ground astronomy.
- m0llusk 7y agoTragic, and yet the future of astronomy is clearly with extraterrestrial observation platforms.
- nsilvestri 7y agoWe only really need to send telescopes to space for observing the wavelengths that are otherwise absorbed by the atmosphere. Adaptive optics are almost unbelievably effective at cutting out the interference that the Hubble telescope is practically obsolete (and indeed obsolete, since it will be de-orbited soon).
- garmaine 7y agoHubble is never going to be deorbited...
- privong 7y ago> the Hubble telescope is practically obsolete (and indeed obsolete, since it will be de-orbited soon). This isn't quite accurate. Hubble has ultraviolet capabilities that are impossible to achieve from the ground (due to the atmospheric absorption). JWST won't replace this functionality. Also, while AO can achieve similar or better angular resolution, it can be difficult to characterize the point spread function (PSF) of the AO system. By contrast the PSF of HST is incredibly stable. Knowing the PSF and having it be stable is key for some types of science.
- SkyBelow 7y agoIt is my guess that the majority of those who raise concerns already have communication access, specifically high speed internet access, provided by other means. I would further guess that they are considering the cost to themselves and not the gains to others. Would they be willing to pay the price to provide internet access by other means to those who would be served by these satellites, or are they hoping that those who don't have it will continue to be able to do without?
- kire456 7y agoLet me pose this unfair question back at you. Are you willing to pay the price for providing an alternate means of sky observation at a scale suitable for astronomy, and for cleaning up the debris that might result from expiration of, or collisions between, tens of thousands of commercial satellites? You are implying that launching many commercial (American) satellites is the best, or even a good, solution to the problem of many people not having what you consider adequate internet. Moreover, apparently this problem is so urgent and the solution so perfect that you feel the need to chastise these scientists for even expressing concern. I don't think you are approaching this discussion in a fair manner.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Are you willing to pay the price for providing an alternate means of sky observation at a scale suitable for astronomy, and for cleaning up the debris that might result from expiration of, or collisions between, tens of thousands of commercial satellites? SpaceX is literally spearheading both technologies and business models required to do exactly that, and Starlink is critical to this as a source of funding.
- Ajedi32 7y ago> and for cleaning up the debris that might result from expiration of, or collisions between, tens of thousands of commercial satellites FWIW, at the altitudes Starlink operates at, that completely hypothetical scenario would only take a few years to remedy, and would cost $0 as the debris naturally de-orbits due to atmospheric drag.
- 7y ago
- isostatic 7y agoLast night (1900GMT), I’m sure we saw a Dragon capsule a few degrees ahead of the ISS as it went overhead. That’s with the naked eye. Anyone know what the apparent magnitude of ISS, Dragon, and Star Link would be?
- Robotbeat 7y agoISS is approximately the same magnitude as the entire SpaceX megaconstellation combined. At its peak, ISS is brighter than Venus and brighter than 20,000 Starlink-sized satellites.
- ldoughty 7y agoWould it be a difficult challenge to develop a imaging process that ignores such fast movements of a object? Musk said they would try to avoid impact, making such an software product and releasing it for free would be a great step in that direction. I imagine, also, that good night shots are long exposures or multiple long exposures.
- Robotbeat 7y agoSatellite tracks are already super common and are already algorithmically removed from long exposures (not hard when you're compositing from a stack of images).
- gpm 7y agoThe satellites are hard to spot already, the satellites still haven't been fully risen to their orbits, the solar arrays presumably aren't yet tracking the sun because they need to be oriented to point the engine in the right direction. Any complaints about this constellation seem either late (completely hypothetical and should been raised years ago when approval was sought from the FCC) or early (based on real world data that doesn't yet exist). The article is substantially more sensational than the IAU letter is is based on: https://www.iau.org/news/announcements/detail/ann19035/ https://www.iau.org/news/announcements/detail/ann19035/
- ubertakter 7y ago> The article is substantially more sensational than the IAU letter is is based on The article uses simpler language, but doesn't seem more sensationalist. > The satellites are hard to spot already I'm not exactly an amateur astronomer, but I do get my telescope out every couple of weeks. If I'm out not too long after sunset, I'll typically spot two or three satellites without trying, so I can imagine "real" astronomers are concerned. Tangentially, some times it's fun to track satellites on purpose. Some people use fast tracking mounts to photograph them.
