4 ms·
>I may be wrong about this (please correct) but I think over 10% of the world's carbon budget is spent on running computers. It's everyone's fault and we all ne
by mrweasel 7y ago
>I may be wrong about this (please correct) but I think over 10% of the world's carbon budget is spent on running computers. It's everyone's fault and we all need to fix this. Don't just blame bitcoin miners.
This part seem much more important, compared to trying to offset plane travel by buying carbon credits.
- ubercow13 7y agoComputers have completely changed the world. Do we all use more carbon or less in total because of that 10% now being used for computing? What did we get for it compared to other uses of carbon?
- rgblambda 7y agoOne way to think of it: Computers enabled massive economic growth, which in turn led to higher carbon emissions. It would be interesting to try to quantify the increase/decrease in carbon emissions due to computing.
- shubhamjain 7y agoComputers can be run by cleaner sources of energy, not planes (at least not with what current technology permits; batteries don't have enough energy density). I prefer plane travel myself, but let's be honest, emissions-wise planes are a horrible way to travel [1]. [1]: https://mobile.twitter.com/shubhamjainco/status/1102449512537251845 https://mobile.twitter.com/shubhamjainco/status/110244951253...
- mrpopo 7y ago> A plane despite transporting hundreds of passengers is less efficient than a fully occupied car. And according to these numbers, a plane is more efficient than a car with 2 occupants. Average vehicle occupancy varies around 1.5 people. It doesn't make the plane a better way to travel, of course. It just shows that individual cars need to be proscribed just as much as airplanes.
- dan-robertson 7y agoComparing planes to cars is slightly silly. One cannot drive across the Atlantic and it’s quite possible to fly much farther in a year than drive. Flying e.g. 6k miles is reasonably easy to do in a year. I think it is easy to not think about the impact as it all happens in a few gos. Driving 6k miles takes a long time and would be felt more acutely. It is easier to switch to cleaner forms of energy for this travel and one may be more inclined to reduce this energy usage as it is also a huge time sink.
- michaelt 7y agoA round trip from New York to Paris is ~7300 miles. A commute of 40 miles per day is ~9600 miles per year. I'd wager there are more people who commute 30 minutes each way by car than there are who go on an annual holiday to Europe :) Of course, reducing either would be a good thing.
- magduf 7y ago>A commute of 40 miles per day is ~9600 miles per year. That's a somewhat short commute by modern American standards too. Honestly, we'd all be better off if we stopped driving to work and made our cities denser and used trains to get around, had more/better train service between nearby cities, and then took annual holidays in Europe on Airbus A380 aircraft that were configured with only economy seating (700+ passengers per plane).
- pessimizer 7y agoThe difference in difficulty of redesigning all cities, remaking public transportation, and locating all workers near their workplaces or figuring out a way they can telecommute, as opposed to skipping the annual holiday to Europe, is vast.
- magduf 7y agoWell it's never going to happen if you just throw up your hands and say "it's impossible". How about starting right now, by raising gas taxes and changing zoning regulations and encouraging denser development?
- SkyBelow 7y agoDepends upon how you measure it. The image impact of flying to climate change conferences is likely far worse than the image impact of using a computer. This can sway opinion enough to change elections and to change the priorities of politicians.
- rwallace 7y agoIt seems wildly improbable. Where did that number come from? I don't believe it's anywhere near that high.