6 ms·
You can basically say that anyone living 500 years ago would say "there is zero chance" that what we take for granted today exists at all. Look at the technolog
by ekianjo 7y ago
You can basically say that anyone living 500 years ago would say "there is zero chance" that what we take for granted today exists at all. Look at the technological achievements of even the past 50 years, most of it could hardly be predicted.
- ohazi 7y agoThere's a pretty big difference between the statements: "We are likely to have life extending and resuscitation technologies in 500 years that are better than what we have today." and "The dead rich people in these particular vats of antifreeze have any more than a snowball's chance in hell at being successfully resuscitated." I think the parent's analysis is correct. Your statements, while also correct, don't really refute the issues pointed out by the parent.
- garmaine 7y agoIt didn't point out any issues... it just made the unsubstantiated claim that a cryonics patient has no chance of ever being revived. It IS physically possible to revive cryonics patients--as in the laws of physics would permit it, even if we don't have anything near the technology required, yet. This isn't a bold claim but rather a statement of fact with respect to information preservation of the vitrification process, and long-term storage at cryogenic temperatures, both of which are well studied in the context of things like organ donor preservation. So if you're claiming that cryonics has "a snowball's chance in hell" of working, then I presume that either you are (1) ignorant of the science, or (2) making some sort of statement about long-term storage prospects or the credibility of the organizations involved. But neither you nor the grandparent actually made any specific claims.
- daeken 7y ago> So if you're claiming that cryonics has "a snowball's chance in hell" of working, then I presume that either you are (1) ignorant of the science, or (2) making some sort of statement about long-term storage prospects or the credibility of the organizations involved. I'm signed up to be a cryonics patient when I die, but yeah, the chances are pretty much nil. Personally, I'll take a slightly diminished bank account and a potentially non-zero percent chance of further life over a zero percent chance, but I won't delude myself into thinking that there's effectively any chance of success here.
- mehrdadn 7y agoWhat I don't understand about this logic is, how do you have any confidence that if by some miracle you were brought back to conscious life again, your life wouldn't be an absolute living hell (organ damage, paralysis, etc.)? Like even if you had infinite money and resources to spend on whatever you wanted, would that risk be sitll worth it to you?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoYou don't. You can only hope that a) future people won't revive you unless they're somewhat confident it'll leave you better off than you were when frozen, and b) worst comes to worst, they can still euthanize you. Cryonics is ultimately a bet on future technology and future humanity.
- nwatson 7y agoFuture people will use the frozen as a resource. I would buy a 2139-October call option on 100-frozen-hopefuls ... that's when I estimate techniques for revival will be viable and when legal hurdles to mass exploitation will be overcome. In 120 years nobody will care about your intentions in being frozen.
- garmaine 7y ago...why? How could there possibly be utility in a corpsicle when you could much more easily achieve the same thing with AI?
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I would buy a 2139-October call option on 100-frozen-hopefuls. Unless you live inordinately long, you'll only be in a position to benefit from that if you are wrong about it being a worthwhile investment. (But right about the technological enablers—just wrong on the socio/legal issues.)
- chimprich 7y agoIt seems unlikely to me that we'd acquire the ability to revive a brain from death before the state of medical technology advances sufficiently to repair nerve damage or regenerate organs. You could put a kind of guarantee into this by only having your head or brain preserved, so the minimum viable tech level for resurrection would be regrowing a body. I'd be more concerned with the emotional and mental challenges of being revived centuries hence, which would be considerable to say the least.
- jfk13 7y ago> a statement of fact with respect to information preservation of the vitrification process That's not a statement of fact, it's a statement of belief. Personally, I think it's highly unlikely that any current vitrification process preserves sufficient information for the patient to be revived. We're nowhere near even understanding what "sufficient information" would be, let alone how to preserve it.
- hutzlibu 7y agoThe thing is .. it is more about biology than physics. You can flush water pipes with whatever you want and clean and rewater it. A complex organism like the human body - and the brain, we still dont really understand? Not likely. Maybe not 0 chance in SciFi future, but still not likely.
- nradov 7y agoActually it is physically impossible to revive cryonics patients because essential information has been irretrievably lost. I don't think you understand the physics (or biology) here.
- garmaine 7y agoWhat information?
- bduerst 7y agoBy this logic, we don't even need to freeze the body. Simply opt in to being resimulated later, since the technology will exist "some day".
- jerf 7y agoA lot of "cryonically-frozen" people are only their heads, since it's been well-known for a while that there's no way to unfreeze the bodies. I suspect it may literally be easier to scan their brains than to unfreeze them, even if they were healthier to begin with. That's not a statement of my belief in the ease of scanning a brain; it's a statement of my belief in just how hard it is to "thaw" a body and get anything back. I'd say it's like getting handed a pile of slag and told to turn it back into a working engine, except that task is multiple orders of magnitude easier.
- bduerst 7y agoBut that's my point, why even bother freezing the brain, if simply waiting a few centuries more of tech progress will mean you don't even need the brain to be consciously brought back? It's just replacing the faith in one omnipotent's afterlife with another.
- garmaine 7y agoHow would that work? Future technology, no matter how advanced, would still require the information in your brain to simulate you. The point of cronics is to preserve that information.
- bduerst 7y agoJust simulate the entire universe and pluck the brain structure of the person you're trying to bring back into reality. You're missing the point though. These solutions entirely rely on future technology development being the omnipotence that gives you afterlife.
- 7y ago