- privong 7y ago> The satellites are hard to spot already, To the naked eye, perhaps. But large telescopes and their instruments are incredibly sensitive. So even if the satellite constellations are minimally visible to the naked eye they can still have a substantial impact on science. Additionally, these satellites are likely to be very bright in the radio portion of the spectrum (due to their uplink/downlink), which could negatively affect radio telescopes.
- Robotbeat 7y agoSatellite track removal is already a well-understood capability that serious telescope projects already do. Satellite radio emissions are well-regulated already, and appropriate measures are in place well before the launch is even approved.
- w8vY7ER 7y agoWhile I share the community's concern for preserving the dark skies wherever possible, is it not premature considering _none_ of the 60 satellites launched have yet to reach their destination altitude?
- gnode 7y agoWhy would this be significant? The separation altitude in the launch was around 450km, according to the numbers in the livestream. The orbital shell being targeted is 550km. This doesn't constitute a large difference in visibility.
- Robotbeat 7y agoDue to the inverse square law, it constitutes half an (astronomical) order of magnitude in visibility. For satellites that are already dim, that's a significant difference. ...especially when combined with proper orientation of the satellites.
- gpm 7y agoSince it likely also affects satellite orientation and possibly configuration. Also since brightness obeys a square law so they should ignoring effects other than distance be 1.5 times their final level still.
- gnode 7y agoA factor of 1.5 doesn't strike me as being enough to suggest the problem will go away (the satellites become too small a part of images to matter). Additionally, the satellites are not two-dimensional, so there is no orientation in which they would not occlude the view. It appears that the objections are not to the size of the satellites (they are relatively small compared to other satellites in LEO), but that they are to be highly numerous. The planned size of the constellation is 11927 satellites. The frequency with which these satellites photobomb astronomical images is the concern, rather than how much area they affect. In fact, their being smaller makes them more of a menace, as they will be more challenging to spot, or easier to confuse with an astronomical entity. This said, I don't think this is a strong argument against putting such satellites in orbit, and progress will and should continue. Astronomers will have to be careful to avoid contamination.
- tntn 7y agoWhy didn't the IAU petition the FCC during the comment period for SpaceX's application? Seems sorta weird to wait for the first launch to express concerns when the application was submitted to the FCC many months ago (and I think I recall an earlier version years ago). (Or if they did, could someone provide the link? I'm not able to find it.)
- trickstra 7y agoThat's like a trade off between 0.000001% chance that the satellite would block some interesting important unique event, against 100% chance of stopping the worldwide satellite internet network and potentially the SpaceX Mars funding I'm calling for urgent action on astronomy groups.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 7y agoSo, realistically, it's going to mean that ground-based telescopes become less productive. Some won't be affected much at all (narrow FoV), while others may have to fundamentally shift how they operate (wide FoV). More exposures will need to be made to overwrite any satellites that pass through the field. This is already done due to existing satellites, so it's simply a question of rates. The radio astronomy issue is potentially more significant, but then I don't understand why these issues weren't raised when the spectrum was being allocated.
- gpm 7y agoThis only doubles the number of satellites iirc, I doubt it will mean many have to fundamentally shift how they operate.
- trickstra 7y ago> why these issues weren't raised when the spectrum was being allocated Because they are bogus. This is riding on a wave of populism, at a time when journalists woke up to an "Elon's train" and twitter was buzzing with many people who saw a satellite with their naked eye for their first time. Actual professional astronomers would either realize this is not such a big problem, or would raise the issues during the spectrum allocation, or would raise issues during the whole time SpaceX was showing animations of the finished constellation to all their fans etc etc... there was a lot of time, no way somebody whose project depended on free skies wouldn't be prepared.
- odiroot 7y agoNIMBYism has reached the orbit.